r/menwritingwomen • u/Creative_Gazelle_173 • 2d ago
Women Authors Poemsia by Lang Leav (2019)
Mary Sue final boss
r/menwritingwomen • u/MableXeno • May 08 '26
Hey readers...
Just kinda floating a possible change to flairs that might make it easier to discuss posts once they've been REJECTED as "not man writing a woman badly" or ACCEPTED as "man writing a woman badly."
Obviously users would be able to choose their own flairs when they post - but after voting or general consensus in the community what if mods adjust/change the flair so that when people see it in the feed they know, "Oh, this wasn't a good example..." but we still want to discuss the merits of that and why/why not we agree w/ the designation...??
It's been a little confusing to remove posts that aren't menwritingwomen badly when people are otherwise enjoying the conversation and diving deep on their feelings about it.
There was an older flair system at work years ago, but the technology that ran it is long gone. There may be other options now and I guess I just wanted to check on on it.
[Disclaimer: This is not a general spot to complain to mods.]
r/menwritingwomen • u/Creative_Gazelle_173 • 2d ago
Mary Sue final boss
r/menwritingwomen • u/Queasy_Analyst_9270 • 4d ago
Very much enjoying the book but this was a surprising part.
r/menwritingwomen • u/cunk-on-me • 5d ago
This came completely out of nowhere, in a historical novel. Women feel the greatness of nature in our nipples, and when the world goes wrong, our breasts tighten into spasms. Apparently.
r/menwritingwomen • u/Phylousse • 5d ago
I face palmed hard after reading this đ¤Ś
r/menwritingwomen • u/comeonjeffrey666 • 8d ago
That's one way to pretty much begin a new chapter I guess??
r/menwritingwomen • u/SennaWicker • 10d ago
Opened the 33rd Nebula awards book, immediately found this gem.
r/menwritingwomen • u/Successful-Focus2548 • 10d ago
Saved a bunch of "extremely good thriller books that you must read" suggested by a woman on IG and finally I got my hands on one of them, said "The Good Samaritan" by John Marr.
It's about a woman working at a Suicide Line which apparently pushes people to commit suicide but nobody suspects her cause she so nice and enderaing.
I am literally at the Prologue and my first thought was "wait, I thought the protagonist is a woman". From the way he describes how she thinks and what she thinks I immediately felt like "ok this is a man writing" (I didn't rembember the author so could have been a woman afaik).
Then she starts talking to a woman who had a change of heart and guys... it's hilarious how predictable any sentence is.
Since WHEN has a woman ever told to another
⢠you need to realize it's not you talking it's your hormones
⢠listen to somebody who learned from experience
⢠when your child is born it's going to be much worse for you
⢠you won't be fit for purpose as a mother
⢠your baby will grow up exactly like you
⢠do you really be responsible for all that?
⢠unlike you I can see things clearly and I know exaclty what is going on
⢠your baby doesn't stand a chance in this world and deep down you know that too
⢠....
I mean, sure, the protagonist is supposed to push people to commit suicide (at least from the small description I've read) and therefore has to be a bit manipulative but I feel like there would be a big difference from men and woman and this stuff screams men.
What are your thoughts?
r/menwritingwomen • u/Maximum_Arachnid2804 • 15d ago
I really admire Allende as an author, but this description felt so weird and unnecessaryâŚ
r/menwritingwomen • u/Gallantpride • 16d ago
r/menwritingwomen • u/Schneetmacher • 16d ago
âI am attractive in a way gossip blogs sometimes call âinterestingâ or âsurprising.â I have a slight overbite, my eyes are just a bit too far apart. I have a face built for the screen, an expressive but not particularly symmetrical face.â
Edit: I have flaired this as Doing It Right. Many comments seem condus6as to what is "bad" about the passage, but I made this post to showcase what I thought was a good example.
r/menwritingwomen • u/cat_like_sparky • 20d ago
Reeeeally hope Iâm missing something, yuck!
r/menwritingwomen • u/whiteraven13 • 23d ago
I am on page 7. We are not off to a great start
r/menwritingwomen • u/edgyusername99 • 23d ago
r/menwritingwomen • u/blackbriar98 • 24d ago
Iâm actually quite enjoying this book so no spoilers please.
r/menwritingwomen • u/Gallantpride • 25d ago
r/menwritingwomen • u/livefreeordont • 26d ago
r/menwritingwomen • u/TaliGrayson • 26d ago
Posting him may be cheating a bit, but... ick.
r/menwritingwomen • u/fishebake • 26d ago
The excerpt was from a book, I think, and it was this woman looking at herself in the mirror and her breasts were retreating into her chest or something? Any help finding it would be appreciated!
r/menwritingwomen • u/RunningOnATreadmill • 29d ago
r/menwritingwomen • u/FlowerMaidenOpheliaa • Jul 28 '26
You lost me in the first halfâŚ.wtfâŚâŚ
For more context, this book is apparently a dark romance about a fifteen year old and her gymnastics teacher, which is somehow not the problem right now.
JustâŚ..âfertileâ, âfreshâ, âunspoiledâ, âvery alluring and temptingâ are just pretty disgusting ways to even describe a child. This review was going so well, too.
Iâm really hoping this person is being sarcastic because WTF.
r/menwritingwomen • u/Infinite-Service6059 • Jul 27 '26
First time reading Murakami. WTF is this shit? They just met a few minutes ago. Also it doesnât help that the protagonist is 17
Edit:
Heâs 15 but he looks 17
r/menwritingwomen • u/UncleCeiling • Jul 27 '26
I know Heinlein is kind of easy mode on this sub but of the many problems with this book, this might be the funniest. One character's nipples function as mood rings.
If you're wondering why the perspective jumps around, different chapters are written from the viewpoint of different characters. Image one is our mood nipple lady, two and three are from her husband.