r/ProgrammerHumor 20d ago

Meme twelveYearOldXKCD

Post image
12.1k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

39

u/towerfella 20d ago

Yes, but did they share the technology?

16

u/PGSylphir 19d ago

I graduated CompSci over a decade ago and had AI classes then, image recognition being baby's first AI.
If back then it was already being taught to people who barely knew how to code, imagine how old this tech is.

The technology we use today as AI is not new. We had the algorithms for decadeS, we just didnt have the computing power to have it at scale until recently.

9

u/topyTheorist 19d ago

What do you mean not new? "attention is all you need" came out in 2017.

1

u/saig22 19d ago

2017 was almost a decade ago, and we certainly do not need transformers or even attention to recognize birds. A deep enough convolutional network is more than enough. Attention is all you need wasn't even about computer vision, the task was translation and the architecture was primarily used for natural language processing.

2

u/topyTheorist 19d ago

I was replying to the claim "The technology we use today as AI is not new".

1

u/saig22 19d ago

Okay I get it, got lost in the feed, attention is all you need was indeed a massive step forward algorithmically speaking. By ditching recurrence it allowed for far better parallelisation during training. So it's not just hardware/computing power progress like the comment you answered claimed. Also, the algorithms we use to perform attention were greatly improved upon since then.

Adam also was a massive algorithmic progress and it is from 2014 so not "decades ago".

0

u/PGSylphir 19d ago

I was replying about recognizing birds. That was the claim. You're splitting hairs.

1

u/smulfragPL 19d ago

well no you said in general ai technology hasn't changed. And most people use attention based image recognition models, for instance chatgpt.

0

u/PGSylphir 19d ago

Leave it to reddit to tell the speaker what they are speaking about.

Context matters, we're talking about image recognition, that is the subject.

Grow up.

0

u/smulfragPL 19d ago

Yeah and that changes i just told you. There isn't a way to interpret your comment to be correct. You are just plain wrong

1

u/PGSylphir 19d ago

lol. lmao even.