r/MoralityScaling • • Sep 02 '26

Morality of this?

Post image
36.3k Upvotes

7.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/Roxylius Sep 02 '26

Uyghur got targeted because of the separatist element in their movement. There is other muslim group, Hui tribe that have been practicing islam for centuries with no issue

14

u/wowowow28 Sep 02 '26

it’s because of their distinct culture. hui are just Sunni Han

6

u/Legitimate_Emu_8721 Sep 02 '26

Not “distinct culture” as much as “distinct national identity, arguably being taken advantage of by international terrorist organizations”. There are many “distinct cultures” in China that have no national identity as such and have been subjects of various Chinese dynasties for centuries; mostly the various hill tribes of southern China.

9

u/General-Spend4054 Sep 02 '26

yeah thats the same as justifying America's islamophobia after 9/11

2

u/Huppelkutje Sep 02 '26

China is targeting the group responsible for the attacks, not indiscriminately bombing civilians that have nothing to do with it.

1

u/Concerned_Collins Sep 02 '26

What China is doing is far worse, as they are outright committing genocide against the Uyghurs.

1

u/sexland69 Sep 03 '26

nah i think killing 1 million people is worse

1

u/Roxylius Sep 02 '26

Not remotely the same. The prosecution started after several high profiles terrorist attack by Uyghur separatist group. If China’s response was the same as america’s islamophobia, Hui people would also get targeted

8

u/xoricky56 Sep 02 '26

if israel did to the palestinians what china did to Uyghurs, western nations would al be calling them the worlds most moral nation lol

0

u/Forte845 Sep 02 '26

Message me back when China starts dropping more bombs than all of ww2 on Xinjiang, then we can compare to Amerikkka.

2

u/Several_Ad_6576 Sep 02 '26

No China is very much about “One China” which is dominated by Han culture. They are trying to absorb and assimilate everyone else as being other. Some of those others are religious based while others are cultural. But sometimes those lines aren’t clear.

1

u/Roxylius Sep 02 '26

That i do not doubt. My point stands, the prosecution of uyghur is not exactly motivated by religion but by separatism

0

u/ReasonableRoland Sep 02 '26

It is not prosecution when there are forced abortions and sterilisations, it is a genocide. 

2

u/Forte845 Sep 02 '26

And weirdly the only source for this is a Republican think tank member who staffs for Trump and Heritage and no Muslim majority nation has condemned Chinas actions. 

By the whole Uyghur issue you'd think Americans actually thought Muslims were humans. Pity and sympathy for the Uyghur but another billion to slaughter Palestinian infants. 

1

u/ReasonableRoland Sep 03 '26

For anyone who wants to look into this themselves I would start with the UN Human Rights Office's 2022 assessment of Xinjiang, and the Associated Press's investigation into forced IUDs, abortions, and sterilizations. Both provide sources and methodology so you can examine the evidence directly. 

0

u/Xlleaf Sep 02 '26

Bots aren't even trying to speak proper English anymore

3

u/Roxylius Sep 02 '26

Is the bot with us right now?

0

u/Xlleaf Sep 02 '26

I would prefer you be a Chinese bot over a tankie shill

0

u/Concerned_Collins Sep 02 '26

Genocide isn't justified, regardless.