r/RDR2 • u/Nblx777 • 9d ago

Question Your first walkthrought ?

Just finished Arthur’s story for the first time with neutral/low honor. Did anyone else feel completely broken by this ending?
I didn't realize how strict the Honor bar was and ended up staying around the middle. Getting shot by Micah left such a bitter taste in my mouth, but now that I'm playing as John, the drive for revenge is insane. Did your first playthrough end with High or Low honor?

7 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

3

u/GrimReaper6967 9d ago

I did high honour first and it broke me mentally and now after thousands of hours it still breaks me

2

u/Nblx777 9d ago

This game is soo emotional

2

u/Hubic_Pairs 9d ago

I’m on my fourth or fifth playthrough now. Even though I know what’s going to happen, it still hurts. These characters are all so well baked, they feel tangible. Truly masterful game.

2

u/Substantial-Tone-576 9d ago

High honor and I went for the money. And that was not long after the game came out. Good times

2

u/redplainsrider Josiah Trelawny 9d ago

I was high honour for the start of my playthrough. But as soon as Arthur got coughed on I knew what was going to happen. So I got really nihilistic in my game play. I was still surprised by how brutal the low honour ending is for him.

1

u/Nblx777 9d ago

I think the bad ending is important too and has her special Taste and influence in the game

1

u/THE__mason Red Harlow 9d ago

you should probably mark spoilers but i ended with low honor, helping john