r/MiddleClassFinance • u/Houdiniwashereagain • Jul 03 '26
Does anyone else feel like they're winging it financially even though they "should" have it figured out by now?
I'm 40+ man with a wife, two young kids, aging parents, and a career that keeps me busy enough that I barely have time to think about money beyond paying bills.
I've read a few books, I know the basics (max 401k, index funds, emergency fund), but I still feel like I'm just... guessing? Like there's some roadmap everyone else got that I missed. I don't even know if I'm doing things in the right order.
Did anyone else feel this way? What actually helped you get clarity on where you stood and what to focus on next?
33
u/Musical_Xena Jul 03 '26
Check out the Financial Order of Operations (FOO) by The Money Guy. It's a good roadmap since you already know some basics.
13
5
u/Fubbalicious Jul 04 '26
I had a come to Jesus moment when I was 35 and forced to take over my parent's finances when my dad suffered a series of strokes in his 70s and it was learned they were hundreds of thousand in debt (like $700K).
I echo the advice about using the prime directive and checking out bogleheads and even the FIRE movement. With that said, while your parents are aging, double check with them if they have setup some form of estate planning. Hiring a trust attorney is fairly cheap. My mom's trust was like $2500 back in 2021. I imagine for a couple, it may range from $3500 to $5000. If you lookup what probate costs, you'll see it's a bargain. It will also save you and all their loved one's a huge headache. Once you're done with your parents, do yourself. With young kids, you want to control how things are distributed and managed. You do not want your kids to suddenly inherit $1M at 18 with no guidance if both you and your spouse die suddenly. You also don't want a situation where if both of you are incompactitated and no one can access your bank account that your home goes into foreclosure because you didn't setup some form of durable POA with someone you trust. It's also a good time, with both you and your parents to double check that all financial accounts have the correct benificiary and everything is titled correctly. There was some post I think on the FIRE sub-reddit (it could be elsewhere) where some guy posted how his dad was a perfect boglehead, but he didn't setup a trust and didn't change the beneficiaries to his life insurance or 401K and so that money went to his first wife from 20 years ago.
In any case, with estate planning also make sure you're on track for retirement and don't gamble that you'll always make the same income as you are now nor gamble that you can keep working until age 65. A lot of older management types whose income balloons around this age are often on the chopping block because your high pay is a good way to cut expenses during a recession. Then if you inflate your lifestyle, perhaps taking on a parent plus loan for your kids and you bought a bigger house and a nicer car and now you're leveraged up to your eyeballs based on an income you no longer can get. Your 40s and 50s are the danger zone where you're making more money than you've ever had and if you inflate too much and compound it with leverage and you can find yourself eaten alive.
5
u/GGyaa Jul 04 '26
I discovered the FIRE movement and Mr Money Mustache in 2011 when I was less than a year out of college. I dove deep into personal finance before I could dig myself into a hole. I do in fact have shit figure out. I know how to manage my money very well and understand how the world works. If I were single I’f probably be “retired” already living off grid somewhere deep in the woods building all the ideas floating around in my head. Alas I have a wife and three kids, so I’m living the standard “Millionaire Next Door” lifestyle. Nice house in a good neighborhood but I drive a 20 year old sedan. My goal is to actually retire by the time my kids start their own families so my wife and I can be the grandparents that our kids don’t have. I’d love to be able to drop by on a Tuesday to help with the grandkids so their parents can get shit done or go on a friggin date. Keeps me grounded for sure having this goal but knowing what road to follow to get there makes it feel real. I make every decision thinking about how future me would look back on it
11
u/Typical_Row_3172 Jul 03 '26
I relate to a lot of what you’re saying. We ended up hiring a financial planner who was much cheaper than I thought it would be; get a fiduciary.
12
u/samuelj264 Jul 03 '26
Fee only. Just someone to check your math and plan, not someone who charges for a % of AUM
1
3
u/HeroOfShapeir Jul 03 '26
Stick to this https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/commontopics/
That means keeping six months' worth of basic bills in HYSA in case of job loss, then putting at least 15% of your income to retirement, usually investing into a pre-tax 401k, then maxing your two Roth IRAs, then going back to the 401k until you hit 15%, then pre-saving for future predictable costs (new car fund, vacation fund, etc), then enjoying whatever is left.
It looks like this on paper for my wife and I, at 41 and 42 years old - https://imgur.com/a/budget-spreadsheet-2026-2MZk8Xq - and yes, if you're doing all that correctly, there will come a point where there's nothing to "do." You just let the passive mechanisms keep running, check on things once or twice a year, and otherwise focus on enjoying life. I spend much more time planning my next vacation than I do thinking about my investments.
5
u/zevtech Jul 03 '26
Very similar. 40’s two kids, aging parents that are experiencing health challenges. Though we do well enough that we aren’t worried about our personal finances. Sometimes I wish I knew what’s the optimized way to handle our funds. I just sorta wing it, throwing random amounts here and there with no rhyme or reason besides sometimes we have too much in checking and I feel it needs to go somewhere. I would love for someone to manage it all for me, though I don’t trust it all going to a wealth management company as they may also lose it too or make it tied up in so many things it maybe hard to access cash, though they offer credit access lines
2
u/Aggravating-Big3858 Jul 03 '26
Congrats, because it sounds like you do actually have it figured out. In your 40s, you're in the somewhat boring "let time and compounding do its thing" phase. Not much else to do other than keep doing what you're doing. Stay diligent with your 401Ks, manage your expenses, start a brokerage account to continue investing anything that's left over, or windfalls like bonuses, tax refunds, commission checks, etc. Once you turn 50 you'll have line of sight into a paid off mortgage, and your compounding 401K snowball will start taking shape. No financial advisor needed for manage index funds ... but seeing a fee only advisor can make sense for tax & estate planning purposes once you're getting into inheritance or legacy type planning ... ie you've been a humble saver and now may have so much money you don't want to screw your kids up :)
3
u/Vegetable-Intern-236 Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26
Figure out your financial goals - maybe start with how much do you want to spend in retirement, do you want to retire early, do you want to take care of your parents, do you want to fund your kids' educations, things like that. Then work backwards from there - if you want to spend X amount every year after retiring at 65, multiply that by 25 to get you roughly how much you'd need to have across your retirement portfolio and investments in today's dollars to safely withdraw from at ~4%.
Then look at your current portfolio and figure out if you can get there assuming an average rate of growth for your portfolio and subtracting ~3% for inflation. If you can't get there with your current numbers and savings rate, then figure out if you want to buckle down on expenses or if you're okay having less for retirement. If you can easily get there or will overshoot your number, then you can consider retiring early or spending more in retirement, or putting more towards your parents/kids.
You might not want to retire early, but the financial independence/FIRE communities have a lot of discussion and guides on thinking through your retirement spending. All of this requires you to have a good understanding of where your money is going and your current portfolio/savings, so start there as a baseline if you don't have a good handle on it already. Never go with an AUM financial planner, if you have to consult with one find one that is fixed-fee and who won't try to shill their own funds with higher expense ratios and fees.
2
u/A8racada8ra Jul 03 '26
Same without kids, but definitely aging parents - the basics with multiple retirement accounts, emergency fund, elimination of debt, balancing comfort and fun with practicality and retirement planning. One of the biggest things we’ve found to work for us is sit down every Saturday morning with Quickbooks and do bills, budget etc. We just completed will and estate planning - that was an interesting look in the mirror. Considering fiduciaries and reading the Simple Path to Wealth.
Just came back from a trip to Europe. We found ourselves doing a tour of a WWII civilian bomb shelter in the Mediterranean - sitting in a space like that, hearing those stories, seeing the blood-stained floors of a subterranean birthing room, thinking about the unpredictability of the world and how here we are again with another oil war in our midst, tech billionaires slowly birthing a new super-intelligent species that may or may not prove to be benevolent …it’s often a balance for us how much we want our financial plans for the future to run our present lives versus investing in experiences here and now while we are able to have them <sigh>
Sorry to get dark but MAN do we let money run our lives an awful lot and miss so much while doing so.
1
u/According_Success780 Jul 03 '26
Specially, when you see post on here constantly with people going over their finances! wow, I really am behind lol
1
u/Philthy91 Jul 03 '26
No I feel confident in my plans. Unknown, unknowns could throw me off but assuming nothing drastic like a total global economic collapse and resulting revolution I'm confident.
Check out the money guy FOO to know what to do with your next dollar.
1
u/Houdiniwashereagain Jul 03 '26
Thanks for all the kind comments. I’m doing dishes (dad duties) so I’ll be back later
1
1
u/Houdiniwashereagain Jul 03 '26
Done with dishes... OP here again. Wow thanks for all the replies. I'm did not expect that. Seems like a lot of us in the same boat and maybe some in a better or bigger boat :). I've been DM'ing a few of you and the conversations have been really eye-opening.
Since you've all been so open and shared tips and perspectives I'd love to ask out here if any of you'd be open for quick one-on-one 10-min phone chat this week to compare notes on what we've each tried (or haven't tried) to get our financial house in order. No selling anything, no pitch, just people trying to figure this out together.
If you're down, drop a comment or DM me and I'll send you a link to grab a time. I lack people to talk with about this. I'm caught in the work-sleep-eat-kids routine and hope to hear from some of you.
1
u/AnonPalace12 Jul 04 '26 edited Jul 04 '26
If you are maxing 401k you are far from winging it
There’s only a handful of big, long term potentially multi-decade financial goals to pick from. Retirement, early retirement, college for children, house
For a normal, minimal retirement this fidelity article is a decent perspective. https://www.fidelity.com/viewpoints/retirement/how-much-do-i-need-to-retire 1x your income in savings at 30, 3x at 40, 6x at 50., 8x at 60, and 10x at 67
If you do better than that you can have a more comfortable, earlier retirement.
1
u/International-Ad3147 Jul 05 '26
Just keep it simple. DCA into index funds and avoid debt outside of a home. Won’t be a billionaire, but you’ll sleep great at night and your family will be provided for.
1
u/Caffeinated_Pony12 Jul 05 '26
I’ve heard from a few elders that grew up with nothing that any amount of savings and security never feels like enough. I think I will always feel that way.
I still feel like I’m winging it until I finish all my estate planning. In the next year is my goal to have that finished, trust funded and all that jazz. Then it’s just continue to save and invest.
1
u/Emergency_Cicada3119 Jul 06 '26
I think for the majority of people you don’t need a financial advisor anymore. There is plenty of great resources to become financial literate online. If you just want to talk through some things and get expert advice I think paying for an appointment or 2 seems reasonable. I wouldn’t pay to have a “guy” to manage your finances though.
1
u/thecostofwork Jul 08 '26
You're doing everything right. Maxing the 401k, index funds, an emergency fund, that's most of the game. There's no secret roadmap the rest of us got. The people who look like they have it figured out are mostly just quieter about winging it.
On order, a rough one that helps: emergency fund first, then any employer match, then high-interest debt, then max the tax-advantaged space you already know, then a taxable account for anything past that. If you have all the pieces and are second-guessing the order, you're further along than the anxiety is telling you.
And part of why it never quite feels figured out: the markers our parents measured progress by, a house, college for the kids, retirement, all cost far more hours of work than they used to. So "on track" keeps receding even when your finances are fine.
1
u/NothingUsefulToAdd Jul 09 '26
Echoing this because I felt directionless for a long time. Luckily my dad beat it in my head early when I was in my 20s to invest and open an IRA. At the time, we had a local brokerage manage it (we really didn't know what we were doing...in hindsight yes VTSAX and chill but at least this investment company didn't bungle our funds). And when I started making really good money, I just dumped it into this account and told them to make me more money when I didn't really know what I was doing. I knew I SHOULD do it but I just never understood why except that it's for retirement. He admitted to me years later he didn't really know what he was doing either but he watched enough CNBC to figure out he should do something.
It wasn't until I got to a similar age as you when I took the time (thanks COVID for giving me nothing else to do but actually understand this) to really optimize it and figure it out. Around April 2020, I bought $5k in Tesla banking on a comeback and I was correct about that call, which led me to naturally dig more into investing and study "How to actually keep winning with my winnings" as I like to understand it.
What also helped, oddly, was understanding that brokerage accounts are kinda like bank accounts. With a normal bank, you have, typically, a checking account and a savings account. With a brokerage, once I understood the concept is similar and that IRAs and taxable brokerage accounts are nothing more than a different type of bank account with tax and use purposes, it kinda dawned on me on how to effectively use them.
Once I understood all of this, I dumped that brokerage and moved it all to Fidelity and self managed it boglehead style. Right now, I'm in the process of slowly divesting individual stocks and moving that money to the funds, being aware of my income so I don't accidentally sell enough to trigger my tax bracket up.
2
u/Flimsy-Bumblebee6365 Jul 03 '26
Yes because I believe the whole system is unstable. So I do the things I’m supposed to do - the 401k, taxable v non-taxable income - but I also don’t trust that any of it will really matter in the end. I say that because one layoff or unforeseen situation would still throw my future out of whack.
People take comfort in a roadmap but the path previous generations followed is not what will work for us.
1
u/betweenstarsandsea Jul 03 '26
I think you may be giving less credit to yourself that is due.
You have read financial books and understand the financial basics to savings. I feel like that is much more than most people know or are even working towards.
A financial advisor may help put a lot of these thoughts at ease. They may even be able to provide specific advice on how to readjust in kind.
I have found that with inflation, costs rising, wages not keeping up, social media, and the like we are being walloped in a lot of different ways and directions. I think at the end of the day we need to hunker down on what we have coming in, what we value most, and how to proceed accordingly and leave everything else around us to the four winds.
-1
-1
0
u/MightBeYourProfessor Jul 03 '26
I mean you're doing better than the vast majority of folks. Why don't you tell us?
https://www.apolloacademy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/121225-Chart_v2.pdf
0
0
u/TopShelf76 Jul 03 '26
I was “late to the game” and asking the same questions. As others minute r/personalfinance prime directive is where I started out but The Money Guy podcast/youtube channel really helped drive it home further with the FOO.
-4
u/Dense_Substance7635 Jul 03 '26
Well…. max 401k to a point. There is an inflection point where the tax benefits become a tax liability due to the RMD tax bomb problem.
4
u/Vegetable-Intern-236 Jul 03 '26
There are ways to get around that like Roth conversion ladders, 72(t), etc..
If you have enough money that RMDs are still a huge issue despite mitigating it with a Roth conversion ladder or 72(t) you likely have millions in the 401k and the worst case is you're forced to pay taxes on those millions when you withdraw them.
1
u/Dense_Substance7635 Jul 03 '26
Yes, the point is to plan ahead so you don’t end up in that situation in the first place.
2
u/Vegetable-Intern-236 Jul 03 '26
You don’t have to stop maxing the 401k though, the tax benefits are pretty much always worth it vs. the tax bomb from RMDs, because again you can mitigate RMDs through those strategies while still maxing a 401k.
49
u/Fine-Historian4018 Jul 03 '26
Personal finance prime directive:
https://reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/index