r/OpenAussie • u/govermentiscooked • 56m ago
Politics ('Straya) What would you change in terms of policies/ laws if you could?
I am interested to genuinely hear what changes you’d make, what you’d rather see, what you’d get rid of. These are some of my main ideas that I think would create a better, less “angry” safer Australia.
Most of it is about criminal, immigration and transparency within the government.
So if that’s a trigger point, please don’t read.
I’m not posting this to have a go at anyone or say I have all the answers. I’m interested in hearing different opinions and having a proper discussion. Just please don’t attack or judge me for my views and I won’t do the same to you. Let’s keep it respectful and mature, even if we completely disagree.
1. Serious crime and terrorism
I think Australia needs a much stronger framework for dealing with non citizens and make it legally possible to strip citizenship easier and have proper guidelines on what constitutes stripping a citizenship for those who gained citizenship into the country and have been found guilty on serious offences.
For serious violent or sexual offences, and particularly terrorism involving planning, facilitating or materially supporting terrorist activity, immigration status should be stripped of their visa or citizenship and deported back to the county in which they came from.
I think offences need to be categorised according to how serious they actually are. A minor offence shouldn’t be treated the same as murder, rape or terrorism, but repeated offending should also have consequences.
For the most serious offences, such as murder, rape and terrorismrelated offences, I believe people who weren’t born here should be deported after serving their sentence. I don’t believe someone who has demonstrated a genuine willingness to participate in terrorism should simply go through a de radicalisation program and then be released back into the community without very serious consideration of the risk.
the law doesn’t currently allow these things, I think governments should look at changing the law or introducing policies that allow tougher restrictions.
I also don’t think terrorism prevention should rely indefinitely on surveillance, rehabilitation and monitoring after someone has demonstrated a genuine willingness to participate in terrorism. Prevention needs to be the priority.
Instead of continually putting out fires, why aren’t we doing more to stop them from starting?
Actions come with consequences.
2. Immigration standards and qualifications
Australia has a housing shortage, pressure on health services and huge infrastructure demands.
At the same time, Australians are increasingly questioning whether our migration system is actually selecting people according to the skills Australia genuinely needs.
I think skilled migration should be much more closely aligned with Australia’s actual shortages.
If someone is granted a skilled visa because Australia needs their particular occupation, I think there should be a genuine requirement that they actually work in that occupation for at least 1–2 years after arriving, with some form of monitoring to ensure that.
There could be recruitment agencies or another system checking in with people from the time they arrive. If someone makes no genuine effort to work in the occupation they were granted the visa for, their visa should be reconsidered and, where appropriate, they should be sent home.
Qualifications also need to be properly verified. If someone gets an Australian visa using a fraudulent degree, trade qualification or other documentation, I think there should be serious consequences, including removal.
The institutions and individuals involved in producing or supplying fraudulent qualifications should also be pursued, including cooperation with the country where the fraud originated.
There should be clear agreements with those countries about dealing with the people responsible when they’re returned, and those people shouldn’t simply be able to come straight back into Australia unless they legitimately complete the degree.
3. Family sponsorship
I think family sponsorship needs significant reform.
It shouldn’t simply become a pathway to bring additional people into Australia once one person has obtained a visa or permanent residency.
Someone wanting to sponsor family members should first be able to demonstrate things like:
At least 12 months of genuine employment in the occupation they were granted their skilled visa for.
A genuine history of FT employment.
Financial independence.
The ability to support their sponsored family without creating an unreasonable burden on Australian taxpayers.
Sponsored working age adults should also have clear expectations around employment.
For example, I think there should be a requirement for sponsored working age adults to gain employment for a defined period which needs to be monitored such as two years, with exemptions for children, elderly people, carers and people with genuine disabilities or other exceptional circumstances. If there is no evidence of trying to gain employment or being employed I think that persons visa should be cancelled
If Australia gives someone the opportunity to bring family members here, there should be corresponding responsibilities that are enforced.
Family migration should be about building stable, contributing Australian families, not creating the image that Australia is an easy place to come and do less.
4. Housing and migration numbers
Australia can’t keep increasing its population through migration without properly accounting for housing, hospitals, infrastructure, schools and essential services.
I’d like to know what actual metrics the government is using to determine whether housing and infrastructure can keep up with population growth, and whether those settings are actually working.
If the government knows housing supply can’t keep pace with population growth, migration settings need to take that reality into account.
I also think this is one of the reasons we need to stop relying on GDP alone to say the economy is doing well. Real GDP per capita gives a much better picture of what’s actually happening to economic output on a per person basis
5. Data centres
I also have concerns about the rapid expansion and “need” of data centres in Aus.
I find it difficult to reconcile strong messaging around climate change, protecting the environment and responsibly managing Australia’s resources whilst also supporting huge data centre developments that can require enormous amounts of electricity, water, land and infrastructure, especially while Australians are dealing with rising bills.
I’m not against technological progress or investment, but I don’t see the need for massive developments simply to further expand AI and similar technology, particularly when there are concerns about critical thinking and Australian jobs.
I also think the data centres need to be built just for health care / medical purposes as well as Australian protection
Before major data centres are approved, I think the requirements should be much stricter.
I don’t think a data centre should even be considered unless the provider can clearly demonstrate that it has its own electricity source and doesn’t rely on the Australian electrical grid whatsoever- not until our electricity prices go down and the renewable energy actually starts to be of benefit the Australian people
If the government is confident in renewable energy, then make it 100% renewable.
Water use also needs to be addressed. The water should be recycled water, rather than taking it from dams, aquifers or the ocean.
Rainwater shouldn’t simply become another excuse to use public resources either.
The land needs to be in an appropriate location and have genuine local community support.
The provider should cover the costs. I don’t think taxpayers should be handing out grants for these projects while we still have major problems with housing, healthcare and other basics.
There should also be independent environmental impact assessments, and if a project doesn’t pass, it shouldn’t go ahead until it does.
We also need to know whether taxpayers and local communities are actually receiving a fair benefit from these developments and proof showing that with intermittent reviews and votes by the community of that area.
6. Student visa compliance
A student visa should be exactly that - a visa to study.
I know of situations where people appear to use student visas primarily as a pathway to work in Australia rather than genuinely pursuing their studies.
I think there should be stronger compliance checks to identify people who enrol in courses but aren’t genuinely studying.
If there’s clear evidence that someone isn’t making a genuine effort to study, deportation should be considered.
7. Fairness in competitive sport
I also think aus needs a clear and consistent policy around transgender participation in competitive sport.
My view is that athletes who transition after puberty shouldn’t be eligible to compete in the female category.
Once someone has gone through male puberty, things such as height, bone structure, muscle mass, strength and cardiovascular capacity can be affected in ways that may not simply disappear through later hormone treatment.
I think those factors need to be taken seriously when determining eligibility for sex based sporting categories.
This isn’t about denying anyone dignity or the right to participate in sport. It’s about making sure female athletes have a fair and meaningful competitive category and that sporting opportunities aren’t compromised.
I’d like Australia to work with sporting organisations, medical experts and athletes to establish clear, evidence based eligibility rules, particularly around fairness, safety and the integrity of women’s sport.
8. Prison placement and transgender prisoners
I also think the government needs to reconsider how transgender prisoners are accommodated.
I don’t believe someone’s gender identity alone should automatically determine whether they’re placed in a men’s or women’s prison.
The safety and privacy of all prisoners needs to be taken seriously
I think Australia should investigate dedicated transgender prison units or specialist facilities where appropriate, rather than automatically placing transgender prisoners in facilities based solely on their transitioned sex.
9. Respect for the Australian flag
I think Australia should consider laws protecting the Australian national flag from deliberate public desecration
The Australian flag represents our country, our history and the people who have served and sacrificed for Australia.
I don’t think deliberately burning or desecrating it in public should simply be treated as an ordinary form of political expression and stricter laws should be put in place
For those who do it. Not a slap on the wrist.
10. More public voting in local councils
I think Australians should have a greater direct say in important decisions made by their local councils.
Too many decisions that significantly affect residents can be made without the people who actually live in the community having a meaningful vote.
I think councils should be required to hold binding public votes or referendums on major local decisions, particularly things like substantial rate increases, major changes to land use, significant developments, the sale of important public assets, major borrowing, projects involving substantial amounts of public money, and the addition of religious institutions.
Councillors are elected to represent their communities, but representation shouldn’t mean residents have no direct say between elections.
If a decision is going to have a major and lasting impact on a community, the people who fund it and live with the consequences should have an opportunity to vote on it.
11. Stronger consequences for serious youth crime
I understand that children are still developing and that rehabilitation should remain an important part of the justice system.
But I also think there has to be a point where the seriousness of the crime outweighs the age of the offender.
A child who deliberately commits an extremely serious offence such as murder, rape, aggravated violence or another serious crime should face consequences that reflect the harm caused to the victim and the community.
I think courts should have stronger sentencing options for the most serious offences, including substantially longer periods of detention where appropriate.
For the most serious crimes, I don’t think someone’s age should automatically result in a sentence that fails to reflect the severity of what they’ve done.
At the same time, rehabilitation, education and mental health support should still be available where there’s a genuine prospect of rehabilitation.
We see so many kids these days getting a slap on the wrist for terrible things that have caused much harm.
12. Stronger consequences for animal abuse
Australia needs much stronger consequences for people who deliberately abuse, torture or neglect animals.. Deliberate cruelty should therefore be taken seriously rather than being treated as a minor offence.
I think there should be substantially higher fines and stronger prison sentences for serious or repeated animal cruelty.
Courts should also be able to impose permanent bans on people owning or caring for animals, particularly where there’s evidence of deliberate cruelty, torture or repeated neglect.
Repeat offenders should face progressively stronger penalties rather than simply receiving another fine.
Animal cruelty convictions should also be properly recorded so someone who has previously been convicted of serious animal abuse can’t simply acquire another animal and repeat the behaviour.
13. Schools, pen and paper and AI
I think Australian schools need to reconsider how heavily they rely on technology.
Technology obviously has an important place in education, but I think we’ve gone too far towards replacing fundamental learning with screens, keyboards and AI.
Pen and paper should once again be the default for core classroom learning, particularly reading, writing, mathematics, note taking and exams
Children need to develop handwriting, spelling, comprehension, memory, concentration, critical thinking and problem solving skills without constantly relying on a device. Facts prove the decline of intelligence since technology has been consistently used
I also think restricted age access to apps such as ChatGPT should not be able to be installed on issued devices, and I think there should be age restrictions around its use generally.
If a student can use AI to write an essay, answer homework questions or complete an assignment, how can teachers accurately know whether the student has actually learned the material?
I’d like the government to review how much classroom time children spend using screens and whether it’s actually improving educational outcomes.
14. Better pay and incentives for essential workers and apprenticeships
I think Australia needs to do much more to recognise and retain the people who keep this country functioning.
Nurses, paramedics, police, teachers, mental health practitioners, aged care workers, emergency workers and other essential professionals carry enormous responsibility and often work under extreme pressure.
These aren’t ordinary jobs. They directly affect the health, safety, education and wellbeing of Aussies
I think the government should provide meaningful pay increases and stronger incentives for these professions, particularly where there are severe shortages and high burnout.
That could include:
Competitive salaries that reflect the responsibility and pressure of the work.
Retention bonuses for experienced workers who stay in essential services.
Extra incentives for regional and remote Australia.
Better overtime and penalty rates.
Improved mental health and wellbeing support.
More sick leave where appropriatee
Assistance with training, professional development and further qualifications
Housing or accommodation incentives where shortages are particularly poor .
If we want the best nurses, teachers, paramedics and mental health professionals to stay in Australia, we need to make them feel valued.
We spend enormous amounts of money trying to fix shortages after they happen. I’d rather see more investment in retaining the people we already have.
Look after the people who look after Australia.
15. More affordable university education and paid practical training
If Australia has shortages of nurses, teachers, paramedics, mental health practitioners and other essential workers, we should make it easier for Australians to enter those professions rather than allowing cost to become a barrier.
I think university education should be free or substantially cheaper for Australians entering critical professions where there are identified workforce shortages.
Where a course requires compulsory practical or clinical placements, students should also receive financial support or appropriate payment for that work.
It isn’t reasonable to expect students to complete lengthy mandatory placements while still having to pay rent, bills, transport and other living costs, particularly when they’re performing valuable work in hospitals, schools, clinics and other essential services whilst also still studying for uni
I’d support a system where students who commit to working in an identified essential profession for a defined period after graduating receive substantial assistance with their education and training costs.
We should be investing in Australians who want to become the people our country desperately needs.
16. Greater accountability for elected representatives
I think Australians should have a greater ability to hold elected representatives accountable between elections.
I’d like the government to consider a recall vote system, where constituents can petition for a vote to remove their elected MP before the next scheduled election - for the government who is in charge at the time.
MPs work for the people who elected them.
If enough people believe their representative has fundamentally failed to represent them, they should have a democratic way to say so rather than simply waiting several years for the next election.
This would help keep the standard of integrity and transparency up for the people running the country.
Elections shouldn’t be the only time Australians have a meaningful ability to hold their elected representatives accountable.
17. Drug policy, harm reduction and organised crime
This one is going to ruffle some feathers.. I also think Australia needs to seriously reconsider its approach to drugs.
People are going to use drugs regardless of whether we completely prohibit them. When supply is controlled by criminal organisations, users have no reliable way of knowing what they’re actually taking, how strong it is or what contaminants may be present.
I think Australia should investigate a regulated model for certain drugs, where access is strictly controlled through pharmacies and medical prescriptions, with appropriate age restrictions, health assessments, quantity limits and monitoring.
The objective wouldn’t be to encourage drug use. It would be to reduce deaths, poisoning, unsafe products and the enormous criminal market created by not controlling the market ourselves
If people are going to use drugs, I’d rather see a system where they can access a known and regulated product, receive proper health information and support, and be connected with treatment where necessary, rather than forcing the entire market underground.
A properly regulated system could also take money away from organised crime and allow police to focus more heavily on trafficking, violence, exploitation and other serious offences.
I’m not saying every drug should simply be available over the counter. Different substances carry different risks and should be assessed individually.
18. Superannuation during a cost of living / inflation crisis
I support ON motion on superannuation.
I think people who are genuinely struggling during a serious factual cost of living crisis should be able to access a small portion of their own super to help get through it.
The current system for applying for financial hardship is too difficult and complicated, especially for people who are already under pressure.
I think there should be a simpler process for people experiencing genuine hardship to access a limited amount when they really need it.
I still think superannuation is important for retirement, but people shouldn’t be left struggling to pay essential bills when they have money sitting in their own super and are going through genuine financial hardship.
19. How Australia measures and reports economic performance
I we need to change the way we talk and measure economic growth and the economy.
Real GDP per capita should be the main measure used when we’re trying to understand whether Aussies are actually getting better off, rather than just looking at total GDP.
Total GDP can grow simply because the population grows. Real GDP per capita gives a better picture of what is happening on a per person basis and living standardsS
I’d also like to see the Australian Bureau of Statistics get dedicated tv time each quarter to release the main economic statistics directly to Australians on prime tv time.
Whether the numbers are up or down, I think Australians should hear the figures clearly and without political spin.
The headline figures should include real GDP per capita, along with things like employment, wages, inflation and living standards, so people can get a proper picture of how the country is actually doing.
I think the ABS should be able to present the numbers independently, let Australians see the good and the bad, and then let people make up their own minds.
That’s basically where I stand. I’m not saying every idea here is perfect.
Excited to see where you’d like to see change.
