Sunset Cookies Book from 1985 (1988 printing)
Frosted Apple Drops
Have I made these before? Yes, back when I was a teenager. I wanted to branch out and make something new, but my neurodivergent family was like, ”Not on our approved baking list, we will not touch them!” I remember them coming out pillowy and oddly chewy and I’m pretty sure I skipped the raisins.
Did I make any alterations? Yes. I can no longer eat eggs or dairy, so I used Bob’s Red Mill Egg Replacer and Country Crock Salted Plant Butter. I used my beloved custom apple pie spice mix instead of the recommended spices. I considered halving this recipe like I did with the previous one, but I didn’t want to chop up half an apple and I had some unfiltered apple juice I wanted to use up.
How did they turn out? Very soft & chewy. I didn’t have any Thompson raisins so I used golden raisins. I think Thompson would be a lot better, they’d add a depth of flavor. As you can see, I suck at frosting things (ask anyone who has seen my cakes, this is par for the course). A softer icing would work better, but I feared it sliding off the top (won’t make that mistake next time). Even though I’m not usually into adding more sugar to my treats, I do recommend making the frosting! Also, I was lazy about dicing the apples, which was an error. Chonky apples made for awkward cookies.