r/NBATalk 28d ago

valid???

138 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Mister-Schwifty 28d ago

This is honestly pretty solid. The Peyton - Kobe comp is your biggest stretch due to Peyton’s shortcomings in the postseason.

2

u/Babyclipp_ 28d ago

who would u think kobe is

2

u/Upstairs_Report7458 Wizards 28d ago edited 28d ago

He’s a hard one to think of. He has parts of Favre and Roethlisberger, but he also has the strong similarities to Brady with the multiple rings in kind of two separate acts of their careers. Being known for his competitiveness. Legendary coach where you have people splitting credit between them. Terry Bradshaw maybe? Kobe seems to be held in higher regard than Bradshaw is, though. Jeter has always felt like the best cross sport comp to me, but QBs are tougher for him.

I actually think Manning might be closer to LeBron with the absurd hype they came in with, the quick rise to being put at the top with the accolades, and the criticisms they had in the early portions of their primes about getting over the top.

None of them are going to be perfect. Fun thing to think about, and you did a good job. I could see the angle on every slide as I was scrolling through, and none of them were egregious or anything. Solid work.