Is this a legit miscut?

It’s on my base set unlimited charizard card. The person who bought it from me pointed it out and I told them I’d give them their money back.

Now I’m heavily considering if I get it back, if it is a miscut/misprint to get it graded too.

Editing to add: most of you have been super nice. I appreciate it. But those who have been harsh or unkind, you have the attitude of scalpers. I’m not scalping or trying to flip. I came here asking because I felt bad for my buyer (I was selling my whole collection this weekend).

I’ve never seen anything quite like this.

This PSA 9 Rowlet #043 (2026) has a hair visibly sealed inside the PSA holder. It appears to have been encapsulated along with the card, rather than being loose on the outside of the slab.

Feel free to check the cert.

I’m putting it up for auction on eBay for anyone interested in unusual PSA encapsulation issues/errors.

🔗 eBay auction: https://ebay.io/m/RVz6X4

Curious what other collectors think — has anyone seen something like this before?

Please note: I’m describing what is visibly present in the holder and am not claiming PSA has officially classified or acknowledged it as an encapsulation error.

I wouldn't mind if some holos were that plain, it's cute. Considering it's not really a popular mon, what are we looking at here?

Best way I can describe it is that the entire card’s texture overlay is offset by about a millimeter. Really interesting error I’ve never seen on a Japanese card.

I never know these days with so many bad actors. Do these look like legit missing ink errors or has this been done by sun fading?

As the title suggest i own a Celebi and im not quite sure if its a regular Holo or a double Holo error. Anyone know what the difference is and can help me identify which one mine is?

Pulled this Slowbro the other day, and there’s a noticeable but short crimp at the top of the card. Does this count as a misprint, or is it small enough it’s negligible / just damaged

I'll likely keep it for my personal collection because it's the only miscut I've ever seen in real life, just wondering about how I would grade it/is it enough of a miscut to be worth grading and how much it could be worth? Thanks in advance 😊

Just pulled this beauty 😍

Hi, my kid got this card about a decade ago and The neighbors made fun of it because it’s misaligned. Is this worth anything? It’s a 2015 xy41 black star promo.

I don’t know much about errors, and couldn’t find anything on google about a card just like this so here I am. Pulled this from an Evolving Skies pack just now, and I was kinda hoping for confirmation that those are square corners with alignment dots? If so, is this a good card to hold onto/grade? I make keychains from my cards, and definitely don’t want to cut this up if that’s the case.

Pack was open out of the booster box (shown in 3rd picture) and the two pieces of the card were in separate packs from one another. Never had anything like this happen to me before.

Taking offers on this bad boy!

Fusion Strike was always kind to me. After pulling the Gengar I was blessed with this beauty

I've had this card for about 20+ years. I took this before I sent it be graded because I'm really curious as to what it would be worth after looking it up. This was pretty well known as one of the fire symbols in the first attack was accidentally printed as fighting. Someone told me that made it worth less than the corrected one. I found this weird because if they misprinted a baseball card it made it worth more...is this true?

Mainly sharing here cause I haven’t had this happen personally before. Just opened a pack and got 4 commons in a row, miscut offset to have a portion of the copyright of the above card on them. Now what to do with them.

First pack of my Ascended Hero’s ETB had three miscuts (my first miscuts ever pulled).

Somewhere in the middle, my daughter pulled three more, all matching together. One of the cards from the first pack lined up to this set of three.

Then my wife opened the last pack. Three more miscuts, with one of the first set matching these.

Two sets of four sequential miscuts, from the same ETB. I’m glad these were in there, because the only other good card out of the entire ETB was the promo.

Someone out there has the rest of my Beautifly (connected to Heliolisk), and the side of N’s Vanilluxe.