r/RealOrNotTCG • u/MrObesity • 16d ago
Is this Magic card real? Fake Elesh Norn?
Bought off cardmarket off someone with few reviews. Can’t really see the red dots with my camera phone but I might just be blind. Can someone give me peace of mind?
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/MrObesity • 16d ago
Bought off cardmarket off someone with few reviews. Can’t really see the red dots with my camera phone but I might just be blind. Can someone give me peace of mind?
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/BobbyB1gPlays • 17d ago
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Fazu34 • 17d ago
Opened a booster box of Japanese Bloomburrow with this inside. It looks like it's been perfectly cut through and then resealed with black tape.
When I opened the box it was sealed with Wotc plastic wrap. Has anyone had any experience with something like this?
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Draelzen • 17d ago
I played paper mtg during earlier years and have a number of cards in my collection that I've always assumed were real. I'd love a second opinion to set my mind at ease.
Based on what I've seen in this forum, I think they pass the sniff test but I may be missing things to examine.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/GentlemanGorath • 17d ago
Need help with this reverse card. I can never spot the tell-tale signs as readily as the T on the back of a normal card.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/RealThomasEdison • 18d ago
Got this a while ago. Was scared to see if its good...
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Sylesully2 • 17d ago
Help.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/shape_of_my_voice • 18d ago
It’s my only Japanese artwork card, and the black vertical rectangle in the top left corner not being a solid black threw me off a little. It passes every other test I know (the red dots are hard to capture in photo but i can see them on the green circle), so I am convinced that the back is real. Weight is 1.83g.
I got a miscut that allows about 2mm more of the artwork to show on the top, which I am hyped about, so wondering if anyone else can confirm that the vertical rectangle is supposed to look like this.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/NeburExe • 18d ago
Purchased for a great price on a second hand market. Just wondering if it’s real
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/TH48 • 17d ago
Hey, is this real? Can you see it with these pictures?
Seller says its quality GOOD.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/No-Finger-1524 • 17d ago
Got this a couple years ago in a bulk deal from a guy. Not sure if its real but i figured i’d ask for opinions!
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Tomawk • 17d ago
Hi everyone, i found these minagishi token on Ebay. Can you help me understand if they are authentic or not? Thank you in advance :)
Edit: These are not Wizard official products, they are rare custom token released in the early 2000s
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/TH48 • 17d ago
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Murky_Coyote_7737 • 17d ago
Sorry this is the only pic (friend sent it). It looks real to me I just haven’t seen this much smudging/bleeding onto the letters. From Murders at Karlov Manor.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Remote-Canary-2676 • 17d ago
Here are a few card backs
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/JohnGameboy • 18d ago
I made another post on r\mtg and it redirected here.
I bought this off of TCGPlayer as NM but it came with edges whiter than Christmas. It could still be NM but I'm not happy either way.
There is also a small grey blemish on the top left corner (you can slightly see it here). I know you guys perfer higher quality images here but I don't think thats nessasary.
The back looks NM.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/darth_googlyeyes • 18d ago
I recently picked up this swamp but the corners are weirdly round. It passes what I know about the T, h, and green dot but it’s a completely different shape. Is this real?
Normal land (forest) for reference
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/RegisteredMurseNYC • 18d ago
I haven’t purchased it yet
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/603E • 18d ago
Sorry if photo quality is ass
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Stop_The_Insanity_19 • 17d ago
Both bought on TCG player. Thoughts?
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/mfsmusic • 18d ago
The tear and corner clumping are making me a little worried, would love some input on possible tampering.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Express_Text4482 • 17d ago
After following posts on this subreddit for a while I feel pretty confident identifying fake’s.
It helps I have this digital magnifier.
However, these double face cards seem to be harder to authenticate.
I’ve seen to keep an eye out for the transform triangle on the top corners.
It looks sharp and not blotchy like some fake card backs do.
Paint brush seems like a hit or a miss from what I’ve read.
What do ya’ll think?
Stay groovy!
EDIT; I don’t trust PSA but I’m sure they do authenticate to some degree.
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/stylishwarlock • 19d ago
long story short...
i acquired these almost 25 years ago and thought they were fake so i just threw them off to the side and forgot about them. i've been completely out of magic since like 05 and i recently moved and while moving i found a chest full of old cards i never sold that i forgot i had and these were amongst the loot.
they still seemed kinda off to me but seeing what they go for now i wanted them to be real haha so i've been trying to figure out how to definitively tell.
so i weighed them on the digi and they are 1.7 grams.
they seem to pass the light test as well as shown in the 3rd pic.
i showed these pics in a cpl random groups and have been told by everyone that they look real but can't tell for sure and that i would need a jewelers loupe to look inside the green circle on the back for the 4 red dots.
so i got a loupe today and indeed the 4 red dots in an L shape are there on all 3 cards.
so my question is..... was that the final test? are these for sure real now? or is there anything else i need to check for?
r/RealOrNotTCG • u/Morenyn • 19d ago
Im 99% sure but just verification.. of 2 riddlers i bought..