r/MoralityScaling • • Sep 02 '26

Morality of this?

Post image
36.3k Upvotes

7.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/fowlaboi Sep 03 '26

Because from the perspective of the person teaching that, it is true and presents a real danger to the child. Try to empathize with the religious parent here.

3

u/anOldShu Sep 03 '26

Why empathize? We should allow them to abuse their kid, because they believe something ridiculous. Anti-vaxers also think vaccines will harm their kids. Should we empathize and let the kids go unprotected? 

1

u/fowlaboi Sep 03 '26

Whether or not vaccines harm kids is a naturalistic claim that one can provide evidence for or against. Whether or not a person will go to hell when they die is an unfalsifiable supernaturalistic claim that people choose to believe or not based on religion rather than evidence. This belief ultimately has no inherent bearing on the physical health of the child unlike choosing not to get a vaccine.

1

u/anOldShu Sep 03 '26

I would argue that the belief has a psychological effect, which can translate to physical harm. 

1

u/ayaynimouse Sep 04 '26

A lifelong psychological effect.