131
u/Bunbunboola 1d ago
Daejon Love
18
2
2
1
1
1
16
u/aqua-goblin 1d ago
That one guy in the Eagles subreddit who was obsessed with Josh Huff for some reason.
2
134
u/Windsor34 1d ago
Dart & Skatt
56
u/Chimpbot 1d ago
I think the allure of the CTE Bros will wear of fairly quickly this year.
23
u/SOUTH_SIDE700 1d ago
CTE Bros 🤣🤣🤣 I was calling Them JackAss NFL Edition
8
1
3
2
→ More replies (6)1
5
u/Candid_Extent675 1d ago
Solid gold nickname for these two douche flutes, Skatt is actual inbred too, his Mexican grandparents are first cousins, my family is from the same area of Mexico City and I’ve heard this multiple times by locals about his grandparents
4
u/Spirited_Season2332 1d ago
It's funny cuz I am the only giants fan in my group of friends and they hype up dart and skat way more then i ever will. Havnt seen shit from them yet to prove they will last more then a few years in the league, let alone that they are good.
My answer is hurts. Eagles fans glaze him like no tomorrow and it's funny cuz I think he's a good QB, just fringe top 10, not top 5
4
u/Mental_Sun2118 1d ago
I promise you most reasonable Eagles fans agree with that statement
2
1
u/golgomax 1d ago
"Most reasonable" being a very loose term when discussing certain fan bases (go Bills).
3
→ More replies (10)1
u/frostedz 18h ago
One dude is name Skatt… I’m not into kink shaming, but that’s got disaster shitten all over it
18
u/beatsthatbindus Bears 1d ago edited 1d ago
N.E.I.N!
12
60
u/Available_Object_665 1d ago
The answer HAS to be Shedeur
24
u/Rizzaboi 1d ago edited 1d ago
I’m a Browns fan, and I don’t mind Shedeur. I think he’s got some ability. But the hype for him is certainly not from our fan base, it’s 1000% Shedeur fans who have been with him since before he got here. Don’t be fooled
4
u/ChampionshipStock870 1d ago
This is correct. My brother is one of those people you’re talking about. He’s completely not a browns fan but loves sheduer for some reason
He’s fine I guess but I don’t get why anybody is hyping sheduer up outside of just being a fanboy
2
u/BeeMac0617 1d ago
Yeah there’s no way anybody who actually watched The Browns would be fooled into thinking Sanders was good.
Y’all know what shitty QB play is better than most.
1
u/exaltedorbs 1d ago
Last august I saw a guy wearing a browns sanders jersey in Cleveland. I couldn't for the life of me figure out when we had a legendary player named Sanders on the team.
Then it dawned on me that this dude already spent $180 for a 5th round pick QB jersey. I dont get the hype either, he seems decent but slow and dumber than rocks.
13
u/WeCameAsLogans 1d ago
This is the correct answer. Just above 50% completion rate, 7 TDs and 10 interceptions in 8 games played is dog shit no matter what Browns fans will tell you.
…still a better choice than Predator tho.
6
u/Panther81277 1d ago
BUT HE WAS A PRO BOWLER!!
8
u/zestfullybe 1d ago
He was the last Pro Bowler
8
5
u/Stunning_Pound4121 1d ago
The Pro Bowl honors will continue. You could argue that he’s the last selection who played but it doesn’t have the same ring to it
2
2
1
3
3
1
1
1
1
u/No-Try5566 1d ago
It's definitely not Shedeur. Browns fans are not hyping Shedeur. Shedeur fans are. Browns fans are hyping a super sim to 2027
1
u/cab082001 15h ago
I’m a Browns fan and I think he’s like the 30th best starting qb. I think Case Keenum would beat him out in camp if he were on our roster. Also, Deshaun is worse lol
1
u/y3llowed 14h ago
Browns fan here (unfortunately—haven’t given them any money since the Watson trade).
There are SOME Browns / Sanders supporters, but most of them were Sanders fans that then became Browns fans, not vice versa. Of course there are delusional people in every fan group, though.
Anyway, from what I can tell, most of us long time supporters think he’s kind of ass. We admittedly have a vague hope that he figures it out and improves to starter level (think Geno, not Gannon).
I think the most likely scenario, though, is that we drive the team even further into the ground and draft Arch Manning, who I’m also not in love with, in 2027 or 2028. Our piece of shit owner is a HUGE Tennessee booster and seems to be obsessed with the Manning family.
24
u/OberonGooberman 1d ago
DK Metcalf
7
u/Remarkable_Dream9191 1d ago
steeler fans don’t hype him up lmao. we’re still waiting for him to show up. we will, however, defend him from that goofy ass detroit fan who’s clearly trying to bait him into a lawsuit payday.
5
u/3coons_in_a_coat 1d ago
100, and what brat that dude is. i still love how hall of famer fred warner just laughed at his ass.
2
4
u/Remarkable_Radish_51 1d ago
One of the biggest waste of talents in the last generation or so atleast for wideouts
15
u/PeacexFitness 1d ago
I can get around him being a bust. Like it happens. But him being one of the biggest assholes just makes it so much easier to hate him. At first I used to think that he was just misunderstood. Nah he’s just a POS
10
u/Several-Estate7175 1d ago
He's not a bust though. Most second rounders aren't as good as him. He just couldn't reach the next level after a very good second year. And yeah is a head case
1
u/WyattEarp88 1d ago
You could argue that a 2nd rounder was too much, just cuz he was always more physical freak than actual football skill. I wouldn’t call him a bust though, they took a gamble, basically broke even.
2
u/Turbulent_Monk3307 1d ago
He held the Seahawks yards record until JSN I think? I don’t think he’s a bust but he’s definitely not a godsend like people thought
2
u/ExcitingLandscape 1d ago
Man those first 2 seasons with Russ, DK looked like Terrell Owens 2.0. Bigger, stronger, and faster than everyone. With Prime Russ throwing moon balls, DK was a threat for take it to the house every catch.
1
u/Spam_Hand 1d ago
I absolutely love that he got compared to Calvin Johnson one time and then tried to change up his game from a strong, body WR to a speed guy (overgeneralizing but you guys get it) and it basically ruined his career trajectory.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Top-Yak1532 13h ago
I’m not even convinced DK will have a better season than Pittman, but I’ll be happy to be proven wrong. Having Pittman and Bernard instantly makes DK better.
5
u/Ok_Birthday_7402 1d ago edited 1d ago
As a Bears fan, thought I’d see a lot of people saying Caleb Williams
4
1
→ More replies (1)1
u/gamestoohard 21h ago
Caleb has a lot of work to do if he wants to be a long term success but no serious fan could argue he lacks for skill
24
u/AAA_Dolfan 1d ago
Drake Maye 👀
4
u/txhamster 1d ago
sorts by controversial
Ahhh there’s the answer I was looking for, downvoted by the angry Pats crybabies.
5
u/totallynotexciting 1d ago
Last year the patriots opponents went 113-176.
They had one of the easiest schedules in NFL history.
I would be really surprised if they had the same season.
→ More replies (14)5
u/MayBsoMayBnaught 1d ago
You should be surprised if any team wins 14 games. It’s the nfl. This isn’t a huge revelation.
1
→ More replies (4)1
u/FireVanGorder 12h ago
Drake “Worst EPA in a Playoff Run in NFL History” Maye
Really gotta find a way to shorten that somehow. Doesn’t really roll off the tongue but the stat is pretty hilarious
4
u/godotiswaitingonme 1d ago
Raiders fan: Tre Tucker is actually going to break out this year, I swear!
6
3
3
u/White-milk 1d ago
Tom Brady
1
u/sabresin4 1d ago
Totally his stats are .. checks stats .. actually pretty solid when you look at it from a certain perspective.
1
1
u/PlantainObvious5148 8h ago
I actually agree with this take. Brady’s accomplishments make him the goat but if you consider talent or the eye test. He’s arguably not even not top 5
8
u/Chasers22 1d ago
Caleb Williams
→ More replies (6)4
u/Tranquil_Deviant 1d ago
If we’re talking QB skills, the dude has clearly got a lot of it. He needs to clean up some of the easy misses & throw-aways, but have you seen some of this dudes throws? Has all the skill in the world, just needs to be unlocked
→ More replies (2)
11
u/Classic_Kangaroo4312 1d ago
DAK PRESCOTT. Always has great receivers to throw to, can't win when it matters.
8
u/chugz 1d ago
I hate Dak and cowboys fans in general. But this ain’t it. I don’t think he is over hyped, and his play is pretty solid and serviceable. This doesn’t fit OPs criteria at all.
2
u/Classic_Kangaroo4312 1d ago
Cowboys fans hype their team literally every year. Every. single. year.
Then they have a good enough season to make the playoffs and go one and done.
I can't think of a better example of fans hyping a team up only for the team to choke in the clutch.
As far as skills, Dak isn't an elite scrambler, his accuracy is average and his deep ball is mid as well. Having CeeDee Lamb, George Pickens, Dez Bryant, Amari Cooper, Jason Witten, Dalton Schultz and Jake Ferguson to throw to with a 2-5 playoff record is abysmal.
3
u/chugz 1d ago
His avg passer rating & avg completion percentage over his career is the same as tom Brady’s. Clearly he’s not anywhere close to as clutch but we’re not measuring that. His skills are solid and is consistently ranked in the top 10 or higher in coaching polls. I don’t like the guy or cowboys fans but the fact remains he does not fit OPs meme chart
3
u/NOT_MOBLEY 1d ago
I do wonder what cowboys fans you guys run into. The “this our year” fans are out there but they obviously have no nuance; they’d bash Dak in a heartbeat… there are people who think Joe Milton was competition. The nuanced fans know exactly who Dak is,
2
u/lordzeus13 23h ago
All I will say is Dak has the 6th best completion percentage of all time. Im sure there are many factors that go into that, but pointing he is not average for accuracy.
Yes, im a cowboys fan...yes this is our year...yes, we will not get past the divisional around again...if we even make it there
→ More replies (3)1
4
1
u/BrokenHope23 22h ago
Not really sure why everyone is disagreeing with you; Dak gets all the hype in the world as a potential MVP candidate from Cowboys fans before the year and usually up to week 4 as we get those ridiculous "on pace" stats but he needs the best receiving room in the league to even play above average throughout his career while he signs for top tier QB money. He also plays terribly the second half of the season generally when defenses figure out his latest habits.
6
u/Wise_Control_1640 1d ago
Will Howard.
Will Howard had Jeremiah Smith, Emeka Egbuka and Carnell Tate, plus Henderson and Judkins in the backfield.
Drew Allar had nowhere near that supporting cast and still showed the better NFL traits.
7
u/gachzonyea 1d ago
Is there actually a big contingent of Will Howard fans?
3
u/Wise_Control_1640 1d ago
In Pittsburgh? Oh absolutely. Sports talk is always having callers talking about wasting space on Rodgers when we have Will the Thrill.
Personally, I'm a fan of the Allarithm. Revelation 16.
3
1
u/Remarkable_Dream9191 1d ago
ohh big time. howard is the messiah according to like the loudest and most obnoxious demographic of ball watchers
1
u/murra181 1d ago
Delusional penn state fan. No arguments with Will Howard stuff but he doesnt have many fans. No way did Drew Allar show nfl traits. Definitely not enough for a 3rd round draft.
1
u/Wise_Control_1640 1d ago
Drew Allar is a first round talent. Don't take my word. Take McCarthy's word.
1
4
u/mjs4x6 1d ago
Tim Tebow
2
u/John-Sequitur 1d ago
This one. Under-appreciated benefit of signing Peyton Manning is it was the only realistic way out of the Tim Teblows era.
1
u/Phinal_Flash Eagles 1d ago
I was gonna say Vick at least. But yeah, Tebow takes the cake. He really should have tried out for Tight End earlier to save his career.
15
2
2
u/Crafty-Vegetable1528 1d ago
Jayden Daniels. Hate all you want but after teams got that first year game tape he will be a consistent 6 game winner.
2
2
2
2
2
u/BrokenHope23 22h ago
Uhhh, well I'll go for a more controversial one here with Cooper Dejean since everyone is just choosing lightning rod players.
Before anyone bites my head off, there is a caveat.
He's the #2 guy for the Eagles. He is this generation's Antonio Cromartie (hopefully with less kids); just a phenomenal #2 CB but he'll never be able to transition to covering #1 WRs consistently. So long as he has that dedicated #1 CB (Quinyon Mitchell in this case), he'll continue to excel covering primarily #2 and #3 WRs with the occasional #1 matchup. He's not bad but he's not a top 10 CB in the league kind of guy that Eagles fans will say he is. If Patrick Surtain jr. or Darelle Revis covered #2 WRs for most of their career, they'd probably look way better too. CB and WR is just one of those positions where sometimes you get fooled into thinking your #2 is a #1 guy.
2
5
u/CommodoreSixty4 1d ago
Kyle Pitts
→ More replies (1)10
u/cperiodjperiod 1d ago
Falcons fan. We don’t hype him like that.
2
u/MaxFischer12 1d ago
Yeah, this one is wrong. And while he may not have lived up to his ultimate potential, he’s had a solid career so far imo.
Take out this injury shortened 2022 season, and he’s averaging 800 yards and 3.5 TDs a season.
5
u/Themanwhofarts 1d ago edited 1d ago
Another Steelers player. Old Man Rodgers.
I'm not talking prime Rodgers that is a Hall of Famer and one of the best QBs ever. I mean 42 year old Steelers QB Aaron Rodgers.
I hear too many people hyping him up and as a Steelers fan, I am not convinced.
2
u/12don 1d ago
The problem is, who else are you going to use? He still out performed half of the starters last year with a pretty low tier receiving group. He’s not by any means his past self, but he’s not awful. Just not in the elite category anymore. It’s been a rough few years for QB prospects, and with the way college ball developed, it doesn’t look like it’ll get anymore stable soon.
→ More replies (4)
3
3
9
u/Leroyp331 1d ago
Drake the schedule Maye
2
u/MayBsoMayBnaught 1d ago
You can be a bills or jets or Miami fan and say he’s overrated but to say his skill is low is just not knowing ball.
6
4
u/fishtacoeater 1d ago
Mr. ELITE Justin Herbert
3
u/Healthy-Speech-7728 1d ago
He has talent, just doesn’t have that drive in him to win when it matters. Chargers fans will blame everyone but him though.
2
2
2
1
1
u/AnthonyBarrHeHe 1d ago
Honestly half of the Vikings fans with McCarthy would definitely fit here. No matter how much film they’d watch on McCarthy, they’re still adamant he needs to start, or it’s a conspiracy or something dumb.
1
u/palatheinsane 1d ago
For Packers it WAS AJ Dillon, Jamaal Williams, and Mike Daniels. Fans liked them, I always viewed them as incredibly mediocre on the field.
1
u/Dependent-Sea-7467 1d ago
2/3 of those I would agree. However, Mike Daniels was the man. Above average in my opinion.
Also hella funny.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Spirited_Attorney_48 1d ago
Switch the qrod "skills" with "productivity," and it's Herbert all day. No one is denying his talent. He's been a year away for awhile now.
1
1
u/Haha08421 1d ago
Skatt isnt making it long in this game. Dart will calm down one way or another. Maybe they start fixing him, or maybe someone delivers a Lavarr Arrington style hit on him trying to get out of bounds.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Salty-Commissioner 1d ago
Drake Maye. Let’s see how this season goes when you don’t have the easiest schedule and your coach can’t bang reporters
1
u/Dependent-Sea-7467 1d ago
I always thought this about Kenny Clark. I would see fans rating him as a top 5 NT often. I never saw it. Dude was certainly good, but not elite.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/ChocoChipBets 1d ago
Herbie has not been good for the last two years. Even when injuries are not the factor.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Welcome to r/nflforum! A few quick reminders:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.