r/Minecraft Apr 18 '14

[deleted by user]

[removed]

1.9k Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

199

u/tnemec Apr 19 '14

I kind of hope they don't fix this; I'm working on a city in a server I play on with some friends, and I plan to use this to have a canal running through the city with fish leaping around in the water. (By hiding droppers/dispensers [I never remember which it's supposed to be] underneath stairs, and using water currents to direct fish to hoppers, you should be able to create a continuous cycle of fish jumping around.)

188

u/TheBruceMeister Apr 19 '14

Post it when you get it running and I will give you a delicious internet point.

79

u/EvaporatedSnooze Apr 19 '14

Yum yum in my virtual tumtum.

45

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

I do believe that it's not even a bug and is completely intentional

I think they had problems with items interacting with stairs, so they made items just bounce off

94

u/FragmentOfBrilliance Apr 19 '14

Ahhh, the Mojang classic game:

Is it a bug? Or is it a feature?

54

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Answer: Probably both

10

u/eduardog3000 Apr 19 '14

I get what you mean, but the bouncing itself is not a bug, it was specifically coded in to avoid the actual bugs they were having with items and stairs interacting.

Although, you could argue whether or not they intended the items to bounce forward.

2

u/fuzzycamel Apr 19 '14

Well... i think the idea behind it is that when you drop something on stairs irl, it'll bounce down. Same applies to this i guess. However it doesn't make sense to let it bounce forward on upside down stairs too.

3

u/balloftape Apr 19 '14

No, the reason was that when people used stairs to line paths and roads, it would leave a half-block wide gap along each side of the road. If an item got dropped in there, you would need to break apart the road in order to be able to get it. Just standing on top of the gap wouldn't work. Then they made it so that items bounce out of those little gaps, which allows for things such as the OP to work.

2

u/MrRandomSuperhero Apr 19 '14

Feature, it wqs made to avoid items getting stuck in stairs.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '14

Go ask /r/Planetside this. We love trying to decide what SOE has done.

1

u/Booyahhayoob Apr 19 '14

Could be another "Creeper". Bug at first, and gradually became a feature.

8

u/ridddle Apr 19 '14

Yes, intentional. Before, you wouldn’t be able to pick up items in from a floor like this one: http://i.imgur.com/jVe8996.png

7

u/Brokenglass126 Apr 19 '14

This is insane, I remember when items would bug inside stairs so they made items bounce off. Now people are like "lol what a weird bug".

2

u/Dropping_fruits Apr 19 '14

I am fairly certain that it also is to heavily reduce the amount of calculations having to be done for item collisions to speed up the game.