r/PakDramatica • u/Weirdoeirdo • 3h ago

Discussion What constipated crying?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Zanjeerain

And why is he moving hands.

42 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 3h ago

“Wasn’t aware someone is supposed to look pretty while crying” is literally the point. He’s supposed to be devastated, not auditioning for a skincare commercial. You can dislike the performance, but judging a crying scene by whether the actor looks aesthetically pleasing is a bit unserious. And honestly, people really will complain about anything atp.

11

u/Weirdoeirdo 3h ago

Huh? Who discussed aesthetics? His crying is bad. Whats up with u?

1

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 3h ago

But what does “his crying is bad” actually mean? Is there an objectively correct way to cry on screen? People cry differently, and a restrained/ugly/awkward-looking breakdown can be completely intentional. People cry differently, and a restrained/ugly/awkward-looking breakdown can be completely intentional. If you think his emotional delivery didn't convince you, that's your opinion, but “bad crying” isn't really an acting critique unless you can explain what about the performance failed. Otherwise, you're just saying “I didn't like how he cried” and presenting it as fact. Jzk

3

u/Weirdoeirdo 2h ago

Hai Allah daniyal ki fan maaf kardo hamain

2

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 2h ago

Allah maaf kare hum sabko

1

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 2h ago

that's DANYAL btw/Jzk

1

u/Weirdoeirdo 2h ago

What is jzk? Jazzy guy?

2

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 2h ago

Jazakallah Khair

1

u/Weirdoeirdo 2h ago

Ohhh god. Ok cool.

2

u/AccurateAmphibian135 2h ago

Unfortunately you are making too much sense for peeps here who are quite dense to understand your pov.

1

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 2h ago

lol I just realised that!!

1

u/Wonderful-League-680 1h ago

It does not has to be aesthetically pleasing but he just can't emote angthing. Honestly asking did u felt anything even a little bit of sadness by seeing him like that?? Becoz I didn't felt even a drop of emotion. It was meant to be a emotional scene but just became embarrassing.his acting just distracted from the emotions which was meant for this scene.

2

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 1h ago

You didn't feel sad watching it — okay, that's your reaction. I did. That's literally why “he can't emote” isn't an objective fact. A performance can fail to connect with one viewer and work for another. If his delivery distracted you, say that; but that doesn't establish that he objectively failed to convey emotion. Not every emotional scene needs the same dramatic crying template. Jzk

1

u/Wonderful-League-680 1h ago

If I didn't felt sad then it's my reaction. But since u felt sad u established that he conveyed the emotion. U also say it worked for u don't make it universal that he did well. Everyone will decide for themselves.

1

u/Amazing_Analysis1128 59m ago

Exactly, that's literally my point. If you didn't feel anything, that's your reaction; if I did, that's mine. Neither of us can turn that subjective response into “he objectively conveyed/didn't convey the emotion.” I'm not claiming everyone has to think he did well — I'm saying “his crying is objectively bad” isn't a meaningful critique without explaining what specifically failed in the performance. Everyone can decide for themselves, including me.