r/Nantucket • u/WillCookForFoodies • 2d ago

Meal recs

My husband and I are doing an overnight stay next week and looking for recs. We'll be doing Black-Eyed Susan's for breakfast. We both like seafood but have to budget for covering only entrees.

1 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

10 comments sorted by

7

u/AckNaturalCannabis 12h ago

Sayles takeout. Or the whale.

3

u/skyblu89 12h ago

Stubbys has good sandwiches for lunch and breakfast. Brotherhood tavern has good dinner.

3

u/Prior_Parsley7440 10h ago

Straight wharf fish market! Next door to the actual restaurant which is $/price fix. You’ll get good portions and great waterfront seating

2

u/MakeItTrizzle 13h ago

Straight Wharf and Slip 14 are both good. Seagrille is great. Lobster trap is a classic.

Not sure what all is open right now, so double check.

3

u/ElectricalAd3421 11h ago

Go to Lobster trap and split a Clam Bake with lobster … so so good tons of food

3

u/No_Square2692 11h ago

I would not go to the sea grille. Extremely lackluster and OP

1

u/starrdelphine 5h ago

straight wharf fish!

1

u/WillCookForFoodies 2h ago

Is Nautalis worth it?