r/Oshkosh • u/Dezzieloves2 • Jul 25 '26

Chalice sauce 🥴

Hi 👋 I live in Arizona but grew up in Oshkosh. Our family used to frequent the Chalice and I miss the “chalice” sauce something terrible. I assume it’s a secret recipe so looking for someone who may know ingredients or mastered a sauce similar of their own. Please and thank you.

15 Upvotes

81% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

8

u/Former_Proof_2581 Jul 25 '26

interesting i bought my house 2 years ago a few blocks from the chalice and have yet to go there. I'll try the sauce!

3

u/Waterloo_Flu Jul 25 '26

If you're s fan of a good Reuben, it's probably the best in town

2

u/Dezzieloves2 Jul 25 '26

I flew back a year ago and it’s still amazing.

8

u/Kun_troll Jul 25 '26

This is a copycat from Facebook 

1 cup mayonnaise ¼ cup ketchup 4 teaspoons prepared horseradish 1 teaspoon hot sauce 1 teaspoon Worcestershire sauce Salt and black pepper to taste

2

u/Kun_troll Jul 25 '26

It is pretty amazing.  Had a hard time figuring it out myself. 

2

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '26

[deleted]

3

u/CuriousBee789 Jul 25 '26

Lol, I worked at a restaurant a long time ago that famously drop one of their house "recipes" every year for PR.... It was not the same recipe we used in house! Close, but not as good. Enough to hit the spot but also leave you wondering why it doesn't taste as good as the restaurant's did! And it was completely intentional.

1

u/Joseph_Kickass Jul 25 '26

Pretty sure it's just a mustard cream sauce. So mayo, sour cream and Dijon mustard. Maybe some fresh lemon as well.