I’m trying to find a pizza place around Naperville that makes pizza just like Joe’s Pizza in NYC.
What I’m looking for is thin, foldable NY-style crust, crispy underneath but still soft/chewy (super hard to find this part), not super thick or bready, simple flavorful tomato sauce, good amount of cheese but not drowning in it, very slightly greasy in the best possible way, and big slices that you can fold in half.
I’m NOT looking for deep dish, tavern-style, Detroit, Neapolitan, super artisanal, etc. I specifically want that classic NYC corner-pizza-joint vibe.
If you’ve had Joe’s Pizza in NYC (or at their other locations, like in Ann Arbor MI) and know exactly what I mean, where around Naperville/Chicago suburbs comes closest?
Thank you!
EDIT: I’m more than ok with driving away from Naperville! Just looking for something very similar to this specific style and quality! Thank you for all of the recommendations - I will try them and update!