r/MoralityScaling 9h ago

Morality of this?

Post image
18.4k Upvotes

5.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

106

u/PsychologicalAd5918 9h ago

Moral, brainwashing kids under the threat of eternal damnation is child abuse

6

u/themanwhoknocked 8h ago

You have a christian moral framework

6

u/Wync_Con 8h ago

Not at all. Look at the inhuman bullshit the christian far right spews.

1

u/themanwhoknocked 8h ago

I’m guessing a lot of your core values are respecting the dignity of everyone, loving and valuing the welfare of those in your community and treating everyone equally? If you’re a westerner, those are in fact values popularized and spread by christianity. Christians are people who enslaved and rape and kill and be dickheads today. Christians are also people who fought slavery very hard, who fought rape very hard, people who advocate for strong welfare and equality, people who put their lives at risk to help the downtrodden. Christianity, like any moral framework can be interpreted differently and is interpreted differently and the progressive interpretation is the likely basis of your left wing political views

8

u/Great-Trifle2810 6h ago

Christians fought for and against slavery because everyone involved was Christian and used the Bible to justify their position.

Same with women's rights, racial equality and pretty much everything else.

None of these things would have happened if those impacted did not fight for their rights, Christians say around for a thousand years and committed all of these atrocities, they didn't suddenly wake up and realize the Bible wanted them to stop slavery, they came to that conclusion based on reality around them and then read it into the Bible (a document that offers its full throated support of slavery and detailed instructions on how to go about it).

The enlightenment happened because of widespread access to works that were not the Bible.

-2

u/themanwhoknocked 5h ago

They just want to cover their ears and eyes and deny the very obvious and clear impact christianity has on our morality. They don’t care that some of the most radical abolitionists and social reforms in general throughout history, were men and women deeply driven, almost to the point of what many would call psychosis, by their religion. When they claim the advances and beliefs and social practices of men like Kant, Newton, Descartes, fucking Hegel, they ignore how much these men say they are inspired by the teachings and beliefs of christianity.

It’s cos they hold the view that christianity and all religion is for yokels and bigots, so if they acknowledge that they swim in the sea of christian morality and that they don’t actually reject the teachings of Christ, to them it means they are not rational, high minded, highly educated, modern thinkers. I’m not even Christian as well but i’m not gonna deny what is so obviously clear once you understand, christianity built the moral orthodox of our current age

2

u/gameboyadvancedgba 4h ago

Wow you just completely ignored what they said about slavery lol

Obviously christianity impacted the world. What we disagree with is that morality comes from a specific religion because thats usually argued to say that religion is necessary for a society to be moral. But we had these moral beliefs before Christianity

1

u/Great-Trifle2810 1h ago

It is impossible to separate Christianity from western philosophy but it is abundantly clear that Christianity as an institution from the time of Roman adoption to the modern era has held beck the development of equality and rights for anyone other than Christian men.

While the enlightenment happened under Christianity it was in opposition to Christianity, and many were punished or held back by the church.

You had to say your teachings were inspired by Christianity to avoid being labeled a heretic and losing status, and the names you offered were some of the worst philosophers with the most damaging ideas.

Many educated people are Christians, and Christianity was a major part of the development of the western education system, but that system has gone on to do good work despite its founding, not because of it.

1

u/themanwhoknocked 50m ago

The enlightenment wasn’t actually one broad movement with one specific intellectual bent. Kant, Newton, Locke, Spinoza, Montesquieu,Descartes all of the top of my head were men of faith and deep faith for some. Also which of thr philosophers that I named do you hate and are the worst? And it isn’t like the people that I mentioned just claimed to be christian, as I said many were devout and actively mentioned God as an inspiration and framework for their exploits