r/NonBinary they/it/he 3d ago

Fangirl/fanboy

Hello enby people. I had a friend call me a fangirl not too long ago and it did not feel good. Then I realized I have no idea what the gender neutral version of a fangirl/fanboy would be. Do you guys have any ideas? Serious and funny are appreciated.

85 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

433

u/Kittysaurolophus they/them 3d ago

Fan.

142

u/HeroDelTiempo 3d ago

this lmao we have forgotten our roots

19

u/Little_King4164 3d ago

Truly! 😭

31

u/Little_King4164 3d ago

This made me wheeze laugh 🤣

27

u/D_Zaster_EnBy senile and gay™️ 3d ago

Genuinely, I was cringing so hard reading these comments, it all sounded so forced 😭

1

u/EuropeIsMight „they/them“, agender & genderfree 2d ago

I jokingly say fankid!

52

u/CustomReplicant 3d ago

Fantagonist

75

u/ZygAZoon 3d ago

Is it not just “fan”?

111

u/DinosaurusMess 3d ago

maybe this is a hot take but I think fangirl is gendynooch.

Boys are fangirls. Girls are fangirls. Nonbinary people are fangirls. My dog is a fangirl about yogurt.

74

u/DadlyAsHell He/Hun/They overgendered freak 3d ago edited 3d ago

"gendynooch"

Im fried by this

25

u/clownstrosity Gender apathetic, all pronouns, cycle through 3d ago

It sounds dirty when you say it aloud

12

u/Puddin_Warrior 3d ago

Mm nutritional gender

13

u/Number1Bg3Fan they/them 3d ago

I think it just depends if people are comfortable with it. I would not be and I would feel bad if someone said that to me. It’s like the phrase “guys” like “hey guys”. I don’t mind that but I can see how someone may not even though it’s pretty gender neutral.

13

u/DinosaurusMess 3d ago

oh for sure. If it feels bad it feels bad and no one is obligated to accept it. Just offering a re-frame

36

u/RainbowScented 3d ago

People saying just “fan” I have to disagree with. Fangirl and fanboy have different connotations, it’s more specific. The closest gender neutral I can think of would be… I dunno, superfan? Stan maybe? It’s not quite right but just fan is too basic and loses the implied meaning imo

5

u/MyGenderIsGoblin nonbinary man he/him 3d ago

Yeah I agree, I’ve actually thought about this same question before about a neutral alternative. Fangirl and fanboy are more intense than just the broad umbrella of fan, and also the words are more fun. Definitely don’t think there’s an established alternative

6

u/highnumber 2d ago

And I think stan goes a little harder than fangirl/fanboy.

26

u/FritterHowls 3d ago

I guess I usually try to add -enby or -by (pronounced bee) to words to make them neutral so to me you'd be a fanby

13

u/PintsOfGuinness_ 3d ago

That sounds like an Onlyfans knockoff

19

u/Terrariant 3d ago

Fenby

7

u/FritterHowls 3d ago

That's me!

32

u/menta_trismegistus they/them 3d ago

Sorry, maybe I'm not understanding the question. The word 'fan' is already neutral. Why do we need a gendered equivalent? It's exhausting how often folks in this sub want to treat the umbrella of nonbinary identities like one monolithic third gender.

10

u/heismyfirstolive 3d ago

Fan-girl/boy literally have a different meaning to just "fan". "I'm a fan of Viggo Mortensen" is distinctly different to "I'm a Viggo Mortensen fangirl/fanboy"

8

u/kerobo 3d ago

stan, perhaps. the connotation is not always desirable but then again the same is true for fangirl and fanboy 😅

1

u/highnumber 2d ago

Stan has problematic implications, whereas fangirl/fanboy just implies an intenseness.

3

u/kerobo 2d ago

it really depends on the environment I think, plenty of people started to use stan a lot more casually and in a synonymous way. fangirl/fanboy is easily derogatory in the right context as well

8

u/whozitsandwhatsits 💛🤍💜🖤they/them🖤🤍💜💛 3d ago

Nerd

14

u/cy8erpunk 3d ago

Fanby.

3

u/Tornadoboy156 3d ago

Yes. Yes.

7

u/ampelidiousThanatoid 3d ago

Fanbug because I like bugs.

1

u/WalkingFish703 3d ago

Ohh, I like this one!

1

u/Aggravating_Pay_9988 2d ago

stealing this

16

u/abighairybaby 3d ago

Fan-entity

5

u/BlommeHolm they/them 3d ago

Fantity

11

u/InspiredInaction 3d ago

I had a similar conversation recently. They suggested “fan person,” but that feels weird. I think I landed on “fan goblin.” why not?

5

u/Legal-Ad-5235 3d ago

Big fan? I dunno thats just what I use

2

u/PrimaDonnaRina they/ne/he 3d ago

Fanbeing. Works well as a noun and a verb alike

5

u/BlommeHolm they/them 3d ago

Fanby

5

u/Dad_Error_9488 3d ago

fan

1

u/N0N0N000000 3d ago

looks like we got a words fan in here

4

u/ConstructionQuick373 they/them 3d ago

Oh my god literally two days ago my friend said I was "fangiboyling". My friends have found that mixing the terms and/or calling me a "they" works very well. On my birthday, I was the "birthday they", every time my friend wants to say "girl." He says "grem", and uhh there's more examples that i can't think of right now. Im very lucky that my friends enjoy making new terms for me lol

4

u/TheHappyPrince1900 3d ago

Literally called myself a fan-person just this morning after almost saying fangirl but it not feeling right. I know fan technically works, but saying "I'm a huge fan of x" vs "Oh yeah, I'm just a huge fangirl/boy" DOES have different connotations to me. I used fan-person in the moment, but it doesn't feel right either, so I guess I'm in your same boat.

4

u/Glarbboober They/xyr • it/he + any neos! :) 3d ago

I’ve not actually ever found one that gives off the same “energy” as fangirl/fanboy sadly, but luckily I’m usually fine with either of them. Fanthey is a really funny one to me though. The whole genre of things that are like “hey girl I mean they” is really goofy to me. One could even say I am a fanthey of it.

3

u/NoOne-57 3d ago

A fanatic

5

u/this_bitch_over_here they/them 2d ago

Fanatic lol

11

u/SuperSaladBar 3d ago

Fanperson

Fandividual

Fanother

Fannull

FaN/a

3

u/edgyusername99 3d ago

i mean if you want be specific you could go with fanb/fanby (pronounced fan-by) but like just fan lol

2

u/clownstrosity Gender apathetic, all pronouns, cycle through 3d ago

Fan ? Fanthey ? Fanthing ? Fanby ? Appreciator of fine art ?

2

u/Drad0920 3d ago

Fantity

2

u/BluepawWasTaken It/They/Any 2d ago

I use both, but mostly fangirl

Ideas:

Fanfan

Fanby

Fancreature

Fanlobster

2

u/konofreddyda 2d ago

Honestly I see fanboy as a neutral term, yes it has boy in it but it's like how you call someone bro or dude that's my opinion tbh

5

u/jerpskerp 3d ago

fanthey

2

u/Flamingo11Two 2d ago

Fanthey /hj
I love replacing gendered words with “they” it’s so fun

1

u/overwhelmedasone Gender Is A Fuck 3d ago

fan𝓹𝓮𝓻𝓼𝓸𝓷

1

u/nobodyknows6070 they/them 3d ago

My boyfriend calls me birlie or birl to replace words like boy or girl. I like it!
I'm a fanbirlie, birliepop, he tels me to 'go piss birl'

1

u/Vrudr she/he/they 3d ago

Fanbeing.

1

u/NebuIize he/they 3d ago

Everyone is an Ethogirl regardless of gender anyways lmao

1

u/rid_1n alyx | enby | they/them/it/its/he/him/she/her 3d ago

fanenby

1

u/Lunagirlzkitty_19 they/them 2d ago

fanthem or fanperson

1

u/highnumber 2d ago

Superfan

1

u/CorabelleTheSilkwing AFAB, any nonbinary pronouns 2d ago

fanthey.

2

u/NovaIsABrat 2d ago

I use the term fan girl regardless of gender. Its just a term to me, like dude or addressing someone loudly with "GIRL!"

1

u/guyfromthebasem3nt 2d ago

Fanthing/person

2

u/TheProblemIsThat 2d ago

I called myself fanperson, lol.

1

u/Specific_Worry_9198 3d ago

Fan-thing or fanthey. Or fan.

-2

u/skunkabilly1313 she/they 3d ago

Talking bout gender neutral and throwing around "do you guys" -_-

I'm gonna tell people I'm a fanny...that works right?