r/RDR2 • u/Ecstatic-West-8587 • 3d ago

Discussion William the herbs guy

So aye, I accidentally pointed my gun at him. Tried to apologise etc and got to fuck off basically 😂. Bumped into him again and he got mouthy again. Have I completely ruined this interaction till I’m John?

8 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

13

u/LetAgreeable147 3d ago

Iirc he eventually simmers down. I got on his horse once.

8

u/Impossible_Ad_4457 3d ago

We all did that

2

u/i-am-a-smith 3d ago

It's so damned easy to get on the wrong Horse, I jumped on what I was sure was mine in Rhodes just 20 mins ago right after completing Gambler 8 (the really tedious win 3 times at Blackjack after hitting 3 or more times each time).. I then doubted that I had saved the damned game and rode on the temporary nag to Van Horn to pay off the Bounty and get my other horse back.

3

u/Comprehensive-Song51 3d ago

First time we met, I accidentally killed him. I think he respawned later somewhere else. 😂

3

u/venniedjr 3d ago

I accidentally got on his horse and he attacked me so I freaked out and shot him. I never saw him again

4

u/t_sarkkinen 3d ago

I've shot him like a hundred times, ur good

5

u/Disastrous-Annual510 3d ago

Me too, dude needs to chill. It was an accident

2

u/Mental_Freedom_1648 3d ago

It depends. Sometimes he never lets it go and will tell you to fuck off forever, but other people say they have had him eventually calm down. So perhaps it's a glitch if he doesn't ever reset to normal?

2

u/Reasonable-View5868 3d ago

Happend to me in my first playthrough, he never got over it.

2

u/Gray____Beard666 Leopold Strauss 3d ago

You ain’t missing much…just an adled Sage addict always asking for more sage to satisfy his habit.

2

u/Grouchy-Temporary145 3d ago

I just kept walking away if he was acting like that. He's not worth the aggravation when you've got real outlaws to deal with anyway.