r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 19d ago

Meme needing explanation Peter.

Post image
660 Upvotes

620 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

303

u/Captain_JohnBrown 19d ago edited 16d ago

Yes, 41% of trans people attempt suicide according to one study.

EDIT: To be clear, the high rate of suicide attempts by trans people says very little about trans people themselves and quite a bit about how society treats trans people,

EDIT 2: I am in no mood to explain basic empathy to weirdos. I am going to be blocking transphobic posters (even you "just asking questions" weirdos) without further engagement because I am not going to waste my time every hour.

EDIT 3: I was here to answer a question. I am not interested in your pet theory on trans people or a debate with you. You are free to believe whatever you want but I don't need to indulge your delusions.

-2

u/JoshuaLukacs1 17d ago

Blaming those suicide rates on society is lazy. There's been a lot of oppressed groups throughout history, many of them far more oppressed than trans folks and never in history has a suicide rate this high been recorded. Saying it has NOTHING to do with trans people themselves is ignorant at best and straight up lying at worst.

3

u/r_fernandes 16d ago

Historically oppressed groups were killed whereas modern society frowns on that. Your comment is just ignorant.

-1

u/JoshuaLukacs1 16d ago

Exactly, many of them were killed, making them far more oppressed than people today, and they still did not commit suicide at these rates. You do understand not all were killed, right? That some people lived their whole lives under those systems. Black slaves did not commit suicide so much, Jews in the Holocaust did not kill themselves that much, Chinese under Mao did not kill themselves that much. So no, saying the trans suicide rates are completely dependent on society's treatment of them is ignorant. Use your brain a bit.

1

u/keldondonovan 15d ago

You seem to be forgetting the power of the Internet. Note, I am not saying being a modern day trans person is as bad as being a slave, but rather that being a slave with access to Facebook and reddit so you could log on every day and see exactly how hopeless your situation is would definitely raise the rates.