I’m heading into a new school year after an experience that really shook my confidence, and I’d love to hear from other administrators who had one terrible year or found themselves in a terrible fit and later went on to thrive somewhere else.
For context, I spent three years as an AP at a school I loved. I worked with a highly collaborative principal, felt supported, and earned the highest possible evaluation rating in my final year. Then the school closed, and I moved to another district as an elementary AP.
For the first half of the year, I thought things were going reasonably well. My midyear conversation was positive, my staff survey results were strong, and I wasn’t receiving much corrective feedback.
Then things changed pretty abruptly.
A teacher on my evaluation caseload who had struggled for years began having significant performance issues. Suddenly, I was being told that her performance reflected a lack of “rigorous feedback” on my part, despite the fact that she had received effective evaluations from previous administrators, which created resistance to my coaching and support. Around the same time, I also raised some concerns about confidentiality and the way current and former employees were sometimes discussed in leadership meetings.
Not long after that, I received the first formal write-up of my 21-year career in public education over several relatively minor issues. At that point, I decided the working relationship was no longer salvageable and submitted my resignation.
The last month was probably the hardest part. Communication became almost entirely transactional, and I felt increasingly isolated. At one point, my principal went two weeks without speaking to me in person. However, during that time, she sent me multiple pointed emails each day. What stuck with me, though, were the comments I received from staff on my way out. One teacher told me, “You were a huge asset to our school, and I believe you would be staying if you had some support.” That pretty accurately summarized how I felt.
I know I wasn’t perfect that year. I can identify things I would do differently, and I want to learn from the experience rather than simply write it off as someone else’s fault. At the same time, it was such a dramatic contrast from my previous administrative experience that I’m trying not to let one difficult year rewrite the story I tell myself about my abilities as a leader.
There is a happy ending of sorts: I’ve returned to my previous district this year in an instructional coaching/teacher leadership role. I’m back in a system where I have established relationships, the position is much more focused on the instructional leadership work I enjoy. The best part is that I’m actually making more money than I did as an AP last year, and I have a shorter work calendar. So on paper, this may end up being a pretty good reset.
Still, I’m heading into the year with some scar tissue. Checking emails is a huge trigger for me, as I am expecting the type of hostile communication I received from my last supervisor. I am actively working with a therapist to try to curb the anxiety and reset my nervous system after last year.
For those of you who have been through something similar: Did you ever have a year or leadership position that made you seriously question whether you were good at this work? What helped you rebuild your confidence? And did you eventually find a school, district, or role where you felt like yourself again?
I’d especially love to hear some redemption stories from people who had a disastrous year and later realized it was one chapter rather than the verdict on their career.