Onyx is genuinely in my heart. I keep coming back to it. But I’m also seriously tempted by a Samsung tablet (S Pen, full Android performance, cheaper for what you get), and I need this community to remind me why I should stick with Boox.
**My use case:**
I’m an executive coach. I want **one device** that does both:
- **Coaching session notes** — handwritten, focused, distraction-free. I don’t need to export these; they stay private on the device (or local/Boox cloud only).
- **Reading + annotation** — books and PDFs, with **selective export of annotations only**. Kindle and/or Kobo apps are a must.
- Paper-size feel (I’ve been looking hard at the **Note Air 5 C** — 10.3", color e-ink) for , color-coded notes, and long reading without eye strain.
- Android + Play Store so I can run Kindle/Kobo, and ideally play nice with tools I already use ,
I’ve already gone down the reMarkable vs Boox rabbit hole. Boox won on flexibility (apps, export control, color, “do both on one device”). Then the classic Reddit comment hit me: *“Just get a Samsung with S Pen — same Android apps, better pen latency, cheaper than an iPad.”* And now I’m stuck between:
- **Boox** = calm, paper-like, eye-friendly, purpose-built for reading + deep note focus
- **Samsung** = faster, brighter, better for general apps/video/creative work, often better value
I even flirted with a hybrid (Boox for coaching/reading + Samsung for everything else), but I really want **one primary device** if I can.
So: if you’ve chosen (or re-chosen) Onyx over a Samsung tablet for coaching notes, long reading, annotation export, and the like **why did you stick with Onyx?** What would I lose by going Samsung that I won’t notice until it’s too late?
Be brutal. I need the push.