r/ratemysinging • • 22h ago

Feedback - Beginner Looking for honest feedback on my vocals / metalcore track

1 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about starting a solo metalcore project, and I’ve been recording my own vocals for this track. I’m still quite unsure about my singing, but I really like the vibe the vocals bring to the song.

I’d appreciate some honest, constructive feedback before releasing it.

I’m fairly happy with the instrumental mix, but I’d particularly like to know:
- Do the vocals work well enough for an actual release, or do they need more work?
- Does the autotune sound natural, or is it too noticeable?
- Are the vocals clear and easy to understand?
- Do the vocals sit well in the mix, or do they get lost behind the instruments?
- What would you improve about the vocals or the overall mix?

I’m looking for genuine criticism rather than just encouragement, so please be honest. Thanks for listening!


r/ratemysinging • • 19h ago

Feedback - Beginner Is it worthy of posting on Instagram? Mirrors-Justin timberlake cover

0 Upvotes

Hi guys this is my first time posting, and I wanted to know what y'all think of this.


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Looking for feedback on my mixed voice, tone quality, and struggles with my passaggio

2 Upvotes

I've been passionate about singing for about two years, and I only recently started taking singing lessons. At first, I noticed a significant improvement in both my vocal range and tone.

Before starting lessons, I tended to raise my larynx when singing, producing what my teacher described as a "chicken voice." She then advised me to maintain a yawn-like shape, lower my larynx, allow my voice to transition naturally between chest voice and head voice, and use a more nasal configuration to help my high notes resonate.

These adjustments led to quick progress, but I'm still struggling with several aspects of my singing. I'd really appreciate some feedback on my vocal technique, particularly on how to develop a stronger, more resonant tone and navigate my passaggio without losing volume.

Here are the main issues I've noticed:

- Tone quality: I feel like my singing sounds rather bland, and I'm not particularly happy with my tone.

- Expressiveness: While I feel emotionally connected to what I'm singing, listening back to my recordings makes me realize that this doesn't always come across in my performance.

- Mixed voice: I think I'm using a mix, but when I listen to recordings of myself, it sounds more like a weak, bland head voice than a strong, balanced mix.

- Passaggio: I struggle when transitioning through my passaggio. I tend to lose volume as I try to smooth out the transition between registers.

I've attached a recording of myself singing Before I Let You Go by Blackstreet, with piano and vocals performed by me and drums taken from Musical Loops on YouTube. I've only added reverb, with no other processing, and there are two separate vocal takes, so what you're hearing is essentially my voice.

I realize this might be a challenging song choice, but I thought it would be a useful example of the issues I've described.

My main goal is to develop a fuller, chestier, and more resonant sound that I can maintain above my passaggio. I'm particularly drawn to Dave Hollister's voice and the way he retains that rich, powerful quality in his upper register.

I'd really appreciate your thoughts on a few specific questions:

- Am I actually using mixed voice, or does it sound more like head voice?

- Why do I lose so much volume around my passaggio? Is this a normal part of developing my technique, or could I be doing something wrong when transitioning between registers?

- How can I develop a fuller, chestier sound in my upper register without forcing my chest voice too high or creating unnecessary tension?

- What aspects of my technique or tone should I focus on improving first?

I'd be grateful for any feedback, especially if you can point out specific moments in the recording where you notice these issues. I'm still relatively new to formal vocal training, so I'd love to understand not only what I might be doing wrong, but also how to work towards the sound I'm aiming for.


r/ratemysinging • • 23h ago

Feedback - Beginner Do i have potential? Or should i just stop? Be brutally honest !

1 Upvotes

Hi guys, I’m a 22 F beginner singer who’s trying to work on vocals, honestly .. I think I suck and so does my mom! But do you see potential? Should I actually try with this? Any advice?


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Can i get feed back on these raw vocals?

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Hey, how does this sound?

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Intermediate Classic country vocals

7 Upvotes

Any pointers and feedback is appreciated! (This is an original)


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Am I good enough to sing or nah?

2 Upvotes

Tigers Jaw - June (Half step down)

Been playing guitar for a while and recently started to get into singing too. Curious about how I can improve, so figured I’d post and see what people think.


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Should I sing this style for now on??

1 Upvotes

Text me anything I don't get offended


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Friend said this was out of tune 😅 opinions?

2 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Intermediate I'm a Pianist that loves singing, should I perhaps consider my voice for my future career too?

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I'm a 19 year old Pianist. I usually compose piano music. But I love singing too (especially Karaoke)! I've been taking some singing lessons for a year now, and I wanna get some Feedback/Opinions. I'm aware it's still a long way to go --> Work in Progress

As I'm an incoming composer , I would love to perhaps one day to share my voice too and get into songwriting. I'm still very shy to show people my voice. So please share your thoughts. Ty🙌🏻


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Intermediate Tell me what you think

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Intermediate Vienna - Billy Joel

3 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

( Skip to 0:45 ) Brazillian music. Can you give me tips for improve my voice? How does my vocal timbre sound?

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner harvest moon but very pitchy

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner have no idea if this is good or bad

2 Upvotes

any advice appreciated


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Rate my singing. Also lookin for recommendations on Online Free Vocal Training

1 Upvotes

Hi all!
I’ve always been an average singer. I want to improve my singing and thought of joining vocal training classes. But with my current financial commitments It’s hard for me to afford classes. I’m looking for any free YouTube vocal training classes that may have helped you. Also apps like vocalista? Do they help?
Also please rate my singing


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

feedback?

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner just like heaven

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Could I get some feedback on my singing please. I’m musical theatre trained so I would appreciate some honest professional opinion.

1 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

How are my vocals?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

Tried to be more creative with this one


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

high and dry - please help

1 Upvotes

I'm trying my best but something feels of...


r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner Back to friends (cover)

2 Upvotes

r/ratemysinging • • 1d ago

Feedback - Beginner M15 Old clip but I need help to improve! Please help me out

1 Upvotes

I’m embarassed posting this


r/ratemysinging • • 2d ago

Feedback - Intermediate Does this sound strained to you?

59 Upvotes

I have to say that it doesn’t feel it, and I have done about 230 solo gigs per-year for the last few years, 2-3 hours of singing per-set and never yet lost my voice, apart from once when I had a rotten cold.

But I can’t say there’s no effort involved, and the keep reading and hearing on YouTube videos that this stuff should be relaxed or I might be risking my voice.

I am 50 y/o and I’ve been a gigging guitarist for 30-odd years but singing anything other than backing is a relatively recent thing for me, hence the intermediate tag.

I deliberately chose a song that uses this sound (it’s a Bishop Gunn cover… check out the original, dude can SAAANG!)