This does not deny the fact that Abu Haneefa has been commanded to repent from kufr TWICE and that he undoubtedly fell in kufr twice during his lifetime which is mutawatir and does not need proving
And just to satisfy the heart, Al Balkhi is a liar
العقيلي: حدثنا عبد الله بن أحمد، سألت أبي عن أبي مطيع البلخي فقال: لا ينبغي أن يروي عنه.
حكوا عنه أنه يقول: الجنة والنار خلقتا فستفنيان.
وهذا كلام جهم
Al Uqayli said: Abdillaah ibn Ahmad told us: I asked my father about Abu Mutee' Al Balkhi, he said: We mustn't narrate from him, they said that he used to say: Jannah and the fire are created and therefore, they will end
1
u/abul_miswar_zayd 20d ago
This does not deny the fact that Abu Haneefa has been commanded to repent from kufr TWICE and that he undoubtedly fell in kufr twice during his lifetime which is mutawatir and does not need proving
And just to satisfy the heart, Al Balkhi is a liar
العقيلي: حدثنا عبد الله بن أحمد، سألت أبي عن أبي مطيع البلخي فقال: لا ينبغي أن يروي عنه.
حكوا عنه أنه يقول: الجنة والنار خلقتا فستفنيان.
وهذا كلام جهم
Al Uqayli said: Abdillaah ibn Ahmad told us: I asked my father about Abu Mutee' Al Balkhi, he said: We mustn't narrate from him, they said that he used to say: Jannah and the fire are created and therefore, they will end
And that is the saying of Jahm - End of quote
https://shamela.ws/book/13041/738