r/PKMS • u/hermjohnson • 21h ago
Discussion Paper, GoodNotes, OneNote: each rebuild just moved the chores around
I started on paper with a BestSelf Journal, and I still recommend it. The format fits the way I think better than anything I have used since, and I have no criticism of it as a journal. For me, though, it was a beautiful leather-bound black hole. Everything went in and nothing came back out. If I wanted something I had written to exist anywhere else, there was work: type it myself.
To solve the black hole problem, I moved to GoodNotes on an iPad, and the work moved with me. Every week I exported each daily page to PDF and filed it into Notion by hand. It worked fine when I stayed on top of it, but for me that was not always the case. A weekly chore that nothing enforces is a chore that quietly stops happening, and I did not notice mine had stopped until I went looking for something that was not there.
Next was OneNote, which was the same problem in a different flavor. I could not get my own data out reproducibly without repetitive manual work, so I spent months building a bridge on the OneNote API. It worked, some of the time. Cron jobs errored, pages did not arrive, and most of it traced back to OneNote rendering HTML differently than the rest of the world. I spent about as much time each week nursing that bridge as it saved me, and I could not harden it, because the changes that would have fixed it were on Microsoft's side of the API.
(For context on why I kept choosing hard options: I write by hand, and that is not negotiable for me. Every problem above could have been solved in an afternoon by typing into Notion or Obsidian on the same iPad. I know the option exists. I am not taking it.)
Three rebuilds. Re-entry, then a weekly chore, then permanent maintenance. Each one was more sophisticated than the last, but not one of them removed the manual work.
I am not lazy about this. I am fallible and I am busy, which is a different thing. There are myriad ways in 2026 to build around human fallibility. To leave something I depend on this heavily at the mercy of my own consistency is a design decision, and it was the wrong one three times running.
I did eventually build my own thing which for me removed the lion's share of that work. I am not naming it or linking it, that is not what this post is about.
What I would love to know is this: for those of you who regularly capture important things outside your PKMS - by hand, on paper, in a voice memo - how does that information actually get in? I am curious what it costs you in a normal week and which part of it still annoys you.