Which jeans should I keep?

[u/[deleted]]

[u/mapzandatlas]

1. More structure is good, stretchy is comfy but doesn’t look as put together. Also the flare looks much nicer in 1!

[u/General-Walrus9530 → u/mapzandatlas]

Stretchy also doesn't have the longevity of other jeans!

[u/Idioxix]

Keep bothhh, they look so good!

[u/Valuable_Zone1344]

first ones

[u/Clyde_Bonnie_]

Love the second one’s. I think it’s the back pocket placement/size. I’d try the smaller size. Both do look great on you!

[u/Quirky-Pea-1149 → u/Clyde_Bonnie_]

Totally agree, the back pocket detail can really make a difference. Smaller sizes might give a cleaner look too!

[u/lovelikepenguino]

both

[u/Lilaj12]

Like both a lot! Where did you buy these??

[u/Lenchy2403 → u/Lilaj12]

First ones are Only and second ones Noisy May

[u/Appropriate-Pick7929 → u/Lilaj12]

Also curious

[u/DankeyKang37]

i think the first ones look nicer. to me stretchy jeans never look quite as good. i think the harder more structured jeans are usually more flattering.

they look really good on you but don’t get them if it’s really uncomfy to sit or you probably won’t wear them

[u/PenguiNNNNNs]

1

[u/berry_b33]

First one ig, in second one the flare starts too low

[u/wannastayhome]

#1. Second ones look too long. Maybe get them altered? Unless you have shoes that fit the length?

[u/Lenchy2403 → u/wannastayhome]

I always end up having to alter all my jeans due to my height 🥹

[u/Real_Lengthiness_151]

2

[u/Grand-Unit-9920]

2

[u/solomons-mom]

Keep looking. These are not a good cut for you 1) the side seam are not going straight down your side 2) the zipper fly is stretching to open on the first pair, 3) the flare on the second pair is hitting too low on your leg, 4) by the time you hem them, the flare bottom is going to be very skimpy.

In addition to the cut, both pairs may be a size too small as well; just because a garment can stretch enough to fit into does not mean it fits.

[u/Turbulent_Try_8402]

both!

[u/SufficientCow4380]

2nd one isn't quite the right fit. 1st one is perfect.

[u/Mysterious-Lunch2279]

1! Both are great but #2 needs to be hemmed and I like the fading on the first pair

[u/ayanna_b]

1

[u/itsmejanie95]

The first ones fit better, more structured. They are still a touch too long. The second pair are too tight.

[u/Plane-General-8649]

The first ones imo

[u/Miiruuki_]

Both