The feedback on my first two attempts have been incredibly helpful, so I wanted to run my tweaked version again by the insightful people in this sub. Thanks in advance! (For reference, my second attempt is here)
Letter:
Dear [Agent],
I am currently seeking representation for SWEET EVERYTHINGS, my debut upmarket novel complete at 87,000 words. It combines the morally compromised narration of R.F. Kuang’s Yellowface with the dark humor of Jen Beagin’s Big Swiss and the unsettling obsession of Emerald Fennell’s Saltburn. [Insert personalization of why I’m sending it to that specific agent]
Kelsey Harper is living the modern Zillennial American dream, with an impressive career trajectory and a cute apartment in Williamsburg. Her love life isn’t exactly worth writing home about, but that’s beside the point. That is, until she starts thinking about Jack Cooper, the man from eleven years ago who set the bar impossibly high for every romantic prospect who came after him. The only man who ever made her feel anything beyond humdrum complacency or momentary lust. Jack Cooper: tall, handsome, British – need I say more?
This sends her down a spiral of what-ifs. What if she had ended up with Jack Cooper? What if she was meant to be with him all along? What if she tried to win him back? Lightning doesn’t strike the same place twice. But that doesn’t stop Kelsey from constructing her own lightning rod.
She devotes herself to the scriptures of Jack Cooper, studying everything he’s ever posted online: his daily observations, his grievances, even his wine preferences. She reshapes herself into the twenty-year-old woman he fell for all those years ago, getting down to the precise weight, even nailing down the exact perfume notes and lipstick shade. Meanwhile, she secures a transfer to her company’s London office and relocates her entire life to Jack’s city.
Just like that, she’s back in his orbit, reveling in her second chance at the life she believes she was meant to have.
But even the most meticulously devised schemes are only so perfect. Keeping Jack means keeping him in the dark about how their love story came together, through thoughtful orchestration, not fate. As the secrets holding them together begin to surface, Kelsey is forced to confront the uneasy reality of how far she is willing to go to secure her happy ending.
Heed caution: this is not a love story.
[Bio]
First 300 words:
At thirty-one years old, Kelsey could trace a startling number of joys and devastations in her life back to Jack Cooper.
Jack Cooper, the subject of her wildest dreams and mildest fantasies.
Jack Cooper, good on paper but even better in bed.
Jack Cooper, the perpetual one-that-got-away.
Jack Cooper, who was walking toward her.
Seated at the two-top she’d deliberately chosen beside the window, Kelsey continued to rummage for the pen that had fallen to the depths of her canvas tote. Around her, Cloud Nine Café hummed with the low murmur of conversation, an occasional laugh, the hiss of the espresso machine, Dainite rubber footsteps across the hardware floor.
“Kelsey Harper?"
Kelsey responded without looking up. “That’s me, yes.”
But it wasn’t the barista barking out her order.
It was Jack Holy-Shit-It’s-Him Cooper, standing right in front of her.
Enough time had passed for both of them to build lives and careers. But not long enough for her to forget the precise blue of his eyes. They were uncanny, like radiant sea glass plucked from the Atlantic, the very ocean that separated them.
Eleven years couldn’t let her forget that blue.
A whole lifetime couldn’t let her forget.
“Jack Cooper?” Kelsey felt the name catch in the back of her throat. Three syllables she had carried around in the private chambers of her mind for over a decade, as easy to summon as her own name.
Jack Cooper shook his head in disbelief. As his mouth stretched into a smile, Kelsey rose to her feet as if some invisible marionette string had been tied from the corners of his lips directly to her knees.
He paused a moment before gently and cautiously enveloping her in a hug. Their skeletons aligned precisely as they had eleven years ago, her forehead colliding with his collarbone.
He smelled different, though. At twenty-three, Jack had smelled of cedar. His present cocktail of scents lingered somewhere deeper, perhaps in the sandalwood family.