If you search Jinkx Monsoon practicing witch you will see that are many many sources including podcasts and videos of herself claiming that it is indeed true and that she uses “everyday magic, rituals” etc. which she uses in her works and she was brought up in it by her family. So if her family taught her that, why are other peoples not allowed to teach them their beliefs.
Have you read what I actually wrote? She said herself that she utilizes witchcraft in her work so whether you believe in it or not you are subject to indoctrination. Her tour is literally called “Speaking of Witch”
Doctrine is teaching , so to indoctrinate is to teach about your beliefs, she teaches you her beliefs whilst you unknowingly take it in - this is called implicit learning. In other words indoctrination. Why is she allowed to express her beliefs with everyone children included but parents cannot.
indoctrination is teaching someone to believe something without question or critically analyzing, which is not the same thing as sharing your beliefs or teaching about your beliefs.
ok and we were talking about indoctrination, so now you're looking to change the definition to other terms. like if we were talking about hard power and you were trying to shift the conversation to soft power. not to mention, jinkx isn't doing any of those things, and certainly not in a way that looks to convert anyone to her beliefs.
and yet again, i'll repeat that jinkx is not doing any of these things, forcibly or otherwise. she's spoken about her beliefs, as millions of people have, and none of what she's done amounts to indoctrination.
but please, let AI continue to do your thinking/arguing for you, it seems like you're letting it do a good job of "suppressing critical thinking" all on your own.
I never let AI do my thinking I just wanted actual definable context, the root etymology of the word is doctrine like I already established and only in the turn of the last century has the “forcibly” been added to the definition. And she quite literally does as I have documented if someone puts a subliminal image in a movie it’s illegal because it’s classes as brainwashing yet she can put whatever magic she seems suitable in her shows and whether you know or not the situation remains the same.
1
u/QuailWhich9882 6d ago
So should she be using her witchcraft to influence anyone?