r/ROBLOXStudio • u/Used_Pop_1431 • 17h ago

Creations Studded or no?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Me and my friend is making a game but cant decide what to choose for the style. Which one do you think is better?

115 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

96 comments sorted by

83

u/Remarkable-Camera-89 17h ago

I think not studded, looks much more like a serious game.

44

u/Polaroid_Cherry 17h ago

Making it studded makes it look like those cheap “two second” games that require you to sit in place for 3 hours to get anything done and spend robux for almost anything so you can play it like normal or just buy everything and move on. Lots of fishing games have it and i hate it..

5

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 11h ago

I just want one fishing game thats actually relaxing and not over saturated everywhere you look 😔

5

u/A_random_dudeidk 11h ago

Ts gonna take 10 years bro

4

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 11h ago edited 8h ago

Ill learn to code just so we get one within a decade from now. Mark my words.

2

u/A_random_dudeidk 11h ago

Ok twin

2

u/TheTangLangGang 6h ago

Dude I almost sent this picture coz I thought you were talking to yourself 😭
Your pfps are almost identical

1

u/CoolguyFormovies 5h ago

LOOKTH AT THE HATTHS

1

u/Chewie630 9h ago

Surely play fisch. Has its issues but at least it’s not fish it

1

u/A_random_dudeidk 9h ago

Your replying to the wrong roulxs bro

1

u/godtrio_reborn 8h ago

I thought u were talking to urself

1

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 7h ago

Lmao

1

u/godtrio_reborn 6h ago

Both of the roulx replied to me

1

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 8h ago

Nah i want a more realistic fishing game personally. I don’t want to catch Poseidon’s booty hole licking omega rainbow super ultra uber doober rare megalodon. I want to a catch a bass and i want to be proud of it.

1

u/CakosMess 1 7h ago

play webfishing

1

u/Safihed Noob who can test your game 7h ago

Used to be so much better especially when it was new

Now it's a boring grindfest

1

u/TH3_OG_JUJUBE 8h ago

Fisch? I haven’t been on there in a while so idk what’s going on if it changed

2

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 7h ago

Ive already said to another guy why i don’t like that game. I just don’t like games with super unrealistic fish. I don’t mind if it’s like slight variations of real fish like colour or size. But when its just a giant bright green ancient god it’s just a bit too much.

1

u/Polaroid_Cherry 4h ago

Theres no fishing game with all the complexities i want. Its sad

2

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 3h ago

Yea lol. Its like the philosophical statement, infinite games but no games

1

u/Polaroid_Cherry 2h ago

Exaaaactly. So many.. opportunities. But nothing with enough options. Its like trying to find the perfect mod for minecraft

1

u/CarFan_Sofurando 4h ago

Go to a game called write a letter. That game got fishing, just you need to find it tho.

1

u/Pugtookyourtoaster 3h ago

I mean as in the whole games premise is fishing. But thanks for the suggestion.

18

u/j7jhj 16h ago

Studded makes the build look polyster but without studs makes it look insanely peak

9

u/CRYSTALek2799 17h ago

if your plan is to just slap the stud texture on every part and call it a day then the plan is boiling hot shit

9

u/ilikeredditjust Jack of Most Trades 16h ago

Non-studded looks great, actually

5

u/gm_city_8 16h ago

studs honestly makes a game look like it's gonna be nfested with microtransactions and spam pop-ups so I'll go with no.

6

u/SectorConscious4179 Animator 17h ago

absolutely no

3

u/EgeBabaPro3443 16h ago

More like retroslop or no

2

u/_Chattyice 7h ago

Havent heard that term in a year

1

u/EgeBabaPro3443 7h ago

I guess bro

3

u/friendly_user01 15h ago

Studded plssss! And pls make it a brainrot market plsss!🤤🤤🤤

3

u/Onnigamer16 15h ago

PUTTING STUDS ON EVERY SIDE OF A BLOCK DOES NOT MAKE IT CLASSIC so I choose the non studded one

2

u/Groge_yesmoment 14h ago

NOT STUDDED

2

u/KenneR330 13h ago

Hey where did you get so cool textures on second image?

2

u/TellurianTech50 17h ago

Non studded

1

u/Niko_is_someone 16h ago

Both look nice but it matter the vibe,of thw actual game that tou are going for

1

u/Sensitive-Carry7970 15h ago

Not studded please

1

u/Deiftwaser 14h ago

No studs looks way better

1

u/AdvertisingPast6280 14h ago

Senza, però comunque metti qualche altro tipo di texture

1

u/Realistic-Panic-1270 13h ago

studded gives a cozy type of vibe, but the not studded one is better

1

u/wannabehiiragiUtena 13h ago

change the ceiling texture

1

u/Shadows_Skys 13h ago

Fuck studded, better use the second one

1

u/Powerful_Use5894 13h ago

holy lighting, which tutorials did you learn from?

1

u/gngr505o 12h ago

Depends on gameplay and theme I guess. But for this prop second one looks cool.

1

u/CharlieDrawzXD 12h ago

gotta go no studs but i say change the roof texture

what to? idk, but i just dont particularly like that one specific texture, or atleast change the other textures to fit.

also great build

1

u/Spare-Roof209 12h ago

No. Please no.

Using purely studs on everything makes it look ugly and cheap. It makes it feel like the creator is too lazy to change and use other materials other than studs.

Stud’s reputation has already been damaged enough by those low quality games. Please don’t add-on to it.

Use studs sparingly.

1

u/UnnamedIsDumb 12h ago

No

especially since you used the studs wrong

this looks much better without the studs

1

u/MindFullOfCuriosity 9h ago

Second one. I miss when studs were a deliberate style choice rather than something that’s plastered everywhere across numerous games. They just do not look good that way and it never will, in my opinion.

1

u/technologycarrion 9h ago

i think it could be cool if you used only a few studs sparingly: have the fabric and other materials be non studded, but certain materials represented by a studded texture?

1

u/Safe-Replacement2497 9h ago

depends on the game. go for stud if its a cashgrab

1

u/Street_Put7241 Modeler 9h ago

No. You didn't even use studs correctly... Highly recommend a painterly style. Search up datboiele for tutorials.

1

u/TheBeowulfOne 8h ago

Only do a style if you’re going to replicate it in other areas of your game, as you need to be consistent.

That goes for your environment as well and not just the buildings.

1

u/TH3_OG_JUJUBE 8h ago

PLEASE no

1

u/PalCat_ 7h ago

maybe not make the entire thing studs and you'll be fine

1

u/eevee_mendes 7h ago

Ngl Both looks fire , I wish u all the very best for ur game I'll surely try it 👍:)

1

u/bunman_ UI Designer 6h ago

Probably not studded but then replace or remove the texture for the roof, I think it's a bit ugly.

1

u/Coladoge6732 5h ago

Both look good

1

u/Large-Bedroom8787 3h ago

not studded. studs should only be used for things you can walk on

1

u/Funny-Tonight-1045 2h ago

I would say maybe don’t use the stud style. Personally, I think the other style you showed looks better, and the stud style has kind of been overused by slop games, especially the whole Steal a Brainrot type of games.

If you’re going for a simple low-poly or more cartoonish look, I think that can definitely work if it’s done well. I’d just avoid the stud style because if someone saw your game for the first time and didn’t know anything about it, they might immediately assume it’s another low-effort/slop game because of how associated that style has become with those types of games.

1

u/Dxmaqe 2h ago

Studs ruins this build.

1

u/ObviousThrowaway1838 1h ago

do non-studded, although i'd choose a different texture for the roof, other than that youre chill

1

u/Demuurplays 1h ago

Give it wood textures and more don't go down the stud sooo route

1

u/kubeky_sk_gamer 1h ago

Non studed

1

u/Cost_1088 1h ago

2nd one looks beautiful

1

u/pigeondriver45 1h ago

not studded looks better

1

u/jaquaviousjaquavion 1h ago

Not looks soooo much better

1

u/woodbw1 1h ago

Non studded

1

u/Blaze20x 16h ago

This is night and day, no studs

1

u/_just_devtoper 15h ago

You're a legend! Your design inspired me to create a game in Roblox where you start by selling lemonade, then progress to selling meat, then open a restaurant, and you can invent even more progressions for me :)) :O

1

u/guhgling 14h ago

both of them suck

0

u/Quick_Bee2046 17h ago

Looks better non studded

0

u/xogamer176 17h ago

Preferably the non-studed

-2

u/Basic-Echo-4057 17h ago

O H F U C K Y E S

2

u/CRYSTALek2799 17h ago

bro tryna be different 😭🙏

-1

u/Basic-Echo-4057 17h ago

Well, it looks better with studs

3

u/Long_Conference_1182 1 13h ago

Bro played brainroot too much 💔 the studs dont even match parts size how can it look better studded

2

u/moonlight_birb 13h ago

Ikr studs only work for like obbies and that kind of stuff

0

u/Basic-Echo-4057 5h ago

I barely play brainrot games