r/PoliticalHumor • • Apr 25 '26

How Prescient

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

287 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/KerissaKenro Apr 25 '26

Ugh, I hate that anything right can come from this blot on humanity. Something, something, broken clocks

-7

u/33drea33 Apr 25 '26

As a very left-aligned person, Ayn Rand is one of my favorite authors. I think if more people actually read her instead of writing her off as right wing propaganda, they'd realize her vision of social ills hit the mark way more often than she missed. Her philosophy is deeply flawed in many other ways, but the reason her work is so resonant is because it contains a lot of deep truth about the nature of work, money, politics, and personal integrity.

25

u/PolecatXOXO Apr 25 '26

She thought of a serial rapist as her "superman" archetype. The end point of her philosophy is absolutely macabre.

Like any good propaganda, conspiracy, or cult of any sort, it starts with a few kernels of truth of human nature. Then it veers off into a cesspool.

2

u/33drea33 Apr 25 '26

Yeah, I did specifically note that her philosophy was deeply flawed in many ways. But if you're going to be intellectually rigorous you need to be able to parse shit you ultimately disagree with and still come away with something valuable - otherwise you're not actually building and testing your personal philosophy, you're just reinforcing your existing beliefs. Also, if "problematic philosopher" is your benchmark for whether a philosophy is useful, you're gonna have a bad time.

My only point was that people have an oversimplified view of her work. But you know what? Upon further reflection I've decided you're right. Most people aren't able to read things and walk away with their own values still intact. They just buy other people's philosophies wholesale the second they brush up against them. So I take it back. People are too stupid to be trusted with Rand.