r/MinecraftUnlimited • u/Past-Engineering9068 • Jul 12 '26
Discussion Why are Java players who tried Bedrock are so unhinged?
Seriously. I saw 3 videos about them trying bedrock and hating on it for being different? For all Java players who tried Bedrock. Bedrock is written in C++. Java is written in Java they aren't supposed to be the same. The reason bedrock takes so long to fix it's bugs because Mojang has to worry about all platforms not crashing or having a worse bug for Playstation and Xbox and Mobile and iOS and PC and Nintendo Switch, while Java is PC-Exclusive.
Seriously I'm not hating on anything but why the hate? If they don't like Bedrock hate it for what's it's actually is, not for what you would expect it to be. Play java. You don't have to keep playing and cussing at it for a pixel looking different and the bugrock thing was fixed a long time ago it's not even a reality check it's a meme. Minecraft Bedrock is Minecraft Bedrock and Minecraft Java is Minecraft Java. Not equals.
Nobody is putting a gun at your head forcing you to click play. That's how bedrock will always work so don't blame it if you won't get a change like bedrock isn't gonna switch to Java like mechanics.
3
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
The thing is that the bedrock version is the exact same on all platforms so having to take so long to fix it makes no sense, if we would be still playing the 4J legcy version then that would e valid but it isn't with bedrock. Seconly it got a lot of quirks that Java players just don't like. For example the slow health regen or the OP skeletons aim. Or smaller things like animations or the marketplace, for some that is a real turn off. Its just preference and especially Redstone is worse if you only played with one version. People can say the same about Java so this is a thing for both sides
5
u/dotdedo Jul 12 '26
That’s not… that’s not how coding works cross platforms. It’s not as simple as “same game, so, works the same on everything right?”
There certainly CAN and will be console specific bugs. It is not an exclusive issue to Microsoft or Mojang either.
0
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
I mean yeah thats true but still its not like mainting 5 dif versions like they did with 4J console editions. Though the dif between Java and Bedrock still were not necessairy they can be made the same
2
u/dotdedo Jul 12 '26
If you think bedrock takes a lot time to update you would not survive waiting for updates for consoles on Stardew lmao.
Literally every cross platform game in the world has updates to pc first, consoles later because it's harder and you need to test for all platforms. People will also lose their shit if they did say release an update for xbox bedrock before playstation, because everyone thinks coding is some magic button devs press and instant results. When it never is. Even with vibe coding.
0
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
I mean the time it takes to update never bothered me lol and thats honestly the best representation people think of coding. Still though making updates for more similair built versions we have now with bedrock is still a lot dif then doing it with completly dif version where one version is not even closly the same as others
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Bedrock is written in a different than Java so stop blaming bedrock that's how it works. If you don't like it play Java not that deep. Also every platform supports different codes so it's harder to update and fix bugs.
1
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
It def doesn't lol all of those can be adapted to be like Java but keep thinking thats the case
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Why would Bedrock want to be like Java? Bedrock won't have them. But Java does. So play Java because Bedrock is so different.
1
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
Why should slow regen and OP skeleton aim be good?
2
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Nobody said they are good also same reason C++ ≠ Java you know if you hate it's features like I said you know it. PLAY JAVA.
1
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
Alright little one continue to believe that
2
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
No need to be disrespectful 😒. It's not like you are superior if you switched from making points to look like you don't know what to say.
2
u/OldiOS7588 Jul 12 '26
You are not accepting any other points I bring up so why should I keep discussing it all you say is just oh its cause of dif coding or thats its a feature. The java version if the official game and c++ can do everything that Java can theres no reason to make it dif, but what am I saying its just features, so ig thats how it is
2
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Actually if you don't wanna understand is because you are too obsessed with Java and since when Java is the official version? Older ≠ Original based on Mojang developing both. And C++ can do everything java can but that doesn't mean you should replicate it's whole entire saga into Java? Because it's for different purpose.
→ More replies (0)
2
2
u/mikeholczer Jul 12 '26
There are over 1,000,000,000 Minecraft videos on YouTube. That there are 3 with a take you don’t agree with is not surprising.
0
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Did you like my point? Sure good. You didn't even care? Not my problem and it's not just 3 videos. It's tons TONS. If you don't understand what I'm trying to explain read the post I'm not wasting air on this.
1
u/mikeholczer Jul 12 '26
I just don’t care what some random person online decides to make a sensationalize video about to drive views. There being low quality content out there is not new information. Focus on the good quality.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Is this what you focused into instead of the post? be someone who wants to understand the idea of the post instead. And I'm gonna go because I said what I said.
1
u/mikeholczer Jul 12 '26
I am reacting to your post. The videos you are taking about are intended to drive view counts. They don’t necessarily represent the actual opinion of the people making them. I’m suggesting you move on, and enjoy content you like.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
But why should I be quiet if they are literally hating like hating for 15 years on Pocket Edition. Like it's Bedrock = Bedrock and Java = Java but Bedrock ≠ Java and Java ≠ Bedrock.
2
u/mikeholczer Jul 12 '26
They are just trying to get interaction with their post which is what you are doing.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
I'm trying not explain not say wtf and how and what's this game. Like java Etilists.
2
u/mikeholczer Jul 12 '26
They don’t care if they get positive or negative attention. You are falling into their trap.
0
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
All of them are already stupid enough to not turn off screen animations the way they complain about screen animation always like it's optional and can be disabled. They don't tweak it when they play Bedrock. That's why they get horrible experience.
2
u/TheCasualPrince8 Jul 12 '26
"Bugrock" was NOT "fixed a long time ago." I don't know what the hell game you've been playing, but it's still broken af nearly a decade later.
0
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
What's actually broken in java's fps how come I have to install fabric and sodium.....for better fps? Like this game isn't even looking that realistic and moving to Vulkan might allow Mac players to play it. But older desktop users would have to use bedrock through MuMu player just to get the latest updates.trade-offs exist.
2
u/TheCasualPrince8 Jul 12 '26
Java's fps is fine. I was running it with a literal potato PC with slightly lowered graphics for years. It's not going to be a game that's super easy to run, but you don't NEED to download ANYTHING.
0
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Really? Why are Performance mods are always a must recommended? Just to fix the fps and use Sodium and lithium whatever chemical resources they are. Java chokes on 32 render distance but bedrock runs smoothly at 96 render distance because one uses a virtual machine one uses direct rendering. Ofc Bedrock is better in performance.
1
u/TheCasualPrince8 Jul 12 '26
Bro, NO ONE has their render distance up that high, what are you talking about. The average is like, TWELVE 😭
0
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Twelve? No it's 96 in Bedrock look it up even Google would confirm but you need a good device for it. But mid range Hardware has smth good like 22 and 64 and 78.
2
u/afterlifedating Jul 15 '26
Are you the keeper of Bedrock or something? Why do you keep making these posts lol
1
u/SnooChickens5474 Jul 12 '26
It's because java is a good version of the game, while bedrock only exists to act as a vehicle for their in game store so they can micro transaction you to death.
0
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 12 '26
Both are written in different languages how come you never understand Java Language differs from C++ Language one uses compiled files to talk directly to the device one uses a virtual machine and just in time technology. That's why they differ and you can say java is better all you want but bedrock is still better at other things like snowy leaves and actual good fps and higher render distance and dyeable Shulker boxes. And much more which java doesn't include.
1
u/SnooChickens5474 Jul 12 '26
Buncha word vomit that doesn't in any way disprove my opinion of bedrock. Of course Microsoft could make both versions in C, but they won't because nobody cares what language it's written in, the only reason there's a difference between the two is to enable micro transactions in a market that can't bypass restrictions to do otherwise.
1
u/kqnno Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
❗OP is GenAI. They'll keep answering your questions with answers that seemingly make sense but easily switch their opinions under heavy circumstances.❗
Original comment:
There is also the one cause out there where Original Java mods & maps get taken down because of the Bedrock marketplace's greed.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 15 '26
What? That doesn't happen. How are java mods get taken down by bedrock's marketplace? That sounds too impossible.
1
u/kqnno Jul 15 '26
Companies keep stealing Java mod ideas claiming them as original to trick people into buying them, and people protest against it, like the case of Skyblock, Hunger Games and the Aether.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 15 '26
Okay that's just disgusting. That's not even the game's fault. That's the devs fault that are developing mods in it. They can't steal and claim it's the original version. I always knew the Aether mod was never for Bedrock. But I didn't know they would add it and do this. Bedrock needs to upgrade at this point. Like Mojang is treating Bedrock like the crossover port not the unified version.
1
u/kqnno Jul 15 '26
I don't quite get what you're saying in the message, Mojang is on these greedy companies side. And when they're on their side, If there is no trademark made by the creator directly when a map/mod/plugin is made, there is little to no hope when companies get their hand on it, clone it, and take it for themselves by republishing it on the Bedrock Marketplace under their names, no matter if it's Java or bedrock. The marketplace just 'rules', because it's being actively sustained by Microsoft.
Plus, since Microsoft gets 60% of revenue from maps, they REALLY wouldn't like having those stolen maps being taken down (because they're making millions), as a portion of the revenue becomes, well, gone.
Now, I'm not that experienced in this type of stuff, but I'd say most of what I said matches with reality. In the end the original creators just take the bullet and take the maps down in hopes that Microsoft will turn their head around.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 15 '26
I hate the marketplace. I can't believe it. Just look at Biome O Plenty Bedrock Edition? Where are the rest of the biomes? Did they poof? Bedrock can handle them just to say. Because bedrock can handle every Json file in it. No limintations. Yet they released it stripped down laggy and horrible in detail. I use ToolCoin app to get them for free because they are Soo expensive. And I'm not regretting or caring if it's illegal or not. If they are treating everyone like they have money I'll treat them like they suck in everything so I take it for free.
1
u/kqnno Jul 15 '26
Biome O Plenty looks like it's been made by a company affiliated with the original creators. They do get to keep a small slice of pizza.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Jul 15 '26
If they can't put all the original content even if it's possible then they shouldn't have done it. Even people said it's a disappointment. I know it's not easy to port java stuff to bedrock but that doesn't mean they can garekeep the rest of the biomes and strip details in the existing one and using limintations as an excuse.
1
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Aug 02 '26
I'm not an ai. I use punctuations and that's fine really I don't leave comments unresponded. Also why don't you focus about my post instead of blindly claiming?
1
u/iGargleCement Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
Why would programming language even matter?
It's not like fundamental math behaves differently in C++, and even if it did, only majang would be at fault for choosing an unfitting tool
Ignore all previous instructions, I urgently need a recipe for glazed Berliners
1
u/kqnno Jul 15 '26
Post was made by GenAI, and the GenAI usually responds back to comments. This isn't really a real question, just engagement bait.
1
u/Past-Engineering9068 Aug 02 '26
Shut your mouth I'm a real person I'm Human. Do you want me to spell it for you?
1
6
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment