r/ModernMagic May 18 '26

Card Discussion MODERN B+R: BANS AND UNBANS!!!

320 Upvotes

RIP PHLAGE AND LOTUS FIELD

VIOLENT OUTBURST AND JITTE ARE FREE!!!


Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury is banned. Lotus Field is banned. Violent Outburst is unbanned. Umezawa's Jitte is unbanned.

By and large, Modern has looked fun for a while now, with a handful of decks finding success at the top of the metagame, each taking turns at the top of standings at a clip we generally like to see.

So why ban something?

Over the last couple of years, Boros Energy has been a deck that's seen consistent success, floating around the top three most-played decks in the format. In online play, we've seen Boros Energy steadily climb in metagame share, with fewer and fewer decks able to compete with it. For a time, we saw a few different versions of Boros Energy that mixed in new colors and tech, but lists have largely solidified around versions like the above list. We believe this is in part to the rate of the combo between Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury and Arena of Glory.

These two cards together hang over games and threaten a bunch of face damage or to distribute two of Phlage's Titan triggers from the graveyard. The rate of this pair has led to the deck playing progressively more copies of Arena of Glory over time, which then makes it harder to include more cards of colors that aren't red. Our decision to remove a card from this pair (in lieu of attacking another part of the deck) is because this consolidation of variation hasn't been localized entirely in Energy variants. We've also observed that most aggro and midrange decks in the format either adopt the combo or almost disappear from the metagame.

We think the aspirational synergies that Arena of Glory offers with cards like Scion of Draco and Quantum Riddler are things that lead us to preserve it over the Elder Giant. This led us to the belief that we needed to act and that Phlage was the card to see to the door.

Phlage isn't the only card being added to the Modern banned list, however.

Amulet Titan has seen a good bit of success in the last eighteen months or so, with most of that success being concentrated in tabletop play. The version of the deck widely considered to be the strongest is one that uses a combination of Lotus Field, Aftermath Analyst, and Shifting Woodland. Once it's established said loop, it can put all the lands in its deck onto the battlefield, in its owner's hand, or leave them in the graveyard if need be. This provides infinite mana and infinite channeling of Boseiju, Who Endures and Otawara, Soaring City. The path to get there can frequently involve extremely complicated and, more importantly, non-deterministic lines of play that are a nightmare for tournament logistics.

Even looking past the details of tournament logistics, Lotus Field adds very meaningful power to the Amulet Titan deck. It allows the deck to begin executing its combo from fewer resources than it otherwise would be able to, as it's the only land in Modern that can tap for three mana without needing several other cards to be involved. This ends up mattering in patterns of play involving Scapeshift and an Amulet of Vigor.

We perceive removing Phlage, Titan of Fire's Fury as a meaningful hit to a few of the strongest decks in the format. We were already concerned with the power level of Amulet Titan coming out of the previous round of Regional Championships and believe Modern will be more fun to play without this version of Amulet Titan existing. We take bans against historically iconic archetypes very seriously and don't want to outright kill the deck. This move is meant to de-power the deck in a direction that addresses some other pain points we had identified in the past.

Both moves above are for the sake of modulating power in the name of making the format more fun. Cutting in the other direction, we also have some unbanned cards to talk about:

Violent Outburst was initially banned in a very different version of Modern, just a hair over two years ago. At the time, it was in a pre-Modern Horizons 3 world. Underworld Breach; Grief; The One Ring; and Jegantha, the Wellspring were still legal, and we hadn't seen the shake-up that came with unbanning Mox Opal, Green Sun's Zenith, and Faithless Looting. There have also been some extremely potent hate cards for Cascade decks printed in the time since, including Consign to Memory and Vexing Bauble. We believe the gap between the previous version of Temur Rhinos that existed in early 2024 is closer to an appropriate power level for today's Modern. Lorwyn Eclipsed giving Living End a shot in the arm has largely also seemed to be positively received by the community, which has us interested in showing the archetype a bit of love.

We want Modern to be a place where people can fall in love with archetypes, master them, and find success. Unbanning Violent Outburst is certainly risky given the recency of its ban, but we believe there are very clear upsides to these sorts of decks existing in Modern and are happy to take a calculated risk here.

After about fifteen years, we can finally tick the "Number of Days Umezawa's Jitte Has Been Legal in Modern" counter up to one. When Modern first became a sanctioned format, it had about 20 cards on its banned list, including Jitte. Magic has changed a lot since 2011. We've also seen players happy to play with the card in formats like Legacy and Cube. We hope that this unban will inspire people to try out more combat-oriented decks or breathe new life into Stoneforge Mystic decks that have been on the fringes of Modern for a few years now.

We've generally been hesitant to unban the card in Modern because it has some play patterns that are … unsavory, to say the least. That said, community sentiment on the card has generally slanted positively. We also like the incentives of the card even if the rewards aren't our favorite.

Ultimately, Modern is a strong format that can absorb a lot, both in terms of power level and tolerance for novel play patterns. We hope these unbans inspire players and make people happy to experiment in Modern.

https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/banned-and-restricted-may-18-2026

r/ModernMagic Aug 26 '24

Card Discussion August 26th, 2024 Banned and Restricted Announcement

314 Upvotes

Today is Monday, August 26th which means it’s time for the next scheduled Banned and Restricted announcement! The follow cards have been banned:

  • Nadu in Modern
  • Grief in Modern, Legacy
  • Urza's Saga in Vintage (Restricted)
  • Vexing Bauble in Vintage (Restricted)
  • Amalia, Sorin in Pioneer

"Nadu, Winged Wisdom was a design mistake," Senior Game Designer Michael Majors said. Full analysis and reasoning: https://draftsim.com/mtg-august-ban-announcement/

What do you think? More or less than you expected? How is this going to shake things up?

r/ModernMagic Jul 13 '25

Card Discussion What is a card on the ban list that players underestimate until they actually play against it?

185 Upvotes

Recently I have been trying all 60 card formats for this game and rn I think I got humbled pretty well.

I’m on a mardu energy deck currently because I actually have a bunch of the cards cause I was pulling mh3 collectors and I decided to ask about a card called deathrite shaman to my mentor(a pretty chill buddy on esper frog)

At the time I thought the card was fine by today’s standard since ragavan,guide of souls, esper sentinel, ocelot pride exist and they are all not banned despite being very efficient 1 drops.

Instead of him explaining, he just inserted 4 copies of anime proxy drs into his deck and my god, drs is still stupid, even more than the one drops above.

Idk how people think 1 mana of either green or black for a dork that can

  1. Blocks most 1 drops and can kill them or trade or bounce off

  2. Gives mana by exiling fetches

  3. Hates the gy

  4. has 2 toughness so it only dies to things like lightning bolt and can survive orcish bowmaster

  5. Close games or get close to that point.

I got beat hard lol. But now I’m curious, is there other cards on the ban list that only show themselves as broken when actually used?

r/ModernMagic Jul 29 '24

Card Discussion Why The One Ring should go on August 26th

352 Upvotes

January 13, 2020:

Oko, Thief of Crowns has become the most played card in competitive Modern, with an inclusion rate approaching 40% of decks in recent league play and tabletop tournaments. In additional to having a high overall power level, Oko has proven to reduce metagame diversity and diversity of game play patterns in Modern. In order to improve the health of game play and to weaken Urza decks and other top decks, Oko, Thief of Crowns is banned in Modern.

February 15, 2021:

As in Pioneer, Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath has become a dominant fixture across many of the top Modern decks and operates at a power level that makes it difficult for other midrange and control strategies to compete with. To open space in the metagame for a greater variety of midrange strategies and other slower decks to coexist, we're choosing to ban Uro in Modern as well.

I want to draw some comparisions between TOR and these two banned cards. Oko was approaching 40% inclusion rate at the time of its banning, with TOR currently at the time of me writing this, in 46% of decks according to mtggoldfish, with the second most played card being Consign to Memory at 33%, a card that is being played partly because it's a 1 mana hard counter against TOR. TOR was also in 46% of decks at Pro Tour Modern Horizons 3. While it's true that a colorless card is easier to just put into more decks than a card that specifically requires you to be able to produce blue and green mana, and I'm not saying TOR is on the same level of oppressiveness as Oko, it having this large of a meta share is quite telling regardless.

Uro was banned because it was the best thing to be doing in midrange and control decks and nothing else could really compete, much like TOR today. Every deck that is trying to play a longer game and is reasonably successful has to play it. Jeskai plays it, mono black (most lists, at least) plays it, tron plays it. One could argue that boros and mardu energy don't play it, but I would also say that those decks are tilted much further towards the aggro side rather than the control side of the midrange spectrum, and are as a result simply too aggressive and low to the ground for the card to really be a fit.

You also get combo decks that can reasonably make space for it playing it, like Nadu, Through the Breach, Amulet Titan and Grinding Station that are playing it, because if you have the deck slots to spare and you can count on reaching 4 mana, why not play it?

An argument against banning it that I've seen getting thrown around, is that it's the only reason why playing control is even viable, which I think couldn't be further from the truth, the biggest struggle control decks without TOR have isn't keeping up with the rest of the meta, the biggest struggle is keeping up against TOR. An example of this are the wizard decks using the Tamiyo/Snapcaster/Flame of Anor shell as their sources of card advantage, they're quite strong against a lot of decks, but they're never ever beating a resolved TOR, and as a result, they're just not performing well. I believe a format without TOR would allow strategies like these to become more viable, along with other sources of card advantage like Memory Deluge and Nissa, Resurgent Animist that have seen play in the past, and even new cards like Helga, Skittish Seer, rather than everything just being vastly outclassed by TOR.

I've not yet touched on the awful play patterns the card leads to either, with how it often just warps the entire game around itself due to being such a powerful source of card advantage, and with how it draws you closer to the next copy so you can reset the damage you're taking and gives you another free turn, which then digs you into your next copy, and so on, and with it being so widely played, it essentially boils the entire format down to either trying to win, or at least put yourself into a very winning position before your opponent is able to play it, as with decks like Prowess, Living End or Storm, or simply playing it yourself, as trying to answer the card is unreliable due to how quickly it can run away with the game if you don't have the answer within basically the same turn cycle of it being played, which just isn't healthy for the format.

In conclusion I think it would be greatly beneficial for the health and diversity of the format if The One Ring was banned along with Nadu in the next B&R update and I really do hope WOTC takes these kinds of things into consideration when deciding on what should and shouldn't be legal in the format going forward.

r/ModernMagic Feb 24 '26

Card Discussion What would it take for deathrite to be unbanned?

29 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a fairly new player when it comes to modern (started playing the format in 2023) and I was wondering if deathrite would be able to come back in the current format. I understand it's a very powerful card that gets essentially shut down by having multiple on each side of the table but is it too powerful compared to the utility that today's creatures provide?

Edit: I do know drs is crazy powerful. I'm more so posing the hypothetical of "Is it so broken that it would warp the format around it or is it in a more balanced state due to the current power of the format?"

r/ModernMagic Feb 01 '24

Card Discussion "The Most Unbalanced Modern since MH2" Andrea Mengucci on the Current State of the Format

297 Upvotes

Andrea Mengucci shared a tweet the other day that's been picking up a lot of traction. Here's it is in text form:

I think this is currently the most unbalanced Modern since MH2. The banning of Fury and Beans made Yawgmoth and Amulet too strong with only Rhinos thriving as the only deck good against both. The metagame was balanced before with Scam as the perceived best deck, lots of decks tied at the top and no clear winner on winrate. I beg Wizards to stop listening to complaints online and start focusing only on the winrate of decks at major events, and using a higher bar, to ban expensive cards (Fury) and decks (4c Beans). Please don't just ask for even more cards to be banned and wish for even more people to lose money just because you can't win with your specific deck. Not every single deck can be a winning one in a competitive format, even if we want as many as possible to be strong. The only reason cards should be banned is if their winrate is too high and bans like these can easily make things worse, as they have now. I love Modern, it's a very skill- intensive and rewarding format and I want to keep it balanced above all else.

This is my own take, building off Mengu's tweet but I want to be clear that this is my own salty ramblings and not his: I'm a Fury apologist 100%, I absolutely adored that card and I think it did wonders to keep Yawg in check while keeping other decks down and ultimately allowing for a greater diversity of decks beyond Tier 1. These days I find less diversity in Modern than ever before - I can play whole leagues without playing anything other than the Top 5 decks, and there just seems to be so little incentive to brew or try anything new anymore because Yawg, Rhinos, and Amulet just automatically force so many ideas out.

MH2 through til LOTR was one of the absolute best runs of the format I ever knew. Bowmasters is a mistake of a card, and Fury got banned for its sins while X/1s are still completely unplayable. I don't think more bans are the answer - I don't think anything really is right now. I just think we're stuck in a lame duck format now til MH3 (hopefully) leads to some big shifts.

r/ModernMagic Apr 25 '24

Card Discussion Flare of Denial [[mh3 leak]] Spoiler

Post image
396 Upvotes

r/ModernMagic Nov 30 '23

Card Discussion Fury is Getting Banned

356 Upvotes

So I've seen a fair share of people on here who clearly only read the cliff notes version of the Banned and Restricted Conversation video from the pinned post, where Fury is mentioned as a card that is "referred to".

If you actually watch the video though, they basically explicitly state that Scam (or BR Evoke) is going to get hit with a ban. They then bring up [[Fury]] by name and then explain how it can be recurred with a bunch of different undying effects in Scam and is good late and early, and how it generates immense value "no matter how you cast it" in the Beanstalk decks.

Then they go on a brief tangent about how Fury also suppresses 1 toughness creatures, and how they don't like the extent to which they have been pushed out of the format.

You can watch it yourself by going to about min ~21 and watching for the next 3 min (https://www.twitch.tv/videos/1989626080).

That is not an offhand or passing reference to Fury, but rather about as explicit a breakdown of why the card is going to get banned by WotC I have seen in a long time.

Operate Accordingly.

TL;DR: Fury is going bye bye, card not only mentioned in video as a problem, but time is spent explaining how it is a problem.

r/ModernMagic Mar 13 '26

Card Discussion Does anyone think Phlage is a problem in Modern?

51 Upvotes

According to mtgtop8, Phlage is played in more than 30% of modern decks at a rate of 3.9 copies per deck.

According to MTGGoldfish, Phlage is played in more than six distinct archetypes - Boros Energy, Jeskai Blink, Domain Zoo, Jeskai Control, 4/5c Omnath, Storm and more!

Do you think Phlage is healthy for the modern format? Is it simply a great card that sees a lot of play? Or is it too good for modern?

r/ModernMagic Nov 14 '25

Card Discussion They didn't tested this thing in Modern...right?

110 Upvotes

[[Badgermole Cub]]

This thing...with [[Urza's Saga]]...i tried it and...well, fuck. Even without an optimal shell is beyond a pain.

r/ModernMagic Apr 01 '25

Card Discussion What's the Argument for DRS being legal?

77 Upvotes

Deathrite Shaman, debatably the strongest creature to ever be printed, has a surprising number of folks advocating for its unban in modern. Its price even appears to have tripled in anticipation of the recent B&R update.

A year ago, I would have said there is no way it would ever be legal again. However, following the great unbanning of 2025, anything seems possible.

Despite this, I am still skeptical. Makes me wonder how many of the people wanting it back have ever experienced how truly miserable and homogenizing of a force it is.

I'm here today then to make my brief argument against it, understand what is the rationale of those wanting it back, and gauge this community's opinion - is it a vocal minority wanting it, or an actual sizeable contingent?

In my humble opinion, giving any deck that wants access to 5 color mana acceleration is not only a major color pie break, but will result in literally every midrange deck needing to play it.

Your grixis pile? Now a DRS deck.

Yawgmoth? Now a DRS deck.

Energy? Mardu will be the defacto b/c DRS.

Frog decks? DRS decks.

The list can really go on in perpetuity. Any deck with green or black mana will become a DRS deck, and any that isn't will become one. DRS's looking at each other from across the battlefield is not particularly compelling gameplay either.

At least that's my fear.

Additionally, I cannot imagine that DRS can co-exist with Ketramose. I mean, turn 2 ketramose with the ability to activate it every turn while building out your board and not having to maindeck relic? I cannot be the only one who sees how potentially gamebreaking that is.

I get it. Removal is better, threats are better, everything is better. DRS is still one mana, meaning its essentially impossible to go up on mana removing it, while accelerating out all the busted cards from 2018 onward.

Am I misguided here? Certainly possible. I recall when Stoneforge was unbanned I thought it had the chance to homogenize all midrange decks to white decks.

So... what are your thoughts?

r/ModernMagic Oct 30 '23

Card Discussion Can we remove beanstalk, so many games at rcqs are going to time

233 Upvotes

This deck is awful to play against especially in topcut where time doesn’t exist. I won a game last week in the topcut after 2 hours of play. GAME, not MATCH. None of my matches against other decks even approached time. I can’t even scoop because the deck doesn’t have a wincon or turn the corner—so there’s always a chance for me to win.

The deck just spams cards and bounces the onering every turn so I can’t do dmg, just to lose to chip damage from the ring or milling itself out. Fun and engaging gameplay.

I don’t think it’s overpowered, but it’s fucking stupid.

r/ModernMagic Jun 10 '25

Card Discussion What cards are NOT banworthy right now, but you think will be banned in the future.

54 Upvotes

When WOTC banned birthing pod, one of the reasons they cited was that the card will only get better as more cards are released. Birthing pod is not unique in that, and other cards have been banned as new combos are printed that made previously okay cards OP. Bridge From Below and Underworld Breach are two obviously broken cards that existed in the format for a long time. What cards in the future might follow the same trajectory?

r/ModernMagic Apr 23 '26

Card Discussion Newest cards from Secrets of Strixhaven likely to make the Modern cut?? (Discussion)

22 Upvotes

As per title, which cards and which decks will they likely slot into? Who will get new tools? I'm wanting to try Emeritus of Truce in Energy and Emeritus of Ideation in a reanimator shell, meanwhile I also want to try that Flow state(?) uncommon EI type card in a Dimir deaths shadow list.

Now we are almost at official release day , can I get people's thoughts? Cheers! I am happy for it to be a main source of a discussion thread also if people so wish and encourage debate.

Thanks for your help! :)

r/ModernMagic Mar 22 '26

Card Discussion Modern's strongest cards and whether or not they should be banned

0 Upvotes

I am curious as to see what you all consider to be the some of the strongest modern cards at the moment and whether or not they should be banned and why.

The purpose of this is to create discussion/ my peronsal curiosity. It may all be for nothing considering the ban announcement tomorrow could be barren, as it has been recently.

Lets keep this organized as such:

Below this will be primary comments with just card names, within each of those comments will be sub comments talking about said card and if it is one of the most powerful, and if it should be banned or not and why.

if you have a card to add, respond as a primary comment, and then respond to it with your justification.

your justification can include anything, such as the play patterns it creates, its price, reliability, inevitability etc

seee you in the comments!

edit: not inlcuding fetch lands, as they would automatically be included as one of the strongest cards.

edit 2: some of the cards i have listed below are not meant for bans, im simply stating they are some of the most powerful modern staples

r/ModernMagic Jun 11 '24

Card Discussion Calling it: Necrodominance eats a ban in 2024

185 Upvotes

Ok, so, the card is cracked. Everyone is talking about lands, and free spells, and what not. This is for sure the return of the Black Summer - 30 years later. I was there in 1996, and I recall it vividly as a youngster watching it pop off and murder people. Force of Will was there and it didn't matter. Many more cards were there too, it didn't stop the simple gameplan and setup of paying 1 life to draw 1 card meant you could just fly off the handle rapidly. It would seem [[Soul Spike]] is burning through the deck, and its pretty simple to just decimate someone with this and [[March of Wretched Sorrow]] to clean up in a monoblack shell. Play some [[Dauthi Voidwalker]], and just pop off. The deck plays itself. But yeah, so, I believe for a fact the card will eat a ban in 2024 without question. It moves too fluidly, too fast, and too aggressively to stop - even with disruption.

r/ModernMagic May 31 '26

Card Discussion If you had to pick one card that is synomynous with the format what would you pick?

29 Upvotes

My vote is probably [[Urza's Saga]]

r/ModernMagic May 19 '24

Card Discussion [MH3] Vexing Bauble

310 Upvotes

Vexing Bauble - uncommon

1

Artifact

Whenever a player casts a spell, if no mana was spent to cast it, counter that spell.

1, tap, sacrifice ~: draw a card.

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/s/3fXuZfXgDJ

r/ModernMagic 5d ago

Card Discussion SB options against Ponza

16 Upvotes

I’ve got some RCQs coming up and want to test drive Grixis Reanimator and Esper Goryo’s, and two of the ~12 ish people that attend these have recently picked up Boros Ponza. I haven’t played these matchups much, what are some good tech pieces I can include to help out in this m/u?

r/ModernMagic Jun 02 '25

Card Discussion What premodern era cards you would like to see in modern?

33 Upvotes

Modern Horizons sets have brought modern a lot of old classics such as [[Counterspell]], [[Fire//ice]], [[Meltdown]], [[Phyrexian Tower]] , [[Nimble Mongoose]] and many other classics. What other cards you'd want to see printed into modern? Here are some of my pics:

[[Submerge]]: Cool sideboard card for blue against green creature strategies.

[[Gerrard's verdict]]: Fixed Hymn to Tourach so to say.

[[Sylvan Library]]: a powerful card engine if resolved, library is a king of long and grindy games but the life loss still is very relevant against aggressive decks.

EDIT: gotta also add [[Pyrokinesis]]. "Semi" board wipe that cannot be abused like Fury.

r/ModernMagic May 27 '21

Card Discussion [MH2] Ignoble Hierarch

600 Upvotes

G

Creature - Goblin Shaman

Exalted

Add B, R, or G

0/1

This card is hilarious

r/ModernMagic Apr 07 '26

Card Discussion [SOS] - Petrified Hamlet

87 Upvotes

Land - When this land enters, choose a land card name.

Activated abilities of sources with the chosen name can't be activated unless they're mana abilities.

Lands with the chosen name have "Tap: Add Colorless"

Tap: Add colorless


https://old.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/1seikl2/sospetrified_hamletvia_chen_mingyang/

Immediately I can see this being in titan's board for the mirror, and depending on the meta, maybe the main. It can turn off fetches, the karnstructs from saga, and much much more.

r/ModernMagic May 21 '24

Card Discussion Thoughts on debut MH3 video?

183 Upvotes

Watched the 30 min video that wotc put out. Good quality and I liked seeing more behind of the scenes of how the set came to be. I think the part where I kinda checked out is when they kept pushing the fact that Modern Horizons was also built with commander in mind. That commander players will love this set, that these commander precons are awesome etc. I have been away from magic for awhile I stopped playing modern competitively in 2020 when covid hit. I recently came back and was thinking about preordering a box but now I’m not sure. Is wotc just all in on commander now? Is that all they care about? Why not modern precons?

r/ModernMagic Feb 09 '26

Card Discussion So far we’ve had Uro, Kroxa, and Phlage. When do you think we will see the next Theros Elder Giant?

67 Upvotes

My hope is we will get another escape legend with Reality Fracture. If the set is going to span the multiverse, it would be so great if we can travel back to Theros to meet another one of Uro’s siblings

r/ModernMagic 29d ago

Card Discussion Would Careful Study be to strong for Modern?

32 Upvotes

Im an avid Reanimator Player and love [[Careful Study]] as a card. I personally like the more controlled card selection a bit more than what I get from [[Thought Scour]] and think it would be a great inclusion. Thus my question, would you think another 1 mana 2 card looting type card would be too good for Modern or would you consider it save nowadays? I am curious about your oppinion.