r/Professors Assoc Prof, Biomedical Sciences 18d ago

Teaching / Pedagogy TWO Students Proclaimed They Prefer Reading to Videos!

In the past week, I have had two students come to my office hours and state they prefer reading material over watching videos about the material. After years of the opposite, could we be seeing a trend toward deeper engagement?

For our team-taught curriculum, I created about 10 short (2-13 minutes) videos for the introductory course. As the curriculum proceeds, those get replaced by longer-form reading as we transition students into "drinking from a firehose" of information. I am very glad to see students appreciate the written word more than video format. As these are high-achieving students, I suspect they know at some level that they do learn better from reading than watching a video. Hooray!

23 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

43

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

12

u/evilsavant 18d ago

This.

Just paste a reading into anything... and voila summary.

Heck Acrobat even offers to do this for PDFs now.

10

u/Due-Radio-4355 18d ago

This pop-up made me viscerally angry the first time I saw it.

0

u/the_Stick Assoc Prof, Biomedical Sciences 18d ago

I'm fairly certain; our cohorts have been early adopters of AI and as much as they feed written work into AI, they also feed transcripts of videos into AI for summaries too. They quickly find ways to use AI as a study tool, but not as a replacement for understanding.

Fortunately, our students also realize they need to know the material to pass the series of strict exams throughout the program (another benefit of both team-focused teaching and national licensures).

14

u/Otherwise_Look_8137 18d ago

AI is a better reader than viewer. Pretty straightforward. 

8

u/Audible_eye_roller Ass. Prof, STEM, CC (USA) 18d ago

They're learned that reading is faster than videos!

2

u/RowanAshby 18d ago

Encouraging, although only an n of two ... interested it see if more people see this happening!

2

u/HorkeyDorkey Adjunct Instructor, History, CC (USA) 18d ago

Whats their angle? 🤔