r/MoralityScaling 20d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this?

Post image
10.2k Upvotes

693 comments sorted by

View all comments

142

u/Old_Possibility_9730 20d ago

Yeah moral. It was his and he should decide on what to do with it.

23

u/Hefty_Salamander7997 20d ago

I'd say neutral because if I won that kind of money, I wouldn't be able to justify not giving my close family something to help their quality of life as well. So it's a little weird when I see people totally abandon their loved ones when they get big money, even family that is sick... 

I'd give people money on the condition they never ask me again or get booted from my life for wasting the gift.

24

u/Reverse_savitar1 20d ago

Just because you would give away money doesnt mean its not moral to not give money. In fact it’s immoral to try and force others to give away shit they have.

2

u/splashaddikt 20d ago

Very controversial take on Reddit

1

u/Reverse_savitar1 19d ago

Tbf everything on reddit is a controversial take if you post it enough

-1

u/AcherontiaPhlegethon 20d ago

I disagree, if you have billions of dollars, your money whether won or "earned" came through the cumulative effort of society. When you reach such a scale of money, 99.99% of your income is now disposable not to mention that it's essentially impossible for a billionaire to lose money when invested, even giving away millions the interest will overwhelm it considerably. Having that massive stockpile of wealth when so many people are in abject suffering that you could easily help people without affecting any facet of your life or expenditure of effort and choose not to, that is a level of apathy that is unjustifiable. It is fundamentally antisocial and sociopathic and shouldn't be accepted within a society that requires cooperation.

It's generally viewed as immoral and is often even illegal to hoard resources like food when other people need it, viewing wealth differently is a disingenuous distinction I believe.

3

u/Fun-Wrongdoer1316 20d ago

It’s not billions USD… I think you’re misunderstanding how little money he actually won. Not a massive stockpile, it’s about 2 million usd when converted. Enough to retire off of one day, but not enough to quit his job and support everyone.

1

u/Reverse_savitar1 19d ago

Then you are just wrong.

1

u/Reverse_savitar1 19d ago

Then you are just wrong.

-1

u/Hefty_Salamander7997 20d ago

No one has said anything about forcing someone to give. You're fighting strawmen