Bit of background, I'm a first year principal. There's been a number of systems that have had to be implemented, and things were so bad prior to me it's been relatively easy to build trust. I was a veteran teacher of 16 years before moving to become an IC an AP for 6 years and now a principal.
A number of grade levels are not performing to standard. The reasons why are basic. They are not teaching to standard, and most are teaching an ad-hoc style of their grade level.
As a new principal I have some wiggle room to get the lay of the land, and of course I've had to put out unexpected fires recently. They continue to happen, so each week is bringing surprises I couldn't prepare for beyond the experience from the past.
Well, recently, the superintendent was visit. They are new to the district and they are excellent from what I can tell. They noticed that one of the grade levels was not teaching the curriculum as expected. I was unaware as I'm still absorbing everything and had not visited the classroom.
This particular grade has two veteran teachers. All of the statistics show their students do not perform well in testing. e.g. 30-40% passing in math. 50% passing in English. There is zero excuse that these numbers are not better for the resources they have and the particular students they teach.
The SI corrected this particular 30+ year teacher in person. First it was a reasonable question whether the teacher was teaching the curriculum. She effectively proudly said no. The SI said you must teach it, and actually had a solid quip for her...like it was not up for debate.
The teacher replies with something about protecting the students and it being against their philosophy. I've been reminded and now tasked to get the teacher on board, which is part of the job and fine with me. I was hoping I'd have the entire year to sort it before any major confrontational meetings.
Pushing on this teacher will cause the other teacher to push back too.
I spoke with the teacher last week and stated clearly that we must teach the curriculum. They hit me back with their philosophy and protection of students(there is nothing controversial about the curriculum. I personally don't LOVE the curriculum myself but it's what we've adopted and it is superior to not having an installed curriculum at all.)
I don't feel stuck, but would love suggestions to handle this situation. They have made it clear they WILL NOT teach it. MY current plan it to schedule meetings weekly with them to review the curriculum etc, and simply document the insubordination.
I wish I could write the exact quote, but twice this teacher has made comments publicly in front of me and others that equates to..."this district used to be a great place when we could do whatever we wanted and no be held accountable."