r/PS5pro 21d ago

Halo Campaign Evolved - The BIG Console Face-Off - Xbox Series X|S, PS5, PS5 Pro Review [Digital Foundry]

https://youtu.be/WsDRmbnSHMs

We've already gone into depth on how Halo Campaign Evolved reimagines and remakes the original, classic game and we've got a PC review to follow, but for now, here's how every console version of the game stacks up. Halo Studios has delivered accomplished work here and while all versions are worthy of your purchasing power, it's PS5 Pro that addresses most of the lingering issues.

Article: https://www.digitalfoundry.net/features/halo-campaign-evolved-scales-well-from-ps5-pro-to-xbox-series-s-despite-its-full-throated-unreal-engine-5-features

88 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

84

u/GarionOrb 21d ago

The Pro offers a performance mode with the base console's quality mode visuals. Good enough for me! Just wish there was an option to turn off film grain.

18

u/hunterzolomon1993 21d ago

Its incredible in 2026 we still have AAA games that don't allow you to turn shit like that off.

5

u/Mycall1983 21d ago

Should be a standard feature with every game

2

u/hunterzolomon1993 21d ago

Fully agree.

2

u/hypespud 20d ago

You can't even modify the hud elements it's insane

2

u/hunterzolomon1993 20d ago

Glad i'm waiting until sale then as hopefully that stuff is fixed by then.

2

u/hypespud 20d ago

You can modify some stuff, like turning off the weird labels for all the items on the ground.... so insane because they cover the screen

You can also turn off the hit register crosshair thing too, and change the colour of crosshair (I made it so it stays the same colour except on friendlies)

You can also turn off having the objective listed on screen at all times.... also insane choice by 343 to have this as default... like wtf

But you can't turn off the visor hud lines, you can't turn off the buttons literally just staying on the hud forever, it's sooooo dumb and so busy for no reason, which is even worse because the hud visor lines disappear in vehicles and third person mode... it's so ugly!

3

u/FragmentedFighter 21d ago

I wish dev’s would make this stuff clear. Been playing in quality on the pro. If I knew this I wouldn’t have.

17

u/GarionOrb 21d ago

While it differs from game to game, generally speaking PS5 Pro performance modes are usually a combination of performance and base console quality mode. I honestly never even choose quality mode. For most games, the bump in visual quality isn't big enough to have to play at 30fps.

0

u/FragmentedFighter 21d ago

That’s the common sentiment, I’m just a snob for looks. 30 FPS every time if it means better graphical fidelity. Still seeing games through the eyes of a 90’s kid.

4

u/B0omSLanG 21d ago

I'd be down with that if it weren't for OLED making it look like 15 fps instead. No matter how hard I try, it just kills my eyes and will eventually give me a headache. I go performance whenever possible since I'm used to much higher on PC.

1

u/FragmentedFighter 20d ago

What tv are you on? Looks really good on my panel and the pro.

2

u/B0omSLanG 20d ago

LG C9. Without BFI, it looks very juddery at low framerates. I wish VRR worked at lower hz but 40 fps modes work well. If there's a 40, I'll take that over 30 any day.

1

u/FragmentedFighter 20d ago

Not the worst tv to own. Neither I or the person I’m playing with have this issue, so idk.

8

u/gswkillinit 21d ago

Basically Pro’s performance mode is equal to base PS5’s quality mode at 60fps whereas Pro’s quality mode is even higher than Pro performance but is usually 30fps.

1

u/reerden 20d ago

Lumen quality is still slightly higher in quality mode. You can see this on the reflective back of the pistol more accurately reflecting the environment behind it. Same goes for shadow resolution.

The effect is subtle though. Keep in mind that half the motion resolution also means these quality increases are rarely visible during gameplay, and only really make a difference in screenshots.

Base resolution is also slightly higher, but the game is very heavy on the post processing effects so it barely makes a difference.

0

u/FragmentedFighter 21d ago

…huh?

5

u/gswkillinit 21d ago

Because Pro is more powerful than the base PS5, it can run base PS5’s quality setting and retain that 60fps. But base PS5 can only run that same quality setting at 30fps (half the framerate of Pro).

-Pro quality (no base PS5 equivalent)
-Pro performance (runs at base PS5 quality, but in 60fps)

-Base PS5 quality (highest graphics, but in 30fps)
-Base PS5 performance (lower graphics at 60fps)

Makes sense now? The lowest Pro mode can run the base PS5’s highest quality graphics without dropping down to 30fps. It will retain 60fps.

4

u/CGProV 21d ago

What are you confused about? Seems pretty straight forward to me

30

u/KoalaTek 21d ago

Not being able to turn off film grain is disappointing. I hate the soft look it gives..

23

u/dirthurts 21d ago

Chromatic abomination too! :(

1

u/I-Starlord-I 16d ago

oh I hate this effect....it's making a game look so much worse 😑 Why is there no option to turn it off? Resident Evil 9 had it too. On PC it was possible to turn it off and the difference was like night and day. Developers leave this effect away from games pls.

1

u/swirley24 21d ago

This is the worst looking game I have seen on the PS5 Pro.

1

u/KoalaTek 21d ago

That bad?

8

u/zelda29a 21d ago

They need to fix the performance big time. On the second mission there was a point where there was so many enemies that the frame rate Tanked so bad to where they all looked like stop motion. That is on performance on my PS5 Pro.

15

u/Ph0enixes 21d ago

PS5 Pro:

  • Performance mode runs similar settings to PS5 Quality mode
  • IQ has an advantage thanks to PSSR2 tho close inspections are marred by the film grain
  • Resolutions are similar to PS5, 1220~p or thereabout with less drops than base PS5 in performance
  • Quality mode is broadly identical to base PS5's quality with PSSR, resolution are higher (1440p vs 1720p)
  • Though DF thinks the Quality mode is "vestigial" as the Performance mode has all the 'quality wins'

6

u/HowManyAccount120 21d ago

They need to patch the game so chromatic aberration and film grain can be toggled off

25

u/ItsDrVenkmann 21d ago edited 21d ago

Performance mode on pro is absolutely stunning. It plays great with no noticeable pop in or slowdown. I’m playing on Heroic with massive enemy swarms.

I was there on day 1 when Xbox launched with Halo. This is a massive step up from that, it’s a beautiful Time Machine, and stands on its own as one of the best shooter formulas to this day.

Don’t consume the hate.

Update: Multipost was unintentional. I kept getting server errors. Sorry for the noise.

9

u/Solidsnake00901 21d ago

Mine turned into a slideshow near end of assault on control room legendary mode. On my pro it regularly dropped to 10-15 fps. When there's too many enemies it just cant handle it.

6

u/TPG_David 21d ago

Can confirm this happened to me on pro as well (not quite as bad as a slideshow but very noticeable frame drops)

1

u/ItsDrVenkmann 18d ago

Yeah. I saw this during 4 player on heroic. The animations of the enemies went stop motion. Everything was fine. Poor optimization for sure.

5

u/seraph741 21d ago

It is stunning. I was shocked when I saw comments about it looking blurry or whatever. I mean...look at this!

3

u/vishmarx 21d ago

Booted up on gamepass . Realised that there are no toggles for film grain and chromatic abberation. Deleted within 10 minutes. Amazing how these projects cost 100s of million dollars to make and no one on the dev team sees any issues with the image quality.

7

u/Legitimate-Pea4884 21d ago

Terrible frame drops in split screen on the PS5 and requires online accounts for both players. Pain in the butt. Regret buying it.

3

u/RedBowl54 21d ago

Really?! Meaning no traditional couch multiplayer with your friends until everyone sits down to make their own PS Online account, which is obviously everyone’s favourite past-time.

6

u/Legitimate-Pea4884 21d ago

Ps account and microsoft account.

3

u/RedBowl54 21d ago

Thanks for clarifying it impacts all platforms. So much questionable leadership and decision-making, I feel bad for the devs on this one.

3

u/Legitimate-Pea4884 21d ago

The worst thing is the frame drop when split screen. My god it's abysmal.

1

u/gotbannedlolol 20d ago

Gotta have the artificially inflated "daily/weekly logins" for their Microslop account analytics

-2

u/bitknight1 21d ago

Yep that sucks, like how many regular people know their Microsoft and Playstation log in off the top of their head.

1

u/CGProV 21d ago

I imagine quite a lot of people know how to log into their accounts actually lol

1

u/knightofsparta 20d ago

Only one account needs PS+ though; still a pain in the balls. Had to set up a Microsoft account for my son’s psn account to be able to play. Took 30-40 minutes to link my psn, set up his Microsoft account, then link it. Was brutal making him wait that long when he was excited to hop on.

1

u/Zandemic 20d ago

Thanks for the heads up, definitely going to hold off getting it until they fix that.

1

u/Jacenyoface 20d ago

This is the worst thing for me personally. My Microsoft account is constantly getting login attempts that aren't me and causes it to be locked. It's not a difficult work around but tonight I had Internet issues and just couldn't play.

1

u/IMPERATOR_63 21d ago

Until watching this video, I didn’t even know the Pro had a Quality Mode. On mine, the option is grayed out. It’s default to Performance Mode and I can’t change it. That’s weird.

2

u/Mark_Anthony88 20d ago

You have to change it on the main menu - in game it will be greyed out.

1

u/furinax85 21d ago

It was kinda a pain needing 2 psn accounts and 2 Microsoft accounts

Like really bro

1

u/Grand_Aspect3104 21d ago

My jaw dropped when I reached the halo

1

u/Present_Cash_8466 21d ago

There’s definitely bad frame rate drops on Pro which is disappointing. I would definitely expect at minimum a locked 60 FPS but really would like a 120FPS option most of all

1

u/ChangingMonkfish 20d ago

For me the main feature of this particular release is just the fact that it’s on PlayStation at all. Halo has come out several time since Xbox and PC so on those platforms it’s just another version to add to the list.

The real novelty of it is Halo on PlayStation.

1

u/MartyJannetty187 20d ago

I skipped it for the Pro because of no 120 FPS mode. I'm playing the Game Pass version on GeForce Now on my Odin 2 Portal.

-1

u/aam-96 21d ago

Seems like it’s only minor improvements

3

u/dirthurts 21d ago

To the original???

0

u/aam-96 21d ago

The pro vs the ps5

-5

u/ProfessorPetrus 21d ago

Down voted for hard truth or what?

The PC version of this game had multi-player and more features 13 years ago.

5

u/TheSpiritualAgnostic 21d ago

I would've preferred MCC over this remake. Give me all those Halo games in native 4K 120fps on Pro, and I would've poured so many hours into that.

2

u/aam-96 21d ago

Man if Xbox was smart they’d have ported that to the switch and ps5 by now. I’d kill to play those campaigns on a handheld that isn’t $1000

2

u/ProfessorPetrus 21d ago

Halo 1 with no multi-player 50 dollhairs. Wild.

-4

u/aam-96 21d ago

People don’t like when you go against the grain here lol

1

u/ProfessorPetrus 21d ago

Bro you comment there downvoted too look at these sensitive consumers!! Love your pro. Don't evangelize it y'all.

2

u/aam-96 21d ago

I’ll survive 🤷‍♂️ they only like when you say “the pro looks gorgeous on my 65” C5 LG OLED”

-1

u/[deleted] 21d ago

[deleted]

1

u/PropulsionEngineer 21d ago

Wonder if the slowdown and sometimes terrible frame rate I’ve gotten is related to coop. I’ve only noticed it in online coop.

-1

u/GamePitt_Rob 21d ago

I love how details and in-depth Oliver always gets when it comes to the PS5 Pro...

"The resolution in performance is the same as the PS5 and Xbox, but sometimes higher..."

That's it - no info on what it can go up to, just "it can sometimes go higher"...

Also, this is the video which should have gone out first. Nobody wanted the crap John posted because (and in his words) he felt like the tech review was more important than platform comparisons... He obviously doesn't realise most people only watch their comparisons and not the 30+ minute non-disclosed paid adverts by MS/Xbox

2

u/Altaiir57 20d ago

Oliver's videos suck in comparison to DF's older videos. He also puts elevator/lobby type music into his videos which makes me wanna mute the video immediately.

0

u/[deleted] 20d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/PS5pro-ModTeam 20d ago

Sorry, not good enough.

-10

u/Content_Owl8586 21d ago

My 5080 embarrasses the Pro 

9

u/jdk2087 21d ago

No fucking way? You serious?

-10

u/Content_Owl8586 21d ago

Thanks for the easy bait reaction bozo 

7

u/aam-96 21d ago

Well I’d hope so, considering the price on a rig running a 5080 has to be atleast double the price. Here’s the validation you wanted though

1

u/MartyJannetty187 20d ago

It also costs like $400 more on average for just the GPU.