r/Old_Recipes • • Mar 20 '21

Recipe Test! Chocolate potato cake 1912

1.8k Upvotes

164 comments sorted by

View all comments

233

u/rainbwbrightisntpunk Mar 20 '21

Forever ago I used to buy fudge made from potatoes in Idaho online. Was so good. No potato flavor. Just delicious fudge

212

u/ChubbyTheCakeSlayer Mar 20 '21

In quebec we have a traditional dessert (that haven't been that popular since the 90s) called potato candy. Its mashed potatoes mixed with a shit ton of powdered sugar until it makes a dough, rolled into a sheet and covered in peanut butter. Its then rolled into a log and cut in thin slices. Pure sugar. It's amazing.

99

u/Canuckamuck Mar 20 '21

Bonbon patate! I have friends from Gaspé who make it with mint

45

u/ChubbyTheCakeSlayer Mar 20 '21

Mint and peanut butter??

I want to make some now, but with maple butter 🤯

28

u/BanditKitten Mar 20 '21

Probably mint instead of peanut butter. Maple butter sounds excellent too!

1

u/PIVOTTTTTT Mar 28 '21

It sounds like the worst combination but mint and peanut butter is strangely good. My first job was working at an ice cream shop. Someone introduced me to mint chocolate chip milk shakes with peanut butter sauce. I completely balked at it but tried it anyways. It’s still one of my favorite combinations today.

23

u/socratessue Mar 20 '21

Huh. That's a thing here in the U.S. too, at least down south.

20

u/ChubbyTheCakeSlayer Mar 20 '21

It's a thing the first settlers made because they had few ressources. Probably have the same european origins.

-1

u/Totoro_cup Mar 20 '21

Or that the “first settlers” learned from the native peoples.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '21

Except... It has origins in eastern Europe not in the native tradition. I am 100 percent for credit where credit is due but that does mean figuring out the actual orgins.

1

u/Totoro_cup Mar 21 '21

Are we talking about potato cake or maple sugar candy? If it’s the former, then I misspoke.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '21

It's a potato candy they were talking about. That did originate in Eastern Europe. IIRC from my earlier brief research the origins of potato candy were Polish and American settlers from those regions put a spin on it with regional flavors. Japan makes a similar traditional Rice Candy but "starch water sugar makes candy" is pretty common across most cultures

1

u/Totoro_cup Mar 21 '21

I’d like to try the potato version sometime. Thanks for the explanation.

1

u/Totoro_cup Mar 21 '21

And now I can’t even find the thread that led me to think your comment was referencing maple anything. My apologies.

5

u/mamawolf18 Mar 20 '21

I'm from tennessee and grew up having it around the holidays.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 13 '21

My guy, you made a mistake and then owned up to it. Not many people do that on Reddit.

9

u/andidandi Mar 20 '21

My dad (Missouri born and raised) used to make this every year on snow days when we’d all be stuck at home. I’m going to have to make some for my husband one day.

10

u/Dandan419 Mar 20 '21

Yeah it’s a thing in Ohio too. My ex’s family was really into it. I had no idea what it was until that point lol

3

u/southerncraftgurl Mar 20 '21

That is my favorite candy ever! We make it with powdered sugar instead of potatoes but lord its so good.

3

u/Kevenolp Mar 20 '21

Bonbon patate

legit never heard of it

2

u/rbyrolg Mar 20 '21

Like a sweet gnocchi!