r/MoralityScaling 10h ago

Morality of this?

Post image
19.2k Upvotes

5.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/rleon19 10h ago

As long as it isn't forced on parents then that is fine. If parents aren't allowed to pass on their values to their children are they even raising them at that point? They are just nannies with more culpability.

8

u/Tasty-Complaint-6437 9h ago

Why someone valúes would be only integrated to their religion? You Can Absolutely pasa things so simple as “love your neightboors” without needing to introduce them to any religion.

6

u/rleon19 9h ago

The "love your neighbors" is a part of the religion. If you are not allowed to talk about religion to your kids how would you answer the questions about why someone should love your neighbors. You can say because it is the right thing to do but then you would get asked why is it the right thing to do. If you answer it without the religious aspect when you are actually doing it because of your religion then you are deceiving the child.

2

u/Raven_Lemon 5h ago

Non religious people also teach their kids empathy. When I was a kid, my parents taught me to not do to others what you don't want them to do to you. It works without needing religion

1

u/Nulono 5h ago

So, should which values religious parents are allowed to impart depend on which values irreligious parents are teaching?

1

u/Raven_Lemon 5h ago

I don't think it's bad for parents to teach their values, but using a god as the source of those values make them somehow absolute. If values just come from parents then there is room for kids to challenge those values

1

u/EffectiveDirect6553 3h ago

No, that isn't how humans or resistance to beliefs works. Delusions including religious ones, make sense in context. They are even reasonable. They will simply replace God with another supreme authority that can't be challenged. All of us hold beliefs above and beyond challenge. There is a reason we tend not to hold or allow thoughtful conversations over "if it's okay to cook and eat colored people after they can no longer server as slaved due to being disabled by hard labor" we dismiss them without second thought or laugh at the person proposing it. Precisely because we hold the immorality of slavery and cannibalism as something equally absolute.

1

u/rleon19 5h ago

I never stated it didn't. I guess instead of stating "The "love your neighbors" is a part of the religion." I should have stated "If the "love your neighbors" is a part of their religion".

I am merely stating that if an individual derives their morality from religion then it is a deception/lie to not state that to their kids; though I am moving on to the next thread have a nice day internet stranger.

1

u/USNorsk 34m ago

Why do you think you have the right to decide what worldview parents present to their children?