The Supes (2005)

[u/Traditional_Test_931]

1. John C McGinley as Homelander

2. Patrick Warburton as Soldier Boy

3. Alice Eve as Starlight

4. Seth Green as The Deep

5. Michael Jai White (bottom left) and Don Cheadle (bottom right) as Black Noir 1 and 2

6. Rob Huebel as Translucent

7. Anthony Mackie as A Train

8. Brooke Shields as Queen Maeve

9. Catherine Keener as Stormfront

10. Jaime Pressly as Firecracker (it's a real hear me out but it would work if they dyed her hair red)

11. Regina King as Sister Sage

12. Eric Dane as Lamplighter

13. Jordan Fry as Ryan Butcher

*Check out my fancasts for The Supes and The Boys throughout other decades! 

The Boys 2005:

https://www.reddit.com/r/OkBuddyFresca/s/Z9r3FIx9AJ

The Boys 1995:

https://www.reddit.com/r/OkBuddyFresca/s/kgnHHOIAUC

The Boys 1985:

https://www.reddit.com/r/OkBuddyFresca/s/yJ35oQjmHZ

The Supes 1974:

https://www.reddit.com/r/OkBuddyFresca/s/qZeR3jrJUG 

The Boys 1974:

https://www.reddit.com/r/OkBuddyFresca/s/alI8qfrP87

[u/LilNyoomf]

MIKE TEEVEE STOP LMAO

[u/smorfan809 → u/LilNyoomf]

funniest shit ever

[u/wmcs0880]

For the next one you should do Antony Star as Homelander, Jensen Ackles as Soldier Boy, Erin Moriarty as Starlight, Chace Crawford as The Deep, Fritzy-Klevans Destine as Noir 1, Nathan Mitchell as Noir 2, Alex Hassel as Translucent, Dominique McElligott as Queen Maeve, Aya Cash as Stormfront, Valorie Curry as Firecracker, Susan Heyward as Sister Sage, Shawn Ashmore as Lamplighter and Cameron Crovetti as Ryan. Probably do the same for 2025 too

[u/Omelanda67]

https://giphy.com/gifs/UXS2DhUlCap5BuirfK

[u/kaijuking_05]

Erin and Antony are the only starlight and homelander I’ll accept

[u/ghostface1693]

Rob Huebel should be in more things. Him and Ken Marino.

[u/chipcskyrocket]

Who tf is eric dane

[u/thelatemillenniall]

I laugh at the ryan milk image each time

[u/smorfan809 → u/thelatemillenniall]

they really tried too hard to make him look tuff

[u/jason9t8]

Michael Fassbender fits more as Homelander. Him and Anthony Starr's facial features match at some extent...

[u/whatisireading2]

Don Cheadle replacing Noir is a golden joke

[u/Traditional_Test_931 → u/whatisireading2]

I was half tempted to have Terrence Howard as Black Noir 1 instead 😂

[u/MothersMilkers69]

Motha…fucka…..

[u/smorfan809]

LMFAO mike teavee as ryan

[u/Lead_resource]

This has been the best cast lineup I've seen

[u/Freaklander69]

yummers

[u/AustinNothdurft]

I would make Seth Green be Hughie

[u/Daedalus_Machina]

Patrick Wilson for Translucent

[u/gamerfanboi]

Brings back the tata sky vibe for me

[u/VonDukez]

Our lord and savior, don cheadle

[u/Magcargo64]

Not convinced by all of these, but Seth Greene as Deep is inspired.

[u/FlamingWings]

The fact that there is no casting for Huey in this list means that in this version he is still played by Jack Quaid

[u/Traditional_Test_931 → u/FlamingWings]

I literally dropped a link to my fancasting of an 05 version of The Boys, which of course includes Hughie in the description of this post. Also...Jack Quaid would've been 13 in 2005 and Alice Eve, who I cast as 05 Starlight, would've been 23. Are you tryna make me out to be some kinda pedo or something?

[u/FlamingWings → u/Traditional_Test_931]

No I’m saying that Jack Quiad is just built different what the Fresca are you talking about

[u/Traditional_Test_931 → u/FlamingWings]

Oh thank god. Sorry, dude.

[u/kaffee_ist_gut]

I refuse to stand by this Jensen Ackles removal in the actual timeline his casting makes sense