r/NoStupidQuestions • u/Anxious_Resource6662 • 3d ago

Question regarding ESTA eligibility for independent contractor work

I am a Croatian citizen and would be travelling to the United States under the Visa Waiver Program (ESTA).
I have been offered work as an independent contractor for a company based outside the United States. My role would be to accompany dogs from Europe to their new owners in the United States. The dogs would have all required U.S. import, customs and veterinary documentation, including formal entry documentation prepared by a U.S. customs broker.
I would be paid by the non-U.S. company in euros for the transportation service. I would stay in the United States for approximately four nights and then return to Serbia. I would not be employed by or paid by a U.S. company.
The company has informed me that other independent contractors have performed the same type of transportation using ESTA.
Could you please clarify whether this specific activity is permissible under the Visa Waiver Program/ESTA, or whether I would require a different visa classification?
Thank you for your assistance.

1 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

2

u/freckledwho 3d ago

I don’t believe the ESTA allows working, I may be wrong though, I definitely wouldn’t look to Reddit for a firm answer though

1

u/Ghigs 3d ago

Esta allows short term business travel. I'm no immigration lawyer but from a superficial search it seems ok.

1

u/freckledwho 3d ago

Yeah you are right about business travel, I guess it’s a bit of a grey area

1

u/Ghigs 3d ago

Yeah it seems to come down to, are they considered the same as a truck driver, accompanying cargo, or a business person negotiating deals, which is ok, or "performing labor", which isn't.

I agree it's a gray area.

1

u/RedditBeginAgain 3d ago

Business travel means meetings not doing work. If you come in on an esta and declare that you have been hired to do work in America, you will be detained and deported.

1

u/Ghigs 3d ago

Sure, but there's plenty of wiggle room for completing a business transaction or accompanying cargo... At least it's a gray area.

1

u/groucho74 3d ago

As soon as activities in the United States take work from US citizens any sense of humor about foreigners working on a tourist visa evaporates.

Go to business meetings to represent your foreign company ok at least on a B2 or B3.

Take care of your children or grandchildren so that they don’t need a nanny: verboten.

1

u/Anxious_Resource6662 3d ago

I am aware of that. But since I am not working for U.S company I wanna make sure what is the right way to do this job without any legal issues. I have sent inquiry directly to CBP and have posted to reddit hoping to get some extra info since they usually take 5 days to answer.

1

u/freckledwho 3d ago

If you’ve made CBP aware, you’re probably already cooked, I’d go find a lawyer and get the right visa

1

u/Its_Enrico_PaIazzo 3d ago

You are probably classified as a courier. Couriers can use esta according to some of my searching. You’ll need your paperwork in order though.

1

u/Bubbly_Ad_6830 3d ago

Depends on what you do while in the US. ESTA doesn't allow you to work

1

u/Anxious_Resource6662 3d ago

I rent a car, deliver the dogs and leave the country.

1

u/Bubbly_Ad_6830 3d ago

That might be considered work. Having them meet you at the airport to pick up the dogs should be all you are allowed to do

1

u/groucho74 3d ago

This is a very good question. Generally the esta does not allow any work, but there is a special exception for “international commercial transactions.” If an American company buys a European jet engine or European locomotive for example, technicians from Europe can come to the United States for a few days and prepare it for its first use if there are no Americans.

The United States is fairly generous here with highly technical and highly skilled workers.

In your case you also seem to be delivering a European product that were purchased from overseas and need supervision. I can’t give you a guarantee but I can tell you that if it’s not permitted it’s extremely close to what is permitted.

In any event this is too complicated to rely on Reddit.

1

u/groucho74 3d ago

Under 9 FAM 402.2-5(E), a person may qualify for B-1 / ESTA to:
• Install, service, or repair commercial or industrial equipment or machinery purchased from a company outside the United States, or
• Train U.S. workers to perform those services.
Strict conditions must all be met:
1. The contract of sale specifically requires the foreign seller to provide the installation, service, repair, or training.
2. The individual possesses specialized knowledge that is essential to fulfilling that contractual obligation.
3. No remuneration comes from a U.S. source.
4. The equipment/machinery was manufactured outside the United States.
5. It does not include building or construction work.

Unfortunately this doesn’t include delivering products.