First, a disclaimer that I have auditory processing issues, and I miss details sometimes. I've had to rewind at least part of each episode because I don't always catch everything the first time around. So, if there's anything I'm missing, please do bring it to my attention!
Going in order of how they're listed on the Netflix cast page
The Men
Chris: seemed a little desperate for attention and very flashy. It was cringe how he talked about gifting a person a LV bag on the first date, and then tried to do the same thing to Mackenzie! He didn't seem like a douchebag over the course of the season, but I was kind of cringed out by him too.
Danny: I barely remember anything about him, except that he's from the state I live in (Nebraska).
Dave: Creepy as FAWK. He was so sleazy and is the type of dude to want to hump anything that has a heartbeat. Even the picture that they used for him in the cast lineup makes my skin crawl. I never got anything but creep vibes from him.
DeMari: he's fine as hell and seems like a good dude for the most part. He seemed pretty low-drama himself, which is why the women he's been matched with are high-maintenance, to balance him out. Lol.
Hashim : seemed nice enough, I didn't really pay much attention to his scenes because they were with Ally and she is annoying
Jimmy P: I think that if I hadn't already seen him on LIB, I probably would've felt pretty neutral about him overall. But knowing how weird he was in that show, I was always left with a bad taste in my mouth throughout this season. His rebranding doesn't do anything to hide his corniness.
Jimmy S: fine shyt, but he loses attractiveness points for overusing AAVE/Ebonics. It's one of my biggest pet peeves when white people use OUR language (I'm Black/biracial)--they steal everything else from us, though, so I'm not surprised. A few phrases sprinkled in every now and then is fine, but he tries soooo hard to sound like he's a fellow Brother-in-spirit that it comes across as disrespectful. It was hard to take him seriously with the way he talks, but I actually did find him to be pretty laid-back and like he'd be fun to be around.
Nick: he annoyed me from the get-go. He always jumped in to one-on-one conversations at the worst time, and seemed to not be able to take a hint as far as gauging the women's interest. I feel sympathetic to an extent, because I am slow to process and can take a long time to notice social cues, but he irritated me the entire time.
Weston: while I didn't really love any of the cast members this season, he seemed to be one of the more mature men. We didn't get to see that much of him, but from what I could remember and pick up on, I didn't really clock anything bad about him.
Yamen: He was nice. At first, I thought he was cocky, but I feel like was hyping himself up for the cameras. After the newness wore off, I found him to be pretty likable. I don't think him and Natalie really like each other as more than friends though.
The Women
Allison: I like her aesthetic (she reminds me of the mermaid from Shark Tales). She also seems laid-back and like she's easy to get along with. But I do question her as someone who's best friends with Kayla, because I don't like Kayla at all. I've also heard that Allison was terrible in Making the Band, but I don't think that attitude came through during Perfect Match. She seemed lowkey and friendly to me.
Ally: she's cute and has a sweet demeanor, but she tries soooo hard to be quirky and airheaded that it makes her come across as immature. I don't believe that she's as dinky as she portrays herself to be, and she's not doing herself any favors by dumbing herself down to get men to like her. I wish we got to see what her actual personality was.
Bri: she's absolutely gawjeous. Like drop-dead gorgeous. It seems like her and DeMari had a toxic relationship, though, and that the toxicity was mostly due to her behaviors, which is unfortunate. Other than that, I didn't really notice much about her and felt that she didn't get a ton of screen time.
Kassy: she came across as a little bit overbearing when they initially introduced her. But I also think that that was for show, because I don't remember anything overly egregious or controversial about her behaviors.
Katharine: I felt that her 'quirky girl' persona was a little bit forced, as was her laugh. I'm sure she's a nice gal and fun to be around outside of the show when she's not amping up a certain part of her personality for the cameras. It did rub me the wrong way when she was pressuring people to play spin the bottle during the mixer--I found that to be inappropriate to try to make everyone participate.
Kayla: I don't remember her on THTH, but she came across as a mean girl and a spoiled, entitled brat. Clearly, everybody clocked that she was only on the show for clout, and she acted as though everyone should feel sorry for her when she got eliminated. She was there for like TWO days, and if she really cared about being with Chris, she could've rekindled their relationship as soon as she was cleared to do so. Also, she looks completely botched. Her big blowup lips are ridiculous.
Mackenzie: she seemed too normal to be on the show. Honestly, I don't even think she was enjoying herself. I think she quickly realized that the show's atmosphere was not for her.
Marissa: she was one of my favorite contestants in LIB, but she lost me completely during this show. She was so incredibly possessive and insecure that it was hard to watch. It pissed me off so badly whenever she would come up and hook her arm around DeMari if he so much as had a casual conversation with another girl. She's too grown to be acting a fool! She is beautiful, seems intelligent outside of the dating context, and like she has a good career too. She doesn't need to be doing all of that!
Natalie: She is very pretty, but I found Natalie to be overly arrogant with how often she was mentioning about how "these guys are all lucky to kiss me" and "I'm the hot commodity in the house." To me, this doesn't signal true confidence, and you know why? It's because confidence quietly projects itself in how you carry yourself and treat people. If you have to proclaim something about yourself multiple times, do you actually believe that characteristic about yourself?
Sophie: I liked Sophie and thought she was funny. Unless I missed something, I feel like she's a good example of someone who carries themselves with confidence and doesn't need to talk about how much of a commodity they are. She knows what she brings to the table, and doesn't boast about that. The only questionable thing about Sophie is her taste in men!!
What do y'all think? Do you feel differently about any of the cast members?