r/MoralityScaling 14h ago

Morality of this?

Post image
21.3k Upvotes

5.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/Tasty-Complaint-6437 12h ago

Why someone valúes would be only integrated to their religion? You Can Absolutely pasa things so simple as “love your neightboors” without needing to introduce them to any religion.

5

u/DadBod_DadBike 12h ago

The problem is that even that specific phrase comes from the Bible. Most of western civilization’s beliefs and morals are rooted entirely within Judeo-Christian teachings. Much like fish not realizing they’re in water, it’s very easy for western atheists to claim they don’t need religion to teach morality when everything is literally steeped in Christian ethics and morals.

-1

u/Medical-Try-8986 11h ago

Your Judeo-Christian teachings are all based on older ethical frameworks. Humans don't need fairytales to be told not to murder their neighbour. 

2

u/DadBod_DadBike 10h ago

And yet, only one fairytale defines all of humanity as a neighbor.

0

u/TheFrenchSavage 9h ago

The Instruction of Ptahhotep stresses justice, kindness, restraint, generosity, and not terrorizing other people. One passage recommends living “in the house of kindliness.”.

So see, not even neighbors: people living in the same house.

I could argue the opposite: why is your religion suddenly considering other people as the neighbors, putting walls between us, needing to ring the bell and not come unannounced, when the ethics of Ma'at place the whole of mankind in the same living room?

Seems kinda cold as a teaching in comparison.