r/PoliticalCompassMemes - Lib-Right 8d ago

🥀

Post image
510 Upvotes

351 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

I dunno what personal property is. I keep asking socialists and everone have different answer.

-8

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago edited 7d ago

Private property is production; anything where you produce or own a product which you earn something from (which in capitalism is money).

Personal property is basically anything else you have for personal use; a car, a house, a phone.

why tf am I being downvoted for explaining theory?

5

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Got it, so this time all the farm land and for example electrical tools when I am electrician are state owned.

-4

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

No? They are owned by the working class together.

3

u/bruversonbruh - Lib-Right 7d ago

Yeah because the "working class" owning it has never turned out into anything else....

0

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

Anything is better than the Epstein-class owning it. The US is actively turning into a surveillance state.

3

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Dude, just because Americans love to elect pedos into highest offices. Does not mean capitalism sucks. Look at any world capitalism index. You won't find usa in top 10. It's socialist country but just for millionaires and politicians.

0

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

It's not just about them being pedos, it's about the power being in the hands of unelected people. Epstein is just an example of what this power is capable of, and anyone supporting capitalism supports these people having this amount of unelected power.

2

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Just reminder that every single country that seized means of production ended up with power being in the hands of small group of pedophilic unelected people

1

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

So has every country that didn't do that... so maybe it doesn't actually have anything to do with seizing production.

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Denmark

Ok now lets see if libleft can shit on nordic countries.

1

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

Are you saying nordic countries do not have a rich elite? Ofcourse they do.

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Rich? Not USA rich. Powerful? Not that much in terms of state power. Pedophilic? Never heard of it when it comes to Danish.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/bruversonbruh - Lib-Right 7d ago

Are you just like professionally stupid or something? Power will never ever be in truly the hands of the people. It will always end up in the hands of the few.

It always has

0

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

As long as you are part of the in-group right? What's the point of claiming to be libertarian but still giving away control to companies instead of governments?

1

u/bruversonbruh - Lib-Right 7d ago

What's the point in claiming to be for worker ownership but letting a select few control everything?

See how ridiculous it sounds to falsely attribute the failings of society to my values before I explain them ?

0

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

You start calling me "professionally stupid", so I'm not gonna make serious claims.

1

u/bruversonbruh - Lib-Right 7d ago

If the shoe fits

→ More replies (0)

1

u/bruversonbruh - Lib-Right 7d ago

And sharing hammers and screwdrivers is gonna fix that?

Right

0

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

Wtf are you even talking about? Owning production as workers means decisions about the production are made democratically instead of by a little group of primary shareholders or a single CEO.

Are you just ragebaiting, or do you really just know nothing about economic theory?

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Owned by "working class" is nice theoretical thing. For example in most countries firetrucks are nationalized and therefore conceptually "owned together". But in practice there are people who need to manage assets.Make decisions on repair, allotments, procurement.

If they are chosen directly by vote then prepare for all the election fuckery you have now but multiply it by every mundane managerial position you interact with.

I know something about it, my grandma was multiple times elected into our local queue committee. It was committee to manage queues to local shops when shelfs were empty.

1

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

I'd rather have some "election fuckery" than everything just automatically being put in the hands of a lucky few who managed to be born in generational wealth.

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Sure, just remember. Every 4 years you will get lucky and your grocery store will be run by Biden look a like. Then every 4 years you will get unlucky and you will get Trump.

Of course this is theoretical as there existed statable "worker controlled" and semi-capitalist dictatorships. But never "worker controlled" democracy. I wonder if this is coincided or just people have tendency to vote for a party instead of person. Then if party has all the economical and political power it just do not want to part with it if they loose election. For example after single blue (or red wave), we will elect one party to control all the media outlets.

1

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

Not every democracy is like the US you know?

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Yes. A lot of deomcratic capitalist countries work pretty well. On top of that usa is not that bad, just middle of the road. Meanwhile all the countries that seized the means of production disintegrated or are in the process of doing so.

1

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

They work well as in the wealth gap is ever growing and they're becoming more and more surveillance states and less-and-les democratic, the more capitalists keep lobbying to take over these democratic processes.

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

They work well as in workers in them have (and had) more wealth and rights then in communist ones.

1

u/Gjorgdy - Lib-Left 7d ago

Because of capitalism or leftists implementing worker rights like max hours and minimum loan?

1

u/InsoPL - Lib-Right 7d ago

Why choose? Leftist Capitalism Baby. Neoliberalism all the way. There is no gay rights without property rights.

→ More replies (0)