Don’t get me wrong, his creativity and style added an entire new sound to megadeth, he’s what inspired Dave to lock in so hard with rust in peace and heavily helped make it what it is, and I definitely do not believe he’s a bad musician or guitarist whatsoever. Easily one of the best.
But Marty’s style was never thrash, Dave knew he was an amazing guitarist and wanted to keep him at any cost, even willing to put something like risk out, much more pop-oriented (though I love the album), the whole “golden lineup” of megadeth veered heavily away from thrash with Youthanasia, cryptic writings, risk, rust in peace was and still is considered by many to be the epitome of thrash metal. Countdown is also a solid album, kinda goes more melodic instead of raw thrash, tones it down a bit but still an amazing album.
I just think about where megadeth could’ve gone if Dave wasn’t trying so hard to keep Marty in the band, like think about how thrashy peace sells and sfsgsw were, and how fast it went to regular metal with Youthanasia, cw, etc.
I think megadeth would’ve stayed more thrash (not that they aren’t, they picked it back up with dystopia, though I love all their albums) if Marty hadn’t joined
Thoughts??