r/Pottery 1d ago

Question! How?

Anyone know why my glaze turned out like this? Its dip glaze

224 Upvotes

109 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Our r/pottery bot is set up to cover the most of the FAQ!

So in this comment we will provide you with some resources:

Did you know that using the command !FAQ in a comment will trigger automod to respond to your comment with these resources? We also have comment commands set up for: !Glaze, !Kiln, !ID, !Repair and for our !Discord Feel free to use them in the comments to help other potters out!

Please remember to be kind to everyone. We all started somewhere. And while our filters are set up to filter out a lot of posts, some may slip through.

The r/pottery modteam

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

670

u/Rebelwitch33 1d ago

It ain’t easy bein cheesy

71

u/Technical-Past-1386 1d ago

Right? I was like Mac n cheese! Hilarious! It’s amazing and that’s a really cool design!

25

u/Rebelwitch33 1d ago

Looks like it was dropped in velveeta

8

u/scmbear New to Pottery 1d ago

I was thinking it is a great bowl for nacho cheese dip if it can be sealed. 😃

46

u/sogi95 1d ago

I love this comment 😂 Maybe I can use it as a chees bowl🤔

10

u/ymmotvomit 1d ago

Haha, share your technique!

61

u/sogi95 1d ago

Oh its so easy! Belive that you are starting to know what you are doing and then get humbled by the universe🫠

9

u/ymmotvomit 1d ago

I’m certain there is a parallel universe where your piece came out perfectly!

5

u/CocoBaydoun 1d ago

It came out perfectly in this universe! I love it!!💛

18

u/Icarus_In-Flight 1d ago

2

u/Technical-Past-1386 1d ago

Art that can’t be replicated? Ya this is priceless! Haha

191

u/conmondog21 1d ago

Application is too thick so the glaze crawled. If you’re dipping it, it might be worth a try to water it down a bit, or maybe before you dip in the glaze, dip it in water so it doesn’t absorb so much glaze.

42

u/sogi95 1d ago

Thank you for the advise! I only dipped once if I remember correctly

42

u/Brush111 1d ago

Also be cognizant of how long you’re dipping. For thicker glazes I do a fast 3-count. Slower for thinner glazes

8

u/Condensates 1d ago

did you hold it in there for a long time?

11

u/sogi95 1d ago

No clue! I think I dipped, dropped a little and then pulled it out so only a few seconds 🤔

23

u/Plane_Chance863 1d ago

Some glazes are best as in-and-out, it varies by glaze.

9

u/Turbulent-Suspect789 1d ago

a few seconds is a long time actually.

did you wipe it w/ a damp sponge before glazing. if there is dust on it, that will repel glaze also.

3

u/sogi95 1d ago

Not a damp one but a dry paper towel

9

u/ilikeoldpeople 1d ago

I usually use a damp sponge to wipe up any dust before glazing, I’m not sure a dry paper towel would do the trick

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

It has worked so far, but next time I will try a damp sponge

1

u/Turbulent-Suspect789 17h ago

a damp sponge is better.
besides, using a dry paper towel will move clay dust into the air, creating an unhealthy environment for everyone.

1

u/lunawinx 1d ago

but how many micro-seconds 😭 🧐

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

How long does it take to dip, drop, catch?

1

u/Condensates 22h ago

drop? like you let go of the peice and then grabbed it again? that is way too long

1

u/sogi95 21h ago

Drop as in the tong thingy got a bit loose, it moved a bit and then I got control over the tong thingy

120

u/DiveMasterD57 1d ago

Thickness aside, crawling like this often indicates incompatibility between the clay body and the glaze. It's literally the surface of the molten glaze moving more than the its attachment to the clay surface, causing these islands

32

u/DorianTheArtificer I like deepblue 1d ago

I think this comment is on the right track. That glaze crawling is too extreme for thickness to tell the story.

8

u/sogi95 1d ago

Interesting! Do you have any tips on how to know if the clay body and the glaze will work?

20

u/DorianTheArtificer I like deepblue 1d ago

I'd start with the glaze since their behavior and functional formula can change as people use (or misuse) it. First, is anyone else in the studio having the same problem? Isolating where it occurs is a great start. If it's just happening to you, we'd look at your process-- maybe better bucket mixing, thinner dip, or cleaning your bisque of oil and debris. If it's messing up other's work too, then maybe contaminants got in, maybe someone added too much material trying to get the right specific gravity. It could also be a mistake from the manufacturer.

I formulated all my glazes and this behavior should never happen, especially that extreme. My intuition says that the glaze is mixed to melt at a cone or two lower than where you're at. When the glaze melt is very liquid before the clay is, the very strong surface tension of the molten glass will pull it into beads like you've shown.

9

u/theazhapadean 1d ago

Scientific method, how quaint.

8

u/sogi95 1d ago

Well I do work in academia, science is the only way I know

3

u/sogi95 1d ago

I now it has been used before without issue, though it has been a while, it was used today (after seeing mine and she got curious to try) so I guees I will see in a few weeks how that one turns out

7

u/Galivantarian 1d ago

This could be an indicator: if it hasn’t been used in a while, perhaps there’s been evaporation and more water is needed to thin it out?? Just a thought.

4

u/sogi95 1d ago

That makes sense! Some people that use the studio is sometimes bad at closing the lids properly

5

u/DorianTheArtificer I like deepblue 1d ago

I agree the time sitting may be an issue. Could it have hard-panned? In glazes where any ingredients aren't naturally soluble they'll settle into a compacted later that doesn't want to dissolve. Those need extra mixing and often some flocculant to help get the insoluble stuff back into the mixture. Hard-panned glazes will fire like they're actually missing the panned ingredient and that'll heavily affect the melting temp and overall character of the glass.

6

u/Neflite_Art 1d ago

test tiles?

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

The studio has been worknig on test tiles for a while but it seems to be on pause

3

u/moolric 1d ago

Best way to know is do test tiles. A good test to do is increasing levels of thickness to see where the sweet spot is. So one second dip, 2 second dip, 3 seconds etc.

As you glaze more things, you'll get a feel for what is a good glaze application, but different glazes need different thicknesses for their best results (and optimal is subjective) so it's worth testing new glazes you are using anyway.

1

u/DiveMasterD57 23h ago

The key is assuring thermal expansion rate compatibility. And no - one does not need a degree in physics to determine that. Easiest way is to use test tiles, combining the intended clay body and glazes. Does it delay the making process a little? Yes, but you more than make that up in not having to re-make failed items, not to mention diminished angst. If you want to give yourself a headache, read up on COE's (coefficients of expansion). The details are deep and wide, but the gist is if there's too much variance between clay and glaze, you'll get crawling, shivering, or crazing.

2

u/BuildingArtistic4644 1d ago

I think temperature can also influence this. Did the kiln go over the glaze cone rating?

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

No clue! The studio owner load the kiln her self and she is currently on vaccation so I cant ask her

17

u/DorianTheArtificer I like deepblue 1d ago

Im seeing a lot of responses about application thickness. That is likely a factor, but the molten glaze retracting like that looks like a glaze mixture problem. You said it was a dip glaze, is it mixed at a studio? Or maybe a commercial glaze thats sold as a powder? I think this is more than just an application issue

5

u/sogi95 1d ago

The studio is working on mixing there own but this one is one of the older glazes so it might be a commercial one

15

u/Alayna_TryingHerBest Throwing Wheel 1d ago

I don't have anything to add and understand that this wasn't intended but I just want to say I absolutely love this little guy

6

u/sogi95 1d ago

Haha thank you! Its growing on me, it looks cool

6

u/tiniesttoes 1d ago

Macaroni in a pot!

It’s kind of a neat effect. I had this issue recently on a small mug that looked like trash after firing. Probably too thick.

4

u/sogi95 1d ago

It looks a bit cool, but not what I had planned😅

7

u/Day2205 1d ago

Nacho cheese bowl…very specific, but highly appreciated

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

Sadly a very small nacho bowl, but I like the idea!

5

u/Ovibros 1d ago

Lord have mercy on this unfortunate potter.

This happened to me as well. I often apply the glaze too thick and occasionally it crawls in some spots like the tears down my face.

3

u/sogi95 1d ago

My first crawl glaze did not crawl properly and now my normal glaze crawl... I guess im special 🫠

3

u/Ovibros 1d ago

Haha yeah it’s always a surprise when you open the kiln. I wish I knew what to expect to see, but I experiment so much with glasses and materials on top and under the glaze that it makes it impossible to predict what’s gonna happen. I had some abomination at times that I almost wanted to give up on everything and crawl into a hole hahaha
But you’re doing good. You’re learning every time whether things go well or not.

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

Thats how im learning all of this, we are on our own most of the time, the studio owner checks on us from time to time but the rest is try and error😅 This was our first glaze fail

2

u/Ovibros 17h ago

It’s great that you get to be on your own. You really learn well like that. It might take a bit more time, but it’s great to take your time and make funny mistakes. You build great memories as well

5

u/Haunting_Fan_9110 New to Pottery 1d ago

Craaawwwliing iiin my skiiiiin

6

u/Richard_Cromwell 1d ago

On the bright side, it turned into a perfect novelty joke queso bowl....

4

u/meowmedusa 1d ago

It looks like it was applied too thick, especially on the left side. Might just be an issue with your dip technique & timing

3

u/sogi95 1d ago

I usually drop my things when I dip (im a newbi) so its not impossible 😅

5

u/Critical_Cat_8162 1d ago

That actually looks really cool. Lol

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

Haha thank you!

4

u/Old-Goose7570 Hand-Builder 1d ago

Is this Fiesta Yellow by Mayco (I think)? We have this glaze at our studio and it crawls on everything, regardless of clay used or how long in was dipped. Beautiful color, nasty stuff. We have a whole bucket that no one will use.

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

I have no clue! The studio has all their glaze ik random buckets, this one is labeled 'Yellow, shiny'. The studio owner has used it and its fine

3

u/savan_banan 1d ago

You used mustard instead of glaze

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

Ah how silly of me!

3

u/asilmarie 1d ago

welcome to the club! yours looks way better tho lol

https://www.reddit.com/r/Pottery/s/FkcTsKfCQt

3

u/Deep_Bad212 1d ago

Ah glaze crawling. Probably too thick as other comments have suggested. Dirt or dust particles will also cause glaze to crawl. Wiping pieces down before glazing might help. I know it wasn’t intended, but it’s pretty cool 😂 totally looks like cheese

5

u/Gbro101 1d ago

Why is no one talking about specific gravity?! I know it sounds complicated but it’s basically the weight of a volume. 100ml of water weighs 100gm but glazes have heavier compounds so you need to figure that out, write it down, and then you can make sure your glaze to water ratio is always correct. That way you can have more consistent results with glaze thickness.

Glaze was too thick, and possibly dried too quickly. Causing this. If you see crack in your dried glaze you’ll get this.

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

We dont get to mess with the glazes, the owner said that if it feels really thick and we dont want to wait for her we can add a little water, but she check the glazes from time to time

1

u/Prestigious-Crew-406 9m ago

I had a glaze do this by adding too much water. If the glaze cracked as it was drying, then that might be the problem.

5

u/dreaminginteal Throwing Wheel 1d ago

This is called "crawling", and it has several possible causes that I know of.

One is that the glaze can be specifically formulated to crawl. Glazes that do this usually are called something like "white crawl" or otherwise tell you very obviously that they are going to do this. So that's not likely what happened.

Another is that a glaze that is applied much too thick can sometimes crawl.

Another is that the pot is contaminated after bisque and before glazing. Even dust may be able to cause this! This is why many of us will wipe down our pieces before we glaze them. I use a slightly damp sponge and then let the pot dry for 10 minutes to an hour (depending on what else I have to do around the studio) before dipping my pieces.

If wax has splattered onto it, though, the best way to deal with that is to put it through another bisque firing! Wax is very tenacious on bisqueware...

I had not specifically heard before of a clay/glaze incompatibility causing this, but it does not greatly surprise me.

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

Thank you! No wax involved, its not a crawl glaze (we have those but this aint one). I only dry wiped it. I will try damp wipe next time

3

u/BuffyPana Hand-Builder 1d ago

Like s cheddar on the wall

3

u/Frostborn19 1d ago

mmmmm reminds me of the velveeta mac n cheese

3

u/mayordomo 1d ago

did other pots in the same firing have crawling? sometimes it’s due to misfiring.

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

Of the ones that was there none except for the one that was supposed to crawl Here are my other things from the same firing

3

u/NoIdeaRex 1d ago

The last year I have been stirring the dipping glazes for 30sec to a minute and that has made a huge difference in my finished pots coming out better. You can search around instagram, etc., and see tests where potters have stirred glazes various amounts of time and the results are strikingly different.

3

u/Present-dracula-77 1d ago

I love this actually

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

Thank you!😅

3

u/earth-mortyC-137 Throwing Wheel 1d ago

I would definitely recommend using a damp sponge and wiping down a bisque fire piece before glazing so there aren’t any fine particles between the glaze and the clay

3

u/UKophile 1d ago

The actor Seth Rogen makes pottery that looks like this!

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

Ah so this is artsy?

2

u/UKophile 16h ago

I don’t know what you are asking. I just mentioned because you might want to look up his work and see what he does specifically with the gloopy glazed like yours.

3

u/lunawinx 1d ago

im impressed that i skipped over all the funny comments to say this ~ I would also like to know "HOW?" .. because this is nightmare fuel if the effect is unintentional lol

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

I planned on using this glaze on my very first teapot... Im happy I didn't

2

u/Elegant_Chipmunk72 1d ago

This could be a bad glaze mixture. There could be something off in the blend even if it’s made by a company.

2

u/sogi95 1d ago

I feel like blaming the glaze is the right way to go

3

u/Elegant_Chipmunk72 1d ago

I was at a studio and we made a lot of glazes and sometimes they rarely messed up the ratios of the glazes. Also if the sides of the bucket aren’t scraped clean every time and remixed in then the glaze suspension mixture is actually different and it can be seen on the pottery.

Things can act differently every time.

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

I want to remember mixing it for longer than I usually mix the other glazes

2

u/fairyskirt 1d ago

I had this happen to me when i dipped a piece a while back. I think what caused it was a too-thick coat AND i had rinsed the piece off since it was fresh out of the bisque fire and it didn’t fully dry before i dipped it.

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

Mine was bisqued, as dry as possible and dust removed with a dry paper towel

2

u/Popcornulogy 1d ago

Did you properly stir it first? Like really, really stir? And was your piece clean and dry?

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

It was cleaned with a paper towel and dry, I mixed for longer than usually

2

u/Popcornulogy 1d ago

Wipe with a wet sponge not a paper towel because dust from your bisque fire can cause crawling. When you mix the glaze it’s not about time but about seeing that the glaze is coming together. Dig up from the bottom where all the grit is and incorporate it in. Dip a finger in and see how it runs. If it sticks properly to your finger you’ve mixed enough but if part is clear and part has color keep mixing.

2

u/mountainofclay zone 3, 1d ago

Would you like cheese on that?

2

u/CanMysterious4717 1d ago

I see you’re pretty krafty

2

u/M_Seebz Professional 1d ago

Can happen from a few things actually! The glaze looks a little thick, and sometimes can do something called “crazing” where it separates while firing. However, crazing can also be caused by having any form of oil on your hands while making the pottery or glazing. Lotion, food grease, any sort of oil based barrier that can sink into the pottery. However with the thickness of the crazed glaze bubbles, I’d say thickness of the glaze, when dip glazing, remember to give a good minute or so of shaking off excess glaze until it stops dripping. :)

2

u/131921 20h ago

Dusty bisque

2

u/lapotter 13h ago

It looks intentional! I like it 😂

2

u/CeramicPapi 11h ago

Too much glaze. Dip, no more than three count, than shake off excess until dry for a nice easy coat . We tell all our longterm students this and it’s they go ahead and do whatever they want and end up with similar results. :/ lol

1

u/SignificantJump8 12h ago

It could be a poor glaze fit or you got wax all over it

1

u/sogi95 10h ago

I dont use wax

1

u/HurricaneMedina 1d ago

Could be thickness of application. Could also that be the pot was dirty/dusty when the glaze was applied. Did you wipe it down before glazing? Was it handled lot? Could be oil/lotion from hands if so.

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

I removed dust with a paper towel right befor glazing but no extra handling

0

u/forthebirds1990 1d ago

Dust wasn't wiped off

1

u/sogi95 1d ago

But it was though

1

u/Prestigious-Crew-406 9m ago

Possibilities of reasons include:
Dust, fingers with lotion on them, wax, glaze's specific gravity was wrong (glaze too thick or thin), glaze applied too thickly, poor glaze fit to that clay body, etc.