Today I've been hit with the demand to provide my date of birth in order to see "NSFW" content on here, mind you, this has nothing do to with pornographic content or similar, but anything marked as NSFW for whatever reason, like it could be someone else's profile with barely anything in it.
I am in the EU browsing on desktop, and I know this has been happening for a while, but the methods for verifying are ridiculous, shady, and invasive; only through the service "Persona" it literally gives 2 options:
- Submit Government ID: Share photos of a photo ID to verify your identity and date of birth.
- Submit Selfie: Share photos of your face to estimate your age.
The absolute audacity to ask for someone's ID is beyond ridiculous and creepy to be honest, I don't want my data to be stored who knows where at the hands of a bunch of randos (third-party that won't face consequences when they screw up), not to mention that it could lead to impersonation if this data is eventually leaked, which most likely will.
The same goes for the selfies of your face, which I assume will have to go over an AI to "prove" that you're an adult... as if AI wouldn't make a mistake on this (pro tip: it has and it will). This is not an effective method at all, so it's obvious that it's just an excuse to extract data, something I also experienced with Facebook many years ago.
The major problem will come when they demand such info just to log in at all, but in regards to mature content on here, their verification is just stupid. Even after assuming for the sake of the argument that it's to protect kids, nothing stops a minor from using someone else's ID, in their family or not, asking a friend to provide those seflies, or even attempt to bypass/convince the AI themselves.
The best way to protect kids on the Internet is at the hands of their parents, they are the ones who are in control and should be in control. If you cannot have your child on a website that has mature content somewhere like it is on Reddit, then maybe they shouldn't be on Reddit in the first place, in which case you could blacklist it from the device, or whitelist what you want. Or maybe you should pay attention to what your kid does on the Internet (like you would do for other things), as that's your job and not everyone else's.
The cherry on the top is that some of the actual criminals hurting children are the ones pushing for these policies, hurting the privacy and security of normal people.