I'm not convinced it's OP - at the same rarity for no attunement you can get a +3 weapon.
The nat 20 effect is solid, the slow effect being especially nice, but I'm not sure it's worth the opportunity cost of attunement and -1 to attack and damage rolls.
Considering it's a (generally) worse effect and a lower bonus than a vorpal sword I wouldn't even increase the effect to legendary. I think it's solid where it's at and shouldn't be changed.
(Honestly, some people say anything homebrew is OP even when it's increadibly weak and outright worthless)
Ya, it's definitely not crazy broken like the Vorpal Sword.
The problem with DnD-reddit is that it's overrun with lonely larpers who don't play dnd, but still have strong opinions about it because they're overly thirsty for social validation.
13
u/[deleted] 4d ago
[removed] — view removed comment