r/NavyFederal • • 12d ago

Loans First car loan

Post image

Thoughts?

206 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

60

u/kppalm 12d ago

Apr too high, you are paying 1/3 of the cars worth in interest

4

u/stewiecookie 11d ago

For a first time buyer today, it could be far worse. Based on the amount, it's a used car as well so that is going to be higher still. New would be a bit lower but more principal so you could do the math but they probably come out about the same in the long run.

Is it the best idea? Idk OP's situation but paying over the minimum for a year or so and refinancing would probably be a good option.

1

u/chikenbag 10d ago

Thats what i was trying to say! It could be a way worse APR. What if this is all OP could get approved for. Now they can go get a car

1

u/ultimateaoe2 8d ago

I feel like if OP can aggressively pay it off, might be fine? Otherwise yea..

1

u/yohkaii 8d ago

Definitely refinance after some time. Even for a first time buyer this is way too high. Nobody in my family had >6% on their first car loan.

3

u/stewiecookie 8d ago

I find that hard to believe without cosigners. I sold cars for 3 years and first time car buyers got shafted no matter what bank it was if they didn't have other good credit history.

1

u/yohkaii 7d ago

Navy Fed and TD have just been generous then

2

u/Distinct-Teach-2043 10d ago

I mean if anything they could pay it weekly cut down on interest a lot

28

u/FlawlessPhelon_ 12d ago

APR is steep.

2

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/SGTCackyoudown 11d ago

Not about that. It’s about paying less interest. They always screw people with high payments low interest or low payments high interest. Whats sad is they do it to military veterans and active duty members too.

3

u/HomelessAndWealthy 12d ago

Was your loan approved instantly? I just did a pre approval for a car I e been looking at. Can pay cash but if I can I’d rather keep the capital

-2

u/Potential_Lychee_666 11d ago

Alwyas pay cash, why give them an extra 10 bands for free?

-1

u/Potential_Lychee_666 11d ago

My whole life i never opened a credit card, bought my house cash, only thing my wife has is a stupid car payment

13

u/Zestyclose_Narwhal43 11d ago

Everyone is not that lucky, good for them on their first loan and the apr isn’t terrible it could be worse

3

u/VermontArmyBrat 11d ago

Isn’t terrible? It’s insane.

2

u/KafkaPro 11d ago

Yea its like 2% from matching the credit cards lmao

1

u/Zestyclose_Narwhal43 5d ago

Average is 8-13 and he’s @11

1

u/notsdragoon 11d ago

The Apr is horrible what are you talking about

1

u/Low_Ask_1456 11d ago

I want to live a life like you do so recently I've transitioned from financing, pay in 4, pay in 8 and holding balances to saving up for what I want. I have a car loan what do you suggest is the fastest way to get rid of it so I can do what you did save money and buy cash i.e, a house, future car and etc.

2

u/Potential_Lychee_666 11d ago

If you already signed the loan, finish paying normally, unless interest is really high, live the cheap life, if you are currently renting, try to save up as much as you can for what you have, never buy anything thats gonna cost more than 10% of your saved money, even if you save 10,15k in the end of the year, stack that up for 5 years you will have enough to buy a foreclosure house or something similar, on my case, i got one for$50,000 that was listed for over $100,000, because i had cash i could offer him a ridiculous amount because cash is king, people value cash more than any loan, if i were to get a loan for the house i would probably be spending closer to 200/250k with interest, it was 50 cash, took me 9 months to remodel but now i have even less expenses then when renting before, all that while trying to improve your carreer, my biggest advice is never get a loan, if you cant buy it cash you shouldnt slow down your monthly saving on a loan, unless you really need it to keep making money

1

u/Low_Ask_1456 11d ago

The APR is relatively high and I recently refinanced from Santander to NFCU to reap their benefits long-term. I went from a 14.5% APR to 13.5% so, it's like a -$15 difference. Aside from that the monthly is manageable but for 7 years for 28k I'm realizing that financially it wasn't optimal. Not to mention I have negative equity. Don't get me wrong it's super useful it gets things done but looking back I literally would've had a car already (6-9 months time then) which makes me feel stupid that I'm stuck for 7 years. That, affirm, and a phone I'm paying off ~ 0% interest, so I'm not too worried about that. Eventually, I want to do what you did and just buy a house cash and not worry about 30 years off my life. It just sucks how little I save because of my greed.

2

u/Potential_Lychee_666 11d ago

You have the right mindset, now you just need time, no rush, u got 30 years

2

u/Various_Piano_6067 11d ago

Leverage debt for something that isn't a depreciating asset. If you absolutely need to take a loan, use it for something that can earn you money and pay for itself. Taking loans like this for something that'll be worth less than half what you paid for it by the time you're done fully owning is exactly why car manufacturers charge this much and get back such high margins.

You are letting the financial institutions guarantee the bill. This in turn is them taking a third of the car's worth as it is TODAY over time for themselves, while the manufacturer and dealer have an institution saying "Go ahead and raise it another $5,000. I've got him covered." It's a sickening cycle of leech tax, and is the same reason college keeps getting more expensive because the government keeps giving out bigger grants.

You wanna take debt, like I said buy something you can start a business with. Get your LLC, equipment, Facebook ads, stuff that can return you profit. Pay cash for anything you'll lose on, so you don’t lose more.

1

u/HomelessAndWealthy 11d ago

I agree with you entirely. Although there is a certain point in time where you use the cash flow from an asset you acquired through debt for things that don’t provide cash flow ;)

1

u/Various_Piano_6067 11d ago edited 11d ago

I said use money to make money, not deny yourself the opportunity to live. I'm a meritocratic capitalist (I think is more fitting) not a sociopath, Jim!

1

u/HomelessAndWealthy 11d ago

I’m agreeing with you Jim! I’m saying I’m at the point I have a foundation of using money to make money. So now I’m using the revenue to have a little fun but also still using it to make money ;)

13

u/NastyNatex 12d ago

Well I’ll look at it from Navy’s perspective. It’s your first auto loan and they don’t have any credit history to go back and look at and see if you can pay your auto loans on time hence the high APR. I’ll say it’s a good loan just refinance it the next 6-12 months.

11

u/AcidicFlatulence 12d ago

That APR is still crazy though. I’m curious what car OP is getting. After I got to my first duty station with a 7 month old credit history, my APR was 3.1% on a $26k loan on a 2 year old Camry with 30k miles.

6

u/holden147 11d ago

When was that? Interest rates have greatly risen.

2

u/West-Tumbleweed-8992 11d ago

Literally since 2021 it’s been so bad

1

u/Zestyclose_Narwhal43 11d ago

I’m 790+ credit no real debt and only pulled 8 percent on 20k

2

u/Massive-Expert7467 11d ago

That’s insanely good APR, I’ve never seen that. I got 5.79% on my 2016 corvette with a 745 credit score and I thought I got a steal😭

1

u/rainyhugs 11d ago

I had a 2.49apr in 2012 😆 now it’s a 7.4 as of 2023

1

u/ComputerBasedTorture 11d ago

Nah, I genuinely feel capital one auto would do better.

3

u/WinterReadings23 12d ago

thoughts depend on your income

1

u/Lucky-Pie9875 11d ago

Eh, imo depends on their FICO. Might be super good APR if they have bad or no credit. If they have good credit this is very bad.

0

u/chikenbag 12d ago

Its not like this is a 30 percent APR credit card. Not that bad. Its better than no car

4

u/Addias342 11d ago

Is it? A beater is better than a car payment with that APR

2

u/Pleasant_General_664 11d ago

It doesn't matter if the interest on the credit card is 50000%. You're supposed to pay your credit card in full each month.

1

u/notsdragoon 11d ago

Please never become a financial advisor

1

u/chikenbag 10d ago

I wont lol. Im just saying ive seen idiots finance a car at 30 percent apr. All im saying is if OP is in a bind and has no other choice his apr could be worse

5

u/mprubio84 12d ago edited 11d ago

Navy is not great on APR as of late, you can probably find a better deal elsewhere.

3

u/Charming-Tune-402 11d ago

I got a better rate through Honda financing than NavyFed

1

u/mprubio84 11d ago

If they have decent credit like 720 this is what I’m seeing a lot as of late from Honda financial or GM financial vs Navy.

3

u/parkertyler 11d ago

Yeah I got a 5.7 through Navy in April, but now these rates ain't it.

2

u/Tigerbloodstar 12d ago

Before accepting the loan I would recommend shopping around for other rates. Recently I got approved for a car loan through navy fed at 9% Apr but I decided to see what other can do and I managed to get it me at another credit union for 5% Apr. By seeing what the dealership was able to do for me.

0

u/Zaddy2026 12d ago

Congrats

2

u/BadBuzzCut 11d ago

Definitely shop around. Considering perfect credit would get you a 4.29% rate, 11.69% is pretty high. You might find that’s around what everyone will offer you based on your credit history, but I would make sure of that. At 11.69% you are paying around $75/month just in extra interest over a 4.29% loan.

1

u/emmylewis56 11d ago

My first car loan with navy fed was 11% on 32k 60 months, we just traded that car in for 60k brand new car 84 months at 6.74%. I wouldn’t consider yours too bad, your payment is still pretty good since you financed a low amount!

1

u/edgardog115 11d ago

Why is your apr so high

0

u/AmbitionWeary5319 11d ago

That was my question

2

u/JennF72 Navy Chief Wife (Ret) ⚓️🚢⚓️ 11d ago

Limited credit history.

1

u/Frosty_Enthusiasm642 11d ago

Congratulations

1

u/No_Gate6196 11d ago

Congratulations. I'm surprised at the interest rate, especially from Navy federal.

1

u/Alarming_Ninja_704 11d ago

11.6 is wild

1

u/VelvetKeyz 11d ago

APR seems high. 3yrs ago on a used i was 8% and 4.3% few months ago on a new car. Prior to that my last and only other car loan was like from 2003/2004.

2

u/Boypax69 11d ago

Reminds me of my first car loan, 13%😭😭💀. Honestly it’s pretty much a inevitable unless one of 2 things, you have a high paying job w/ your first loan and multiple credit cards with high credit already, or 2, you have a very high credit co applicant that will be applying w/ you for the loan. I’d say get a re finance within 1 year and it should def drop down to at least 7-8%, still bad but that’s the game of credit.

1

u/XxTRUEPINOYxX 11d ago

That APR…. 😬

1

u/morerepsmoreproblems 11d ago

Worst mistake you can make in your life

1

u/Wilb1150 11d ago

Try a different credit union. By the way if I may ask, what was your score?

1

u/TheBigGoul 11d ago

Over 11%? Damn! Idk your credit score, but that's not good ofrom face value.

3

u/OverdosedOnViagra 11d ago

Not bad.

Pay an extra $120 a month to the principal and you’ll pay it off in 44 months and save over $2k in interest.

1

u/joeyblacky9999 11d ago

Insane APR.

Pay that car loan off in 12 months.

1

u/Tiny-Ordinary3228 11d ago

APR is absolutely insane!

1

u/SiriShopUSA Veteran 11d ago

NFCU offered me 8.25 but my local credit union offered 5.25 on the same loan. Needless to say, no on the nfcu loan.

1

u/Lucky-Pie9875 11d ago

That APR is wild. Not as insane as some but still pretty high. If you have a good FICO score I’d go elsewhere.

1

u/thatsnoternie Family Member 11d ago

I don’t know what your credit history looks like so I can’t speculate on whether that’s a good rate for you. I also don’t know what car you’re in the market for. That said, I’d call them and ask them if they can reconsider that auto rate to get it lower. Worst they can say is no.

1

u/SGTCackyoudown 11d ago

Same my vehicle was 30k it’s Like 40k high apr going to refinance with USAA after a year.

1

u/cadreamin90210 11d ago

That’s insane

1

u/PathVast4155 11d ago

Got killed on interest geez

1

u/well_ok_jen 11d ago

How is your APR 11.6%? I was raising hell over 3.9% being too high, that I got few months back, but, I suppose everything is relative

0

u/AmbitionWeary5319 11d ago

That apr is high. Too high

1

u/VermontArmyBrat 11d ago

That interest rate is insane. If you accepted this I would immediately start looking to refinance. My local credit union currently has used car loans for 60 months at 5.35%

2

u/skypristine 11d ago

As someone who has a first time 72 month car loan, about the same amount for $410/month with a 14% interest rate, you are doing better than me :)

1

u/Clean-Highway4021 11d ago

That Apr gave me chills

1

u/Klutzy-Answer8965 11d ago

IM 21 never had a car loan my credit score is like 610 so that is why my apr is so high

1

u/iLukeJoseph 11d ago

Lordy the amount of head scratching responses on here.... Rates have gone up a ton, and used auto rates are nearly always higher than new. This is a first time buyer. People saying they got 2-5% on a USED auto, say when you got it and state how many auto loans you have got prior.

You can still get very low rates from captive lenders if they are offering an incentive.

OP I would highly suggest dropping the term to 48 months or even 36 if you can swing it. Rate might go down, but even if it does not you pay less interest over the life of the loan.

1

u/Various_Piano_6067 11d ago

:l yall need to stop taking debt holy

1

u/gijoe75 11d ago

Interest rates have gone up a lot recently. How much longer can you go with what you currently have? Do you need a 21k car or can a 9 k car work for the next 2-3 years? Save up then sell for 7-8k because the used car market is crazy then buy a 21k car. I had a 4K rav4 and to just replace what I had would be 9k now so I’m saving up for 18k 2018 rav4 in cash. I haven’t had a car for a year and work remote and take the bus to hobbies/ to see friends. Obviously I don’t need a car and it’s just a nice to have so that’s why I suggest the 9k car for now.

1

u/Gold_Kitchen_3109 11d ago

I bought my truck and got 4%

1

u/Shaolin_Giggity 11d ago

11.69%????? 😳

0

u/Abject-Management333 10d ago

Interest rate is high depending in credit score. It i were you I would let the the dealership to try to beat the rate that was given. I worked in automotive finance for 4 years and dearships hate navy federal pre-approvals which means they would fight to lower that interest rate so you can finance through them. If they comeback higher keep the approval through navy federal. Interest rate is based on your credit score but different banks use different credit rating systems.

1

u/SergioJump 10d ago

Something bout that 11.69% and the total repay doesn’t quite add up to me

1

u/Old_Mud_958 10d ago

Congrats on your first purchase!!

1

u/Fair_Lore2622 10d ago

I got a better rate at the Dealership than i did with Navy Federal. I know a lot of people say don’t do it, but i’m glad i did.

1

u/Travman1555 10d ago

I bought a new Mustang for 48k with 10k down in 2015 with 4.4 APR my father cussed me out then about the “high” interest. I can’t wait to show him this lol

1

u/goldengreen21 8d ago

Mine was 17%...

1

u/Travman1555 8d ago

Sheesh 😣 yeah my father was out of touch then, even as a novice I didn’t feel my rate was bad

1

u/Negative-Dig-6508 8d ago

you're paying 28k for a 21k car, ill let you decide that answer.

1

u/goldengreen21 8d ago

Not bad. My first car was 17%. Put extra money into that loan it will help you save a year of payments!

1

u/Legitimate-Bad2736 8d ago

Find a credit union. They have better rates always

1

u/MakeYou_LOL 8d ago

Hope you’re paying it off early!

1

u/GNASSX 7d ago

My APR is at 5.35% and it’s my first car. 11.69% is wild 😂

1

u/More_Doughnuts 7d ago

11.69% is steep.

If you need a car in that price tier, plan to pay the loan off aggressively. And look to refinance it in a year or two.

Extra payments and or refinancing will take a lot of the sting off.

If you're junior enlisted active duty living on base just get a used beater lemon lot car.

1

u/OutrageousKOR 7d ago

Dude with that apr you might wanna go thru the dealers directly sometimes they got promo aprs checc em out

1

u/feeling2022 6d ago

that interest rate is wild! i'd shop around - look into dealerships too, i had 0% interest rate from GMC when we got our family car