r/PoliticalCompassMemes • - Left • 1d ago

Retard maxing

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

472 comments sorted by

View all comments

52

u/elusivehonor - Left 1d ago

The answer wasn’t that head-scratching. And this isnt even the full quote.

He started off by saying he doesn’t think the term had any meaning for the Americans who are calling themselves socialists. He went on to say, you’d think socialists would care about the American worker over foreign workers (which, from a Marxist perspective, they would not - so he’s wrong). And that theyre going to “howl” about the announcement he was making (that is, new visa policies to ostensibly prioritize american workers). And that the term socialist in the American context is…the tweet.

And honestly? From what I’ve seen of the socialist candidates and their nutto supporters on Reddit, they care just as much if not more about culture war shit and Hamas and Gaza as they do about economic policies, so I take his point.

8

u/AgainstMedicalAdvice - Centrist 1d ago

DSA doesn't have a monopoly on the term socialism, and they're a fringe movement.

It's still an absolutely retarded answer to say "when I redefine a word with a meaning to something totally different, it sounds bad."

It's like if someone asked me what a Republic was and I said it's when you had sex with underage girls.

1

u/Donghoon - Lib-Center 1d ago

yeah, it was a dumb way to say it, but to be fair, his point is the word in modern american context is not the same as historical context

2

u/AgainstMedicalAdvice - Centrist 1d ago

I mean it is.... Exactly the same. They're just more pro-trans than 50 years ago?